Loading...
1986 04 22 PCA G E N D A PLANNING COMMISSION - CITY OF LA QUINTA A Regular Meeting to be Held at the La Quinta City Hall, 78-105 Calle Estado, La Quinta, California April 22, 1986 7:00 p.m. 1. CALL TO ORDER A. Flag Salute 2. ROLL CALL 3. HEARINGS A. PLOT PLAN NO. 86-274, A request to construct three, two-story retail/office buildings totaling 10,216 sq.ft. on a .846-acre site; John Feld, La Quinta, Ltd., Partnership - Applicant. p rnll� 1. Report from Staff. 2. Motion for Adoption. B. AMENDMENT TO LAND USE ORDINANCE, "SPECIAL RESIDENTIAL" ZONE, A request for approval to amend the text of the Municipal Land Use Ordinance No. 348, by adding the new zoning classi- fication of "Special Residential" Zone; City Initiated. 1. Report from Staff. 2. Motion for Adoption. fy C. CHANGE OF ZONE NO, 86-122, A request for approval to rezone certain property located within the City as a "Special Residential" Zone in order to bring the zoning into �v compliance with the General Plan Land Use Plan; City uJN Initiated. 1. Report from Staff. 2. Motion for Adoption. 4. CONSENT CALENDAR A. PLOT PLAN NO. 86-279, a request to construct a single-family dwelling on the west side of Avenida Montezuma, 106' north- west of Calle Potrero; Rick Johnson Construction, Applicant AGENDA - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 2. 'L B. PLOT PLAN NO. 86-280, a request to construct a single-family dwelling on the east side of Avenida Vallejo, 150' north of Calle Ensenada; Rick Johnson Construction, Applicant. C. PLOT PLAN NO. 86-282, a request to construct a single-family dwelling at the southwest corner of Avenida Carranza and Calle Nogales; Marian Adair, Applicant. D. PLOT PLAN NO. 86-283, a request to construct a single-family dwelling on the west side of Avenida Carranza, 50' south of Calle Nogales; Marian Adair, Applicant. E. PLOT PLAN NO. 86-287, a request to construct a single-family dwelling on the east side of Avenida Diaz, 100' north of Calle Tecate; Pine Creek Development/James Laier, Applicant F. PLOT PLAN NO. 86-288, a request to construct a single-family dwelling on the east side of Avenida Velasco, 100' south of Calle Chihuahua; Pine Creek Development/James Laier, Applicant G. PLOT PLAN NO. 86-289, a request to construct a single-family dwelling on the east side of Avenida Ramirez, 50' north of Calle Monterey; Pine Creek Development/James Laier, Applicant. M. N. PLOT PLAN NO. 86-290, a request to construct a single-family dwelling on the east side of Avenida Ramirez, 150' south of Calle Arroba; Joel Colombo, Applicant. PLOT PLAN NO. 86-291, a request to construct a single-family dwelling on the east side of Avenida Ramirez, 100' south of Calle Arroba; Joel Colombo, Applicant. PLOT PLAN NO. 86-292, a request to construct a single-family dwelling on the east side of Avenida Villa, 200' south of Calle Monterey; Joel Colombo, Applicant. PLOT PLAN NO. 86-293, a request to construct a single-family dwelling on the west side of Avenida Juarez, 150' south of Calle Colima; Joel Colombo, Applicant. PLOT PLAN NO. 86-294, a request to construct a single-family dwelling on the west side of Avenida Juarez, 100' south of Calle Colima; Joel Colombo, Applicant. MINUTES of the regular meeting of March 25, 1986. MINUTES of the regular meeting of April 8, 1986. AGENDA - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 3. 5. BUSINESS A. PLOT PLAN NO. 86-295, A request to construct a 3052 sq.ft. bank building at the northeast corner of Avenida Bermudas and Calle Estado; Dan Edgar, Applicant 1. Report From Staff. 2. Motion for Adoption. 6. ADJOURNMENT. m u ITEM NO DATE /1 PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING RE: EMOTION BY: BRANDr DE GA-�( RMD VALLING THOiUSMURGH -SECOND BY: BRANDY GASPF�tII MDRAN VAMING THOIUZURGH DISCUSSION: ROLL CALL t CW!MISSIONERS: AYE NO ABSTAIN ABSENT PRESENT k BRANDT v/ DE GASPERIN v MORAN -/ WALLING THO[MURGH J�- UNANIMOUSLY ADOPTED: YES NO ITEM NO. DATE Z �6 }J PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING RE: MOTION BY:��DE GASPERIN MORAN MU'I'ING THORNBURGH SECOND BY: BRANDT DE GASPERIN MORAN� THORNBURGH DISCU^SSION: c ROLL CALL VOTE: CO"MSSIONERS: AYE NO ABSTAIN ABSENT PRESENT BRANDT - DE GASPERIN - MORAN - VULILING THORNBURGH - UNANIMOUSLY ADOPTED: YES NO IM MEMORAND CITY OF LA OUINTA 34. TO: The Honorable Chairman and Members of the Planning Commission FROM: Community Development Department DATE: April 22, 1986 SUBJECT: PLOT PLAN NO. 86-274 LOCATION: North Side of Avenida Montezuma; Between Avenida Navarro and Avenida Bermudas APPLICANT: John Feld, La Quinta Ltd., Partnership REQUEST: Approval to Construct Three, Two -Story, Retail/Office Buildings Totaling 10,216 Sq.Ft. on a .846-Acre Site BACKGROUND 1. General Plan Designations: a. Site: Village Commercial b. Surrounding Area: Village Commercial and High Density Residential to the northwest. c. Circulation Plan: Avenida Bermudas is a Secondary Arterial with proposed 88' right-of-way. 2. Zoning: a. Site: C-P-S (Scenic Highway Commercial) b. Surrounding Area: North - R-3*; South, East and West - C-P-S* 3. Existing Conditions The site is level, unimproved and barren of any significant vegetation. The roadways bordering the site to the south, east and west are paved, but otherwise unimproved around the site perimeter. A small residential structure exists contiguous to the northwest corner of the site. The Black Gold Gas Station is located directly across from the site, to the south. With the exception of the existing structure, the block is vacant; however, significant development exists in the surrounding area, primarily commercial -service related. STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 2. Existing facilities are available to provide telephone, electri- city and water services to the site. Sanitation service will be provided by a temporary, on -site, septic system, as sewerage facilities have not as yet been extended into the downtown area. A 10' utility easement runs through the center of the block. 4. Environmental Assessment An Environmental Assessment has been prepared as required by the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). The identified impacts which will be associated with this project are those usually associated with small scale infill development of urban- ized land. Incremental increases in public services are anticipated, and will be mitigated by payment of the required infrastructure fees and improvements to utility systems by the Applicant. Impacts associated with grading, construction, flooding and seismic hazards will be mitigated through adherence to municipal ordinances and building code requirements. The amount of traffic which will be generated could be substantial relative to existing conditions, and additional access points and the location of the site on a corner indicate that an incremental increase in traffic conflicts can be anticipated. However, these impacts will be mitigated with the improvements to be required of the Applicant. 5. Description of Request The Applicant proposes construction of three, two-story, office/ retail structures with a total floor area of 10,216 sq.ft. office space will be entirely on second floor areas, with retail below. Total net office space is 2920 sq.ft., while total net retail space (sales and display only) comes to 5647 sq.ft. Two of the buildings share the same floor plan and will simply be reversed in terms of their site location. The site is composed of seven individual lots merged into one parcel. Each of the three buildings will have outside stairwells to access the second floors. No interior lobby areas are designated. The building exterior will be medium texture stucco, with a mansard -hip style, flat concrete tile roof. Information requested on colors has not been submitted. Height of buildings 1 and 2 is 28.51, while building 3 will be approximately 26' high. Window glass shall be bronze tinted and framed in anodized bronze aluminum. The general building design is more modern than that existing in the downtown area. The site plan provides off-street parking as required, delineating 66 spaces. Circulation flow is via 3 access drives; 2 on Bermudas and 1 on Navarro. The buildings are set back 5' from ultimate right-of-way of all bordering streets. STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 3. 6. Comments from Other Agencies a. City Engineer: (1) Dedicate street/utility easements as required by City Engineer. (2) Construct necessary street improvements for Avenida Bermudas, Calle Montezuma and Avenida Navarro. (3) Prepared street improvement plans by Registered Civil Engineer to be submitted as required by City Engineer. (4) Submit a grading plan prepared by a Registered Civil Engineer prior to building permit issuance, in accordance with requirements of City Engineer. (5) Submit preliminary engineering geological/soils report with grading plan. (6) Drainage disposal to be provided as required by City Engineer. (7) Install all utilities prior to any street construction. (8) Payment of required plan check and inspection fees, and parcel merger required. (9) Applicant agrees to be included in City -Wide Landscape and Lighting District, with assessments to be done on a benefit basis as required by law. (10) Driveways shall be located so as to line up with opposite streets and existing driveways as per City Engineer. (11) Parking stall depth shall comply to City Standards. b. City Fire Marshal: (1) Fire Marshal required to set minimum fire flow for construction of commercial buildings. Minimum fire flow of 500 GPM at 2-hour duration at 20 psi residual operating pressure to be available prior to placement of combustibles on the site. (2) Required fire flow to be available from a Super hydrant (6" x 4" x 2-1/2" x 2-1/211) to be not less than 251, but not more than 165' from any portion of building measure- ment along approved vehicular travelways. STAFF REPORT - April 22, 1986 Page 4. PLANNING COMMISSION (3) Combination of on-site/off-site Super hydrants required as previously noted; flow to be available from any two (2) adjacent hydrants in the system. (4) Designated areas required to be maintained as fire lanes. (5) Portable fire extinguisher required as per NFPA, Pamphlet #10. (6) Install panic hardware and exit signage per Chapter 33 of the Uniform Building Code. (7) Required fire flow equals 3000 GPM. c. Community Safety Department: (1) Provide handicapped ramp on corner of Montezuma and Navarro. d. Building Division: No Comment. e. Coachella Valley Water District: (1) Area is subject to shallow flooding; located in Zone AO, two -foot depth. (2) District to furnish domestic water service in accordance with CVWD regulations. (3) Area to be annexed to CVWD Improvement District No. 55 for sanitation service. f. Southern California Gas Company: No Comment. g. La Quinta Chamber of Commerce: (1) Provide Chamber with information on leaseable space. h. Riverside County Sheriff: (1) Recommend above average lighting and equipment with vandalism resistent covers. (2) Incremental increase in called for services. Comments were requested, but not received from: * Imperial Irrigation District * General Telephone Company * Riverside County Agricultural Commission STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 5. STAFF COMMENTS AND ANALYSIS General Plan Consistency: The proposed office/retail use is consis- tent with the La Quinta General Plan's Land Use Element. The City is developing a downtown specific plan which will establish more finite policies and guidelines for permittable uses and design requirements. This proposal will more than likely be consistent with the specific plan and future area development with regards to land use. The General Plan requires, under Policy 3.26, that non-residential developments within 1000' of residential uses shall prepare a noise analysis. Because the General Plan provides flexible guidelines, Staff's interpretation of this policy is that the proposed project's scale, location and intensity would not warrant a detailed noise analysis. Because construction noise (temporary) appears to be the major consideration, adequate mitigation of these noise sources needs to be provided. Design of the building, as proposed, is generally consistent with the downtown development scheme. The construction is somewhat more modern than past approvals and existing structures. Due to the existence of offset intersections at Montezuma and La Fonda the amount of ultimate vehicular traffic which is anticipated, and the project's location at a major corner, Staff feels that only one drive- way access should be allowed to Avenida Bermudas, and it should be located so as to line up with the centerline of Avenida La Fonda, which intersects Bermudas to the east. Site Plan Considerations Zoning: The site is located in the C-P-S Zone, which does not require setbacks. The Applicant's site plan does provide 5' setbacks in addi- tion to the required right-of-way dedications along Avenida Bermudas, Navarro and Calle Montezuma. The setback areas are proposed to be fully landscaped. A deeper setback should be considered for building 2 (corner of Montezuma and Bermudas) in order to provide additional sight distance. Parking/Circulation/Landscaping Requirements: Based on the ratio of commercial and retail space proposed by the Applicant, this project requires 50 spaces. The site plan allows significant flexibility in the ratio of retail to commercial office space, providing 66 spaces. Some parking should be deleted to provide additional interior landscaping. The overall parking layout relies on car overhangs as part of stall depth. This requires an actual stall depth of 171. The site plan allows 161, and must be increased to provide the adequate depth. Landscaping in parking stall areas should be designed to consider the need for vehicle overhang space. Buildings 1 and 2 do not provide walkway STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 6. areas for pedestrians; this will create additional circulation conflicts with other traffic. The long rows of parking stalls along the northwesterly corner of the site should also incorporate land- scaped separation islands to provide shading and break the monotonous effect of the row. The site plan shows 12' sidewalks along Montezuma and Bermudas, with 9.5' sidewalk along Navarro. Some park- way area needs to be provided to allow for utility locations, street furniture, trees and other plantings, etc. A buffer wall needs to be provided along the north and west property lines which abut residentially zoned property, as required by the Municipal Land Use Ordinance. Appropriate permits will have to be secured from Imperial Irrigation District in order to construct parking within their easement, which runs north -south through the center of the property. The Applicant should also provide additional clearance for pedestrian movements along parking areas fronting on buildings 1 and 2. Only 1' of clearance exists along the north elevations of those buildings. CONCLUSIONS 1. The proposed retail/office use is consistent with the La Quinta General Plan designation of Village Commercial. 2. The proposed use is in compliance with the requirements of the C-P-S Zone. 3. The existing utilities are adequate or can be upgraded to provide for the needs of the proposed use. 4. The existing public roadways will adequately provide for traffic circulation. 5. The parking can be adequately provided by on -site spaces. 6. The style of architecture and proposed building materials are compatible with existing development in the area. 7. Approval of the project will not result in any significant environmental impacts. 8. Adequate noise mitigation can be attained through adherence to local ordinances. FINDINGS 1. The proposal is consistent with the La Quinta General Plan and Municipal Land Use Ordinance. 2. The general building design is consistent and compatible with existing and anticipated area development. STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 7. 3. There will be adequate utilities and public services to serve the project. 4. Approval of the project will not result in any significant adverse impacts on the environment. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Based upon the above findings, Community Development Department Staff recommends approval of Plot Plan No. 86-274 in accordance with Exhibits A, B and C, and subject to the attached conditions. PREPARED BY: Wallace Nesbit Planning Assistant WN:dmv Atch: Conditions of Approval Exhibits A, B and C APPROVED BY: C/:a Lawrence L. Stevens, AICP Community Development Director CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL THREE RETAIL/OFFICE BUILDINGS APRIL 22, 1986 JOHN FELD, LA QUINTA LTD. General 1. The development of the site and building shall comply with approved Exhibits A, B, and C as contained in the Community Development Department's file for Plot Plan No. 86-274, and the following conditions, which conditions shall take precedence in the event of any conflict with the provisions of the public use case. 2. Plot Plan No. 86-274 shall comply with the standards and require- ments of the La Quinta Land Use Ordinance unless otherwise modified by the following conditions. 3. This approval shall be used within two (2) years after final proceedings before the La Quinta Community Development Director; otherwise, it shall become null and void and of no effect whatsoever. The term "use" shall mean the beginning of substan- tial construction of permanent buildings (not including grading) authorized by this permit, which construction shall thereafter be pursued diligently to completion. 4. Prior to the issuance of a building permit for construction of any use contemplated by this approval, the Applicant first shall obtain permits and/or clearances from the following public agencies: * City Engineer * City Fire Marshal * Community Development Dept., Planning Division * Riverside County Environmental Health Dept. * Imperial Irrigation District Evidence of said permits or clearances from the above agencies shall be presented to the Building Division at the time of appli- cation for a building permit for the use contemplated herewith. Building Design 5. The building shall be constructed in accordance with the approved Exhibits B and C contained within the Community Development Department's file for Plot Plan No. 86-274, except where these conditions shall make any amendments. 6. The type of the exterior building materials shall be in accordance with the approved Exhibit C-1 and materials sample board. Colors shall be subject to review and approval by the Community Development Department. 7. All roof -mounted equipment shall be screened by the roof structure. 1!II°;, CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL - THREE RETAIL/OFFICE BUILDINGS April 22, 1986 Page 2. 8. All signage to be proposed shall be submitted for review by the Community Development Department. A lighting plan for the building's exterior areas, including any proposed parking area lighting, shall be submitted for review and approval by the Community Development Department prior to installation. Streets Parking and Circulation 10. The Applicant shall comply with the following requirements of the City Engineer: (a) The Applicant shall dedicate all necessary public street and utility easements as required by the City Engineer, including the corner cutoffs at Bermudas and Montezuma, and Navarro and Montezuma. (b) The Applicant shall construct street improvements for 1/2 of Bermudas; 1/2 of Montezuma; and 1/2 of Navarro. (c) That the Applicant shall have prepared street improvement plans that are prepared by a Registered Civil Engineer. Street improvements, including traffic signs and markings, shall conform to City Standards as determined by the City Engineer and adopted by the LQMC. (3" AC over 4" Class 2 Base minimum for residential streets). Street design shall take into account the subgrade soil strength, the anticipated traffic loading, and street design life. (d) The Applicant shall have prepared a grading plan that is prepared by a Registered Civil Engineer, who will be required to supervise the grading and drainage improvement construction; and certify that the constructed conditions at the rough grade state are as per the approved plans and grading permit. This is required prior to issuance of building permits. Certification at the final grade stage and verification of pad elevations is also required prior to final approval of grading construction. (e) A thorough preliminary engineering geological and soils engineering investigation shall be done and the report submitted for review along with the grading plan. The reports recommendations shall be incorporated into the grading plan approval. The soils engineer and/or the engineering geologist must certify to the adequacy of the grading plan. Pursuant to Section 11568 of the Business and Professions Code, the soils report certification shall be indicated on the final subdivision map. E CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL - THREE RETAIL/OFFICE BUILDINGS April 22, 1986 Page 3. (f) Drainage disposal facilities shall be provided as required by the City Engineer. (g) All utilities will be installed and trenches compacted to City Standards prior to construction of any streets. The soils engineer shall provide the necessary compaction test reports for review by the City Engineer. (h) An encroachment permit for work shall be secured prior to constructing or joining improvements. (i) The Applicant shall pay the required processing, plan checking and inspection fees as are current at the time the work is being accomplished by City personnel or subcon- tractors for the Planning, Building, or Engineering Divisions. (j) Applicant acknowledges that the City is considering a City-wide Landscape and Lighting District, and agrees to be included in that District. Assessments will be done on a benefit basis as required by law. (k) Driveway locations shall line up with streets and/or existing opposite side driveways whenever possible, as per the City Engineer's requirements. (1) Depth of parking stalls shall be increased to 17' with a vehicle overhang, in order to comply with City Standards. (m) Provide handicapped access ramp at the corner of Navarro and Montezuma. 11. A 6'-high, masonry or other compatible type of wall shall be provided along the north and west property lines abutting residentially zoned property northwesterly of the site. 12. Access onto Bermudas shall be limited to the northerly of the two approaches shown. 13. Trash enclosure shall be gated and enclosed by a 6'-high wall of the same construction and color as the commercial buildings. Location and construction of the enclosure shall conform to requirements of Palm Desert Disposal Company. 14. The number of parking stalls shall be reduced so as to adequately provide landscaped parking islands and comply with City Parking Standards. The Applicant shall demonstrate that the interior landscaped areas exceed 3% of the amount of parking area. 11 CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL - THREE RETAIL/OFFICE BUILDINGS April 22, 1986 Page 4. Public Services and Utilities 15. Fire protection shall be provided in accordance with the City of La Quinta Codes and Ordinances in effect at the time of issuance of the building permit as follows: /000 (a) A fire flow of 59(T GPM for a 2-hour duration at 20 psi residual operating pressure must be available before any combustible material is placed on the job site. (b) The required fire flow of 3000 GPM shall be available from a Super hydrant, (6" x 4" x 2-1/2" x 2-1/211), located not less than 25 feet or more than 165 feet from any portion of the building as measured along approved vehicular travelways. (c) A combination of on -site and off -site Super fire hydrants, (6" x 4" x 2-1/2" x 2-1/211), will be required located not less than 25 feet or more than 165 feet from any portion of the building as measured along approved vehicular travelways. The required fire flow shall be available from any two adjacent hydrants. (d) Certain areas will be required to be maintained as fire lanes. The Applicant shall coordinate these locations with the City Fire Marshal and the Community Safety Coordinator. (e) Install portable fire extinguishers as per NFPA, Pamphlet #10. (f) Install panic hardware and exit signs, as per Chapter 33 of the Uniform Building Code. (g) The required fire flow equals 3000 GPM. (h) Fire Department shall perform a final inspection prior to occupancy. 16. Water service shall be provided in accordance with the require- ments of Coachella Valley Water District and the City of La Quinta. 17. Location and design of the septic system shall be subject to the standards and requirements of the Riverside County Health Department. The system shall be designed to allow ultimate hookup to permanent sewer lines should these lines become avail- able prior to occupancy. The Applicant shall connect to those facilities at that time. 18. All on -site utilities shall be installed underground. CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL - THREE RETAIL/OFFICE BUILDINGS April 22, 1986 Page 5. Miscellaneous 19. Prior to the issuance of building permits, the Applicant shall submit to the Community Development Department, Planning Division, for review and approval, a plan (or plans) showing the following: (a) Landscaping, including revisions to plant types, sizes spacing, and locations as required by these conditions, or proposed by the Applicant. (b) Landscape irrigation system. (c) Location and design detail of any proposed and/or required walls. (d) Location and design of sidewalks and walkways on -site and adjacent Avenida Bermudas, Avenida Navarro and Calle Montezuma. (e) Exterior lighting plan. (f) Design of walled enclosure for trash bin. The approved landscaping and improvements shall be installed prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy. The landscaping shall be maintained in a healthy and viable condition for the life of the project. Landscaping within 10' of all driveway approaches shall not exceed 30" in height. Landscaping shall not interfere with vehicle overhang areas. 20. Desert or native plant species and drought resistant planting materials shall be incorporated into the landscaping plans for the site. � � 1 21. Prior to the issuance of aAbuilding perms , the Applicant shall submit a sign plan showing the location, type, size, colors and type of illumination (if any) of all proposed identification and directional signs. Identification signs shall be limited to building name or directory type signs. All on -site traffic, directional or informational signs shall be installed in accordance with the approved plan prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy. 22. Prior to the issuance of building permits, the Applicant shall comply with the City's adopted requirements regarding infra- structure fees. ITEM NO DATE 13. 'E. PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING RE: ; w MOTION BY: BRANDT \ +u. E15PFRtIN PIING ZSiO1II7BURCii SECOND BY: BRANDT DE GASPERIN MORAN VUlLING TWIMURGH COMMISSIONERS: UNANIMOUSLY ADOPTED: AYE NO YES ABSTAIN NO ABSENT PRESENT ,MEMORANDUM CITY OF LA QUINTA 3 b TO: The Honorable Chairman and Members of the Planning Commission FROM: The Community Development Department DATE: April 22, 1986 SUBJECT: AM7IFNIEU TO TEXT OF THE MUNICIPAL LAND USE ORDINANCE LOCATION: City -Wide APPLICANT: City -Initiated REQUEST: Amend the Ordinance by Adding the "Special Residential Zone" Purpose of the Proposed "Special Residential" Zone The creation of the new zone is intended to accomplish the following: ° Provide a zone for existing and proposed subdivisions which is consistent with the 4 to 8 unit per acre density range permitted by the General Plan Land Use designation of Medium Density Residential. ° Clarify and simplify development standards by consolidating the current R-1 Standards, the City Council's adopted policies and the Planning Commission's requirements into a single text. • Streamline the review procedure for new single family houses by providing for a one-step application submittal process and staff design approval. Relationship to Design Guidelines Manual The "Special Residential Zone" will regulate site and building development standards and design review procedures. The design manual will address recommended architectural styles and design features in addition to the development standards of the zone. Both the manual's format and adoption procedure will make this a more flexible document that can be revised as changing conditions or city policies warrant. STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page Two FINDINGS 1. The proposed Special Commercial Zone is consistent with the La Quinta General Plan Land Use designation of Medium Density Residential (4 to 8 units per acre). 2. Adoption of the "Special Residential" Zone will allow rezoning of certain property located within the City to bring it into conformance with the General Plan land use designation. 3. The adoption of the new zone will allow existing older subdivided areas to be rezoned and be brought into conformance with the Municipal Land Use Ordinance. 4. Adoption of the zone will establish cohesive design standards and design review procedures for new houses constructed within subdivisions. 5. Adoption of the ordinance will not result in an adverse impact on the environment. STAFF RECOMMENDATION The Community Development Department recommends adoption of the Amendment to the Municipal Land Use Ordinance adding the "Special Residential" Zone, in accordance with the attached text. PREPARED BY. APPROVED BY:ZZ'_� Sandra L. Bonner Lawrence L. Stevens, AICP Principal Planner Community Development Director SLB;psn SPECIAL RESIDENTIAL SINGLE-FAMILY ZONE 9.03.010 PURPOSE: The SR Zoning District is generally appropriate where a density of between four (4) and eight (8) units per acre is provided for in the General Plan of the City. It is intended to provide development standards for single- family residential uses and to assure high quality development especially in the "Cove" area. 9.03.020 ALLOWABLE USES: The following uses shall be allowed in the SR Zone. The establishment of allowable uses shall be as provided by Section 9.03.040.A (Precise Plan): A. Single -Family Dwellings B. Accessory buildings and uses incidental to the use of the property as a single-family residence. C. Home Occupations (See Section 18.42) D. Small and Large Family Daycare homes pursuant to the State Health and Safety Code E. Residential Care Facilities, where the number of residents under care is six (6) or fewer, pursuant to the State Welfare and Institutions Code F. Temporary real estate tract offices located within a subdivision, to be used only for and during the original sale of the subdivision (Section 18.30) G. Public Facilities and Utilities 9.03.021 CONDITIONAL USES: The following uses may be allowed in the SR Zone. The establishment of conditional uses shall be as provided by Section 18.28 (Conditional Use Permits): A. Educational Institutions, not including trade or vocational schools B. Churches, Temples and other places of religious worship C. Second Unit or "Granny Flat" within a single-family house pursuant to Section 65852.2 of the California Government Code D. Residential Care Facilities, where the number of residents under care is greater than six (6), pursuant to the State Health and Safety Code. E. Bed and Breakfast - 1 - 9.03.022 SUBDIVISIONS AND PLANNED RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENTS: These projects are permitted in the SR Zone pursuant to the provisions of the Municipal Land Division Ordinance and the development standards in Section 18.5. In addition, the design and siting of all buildings within a standard subdivision shall be subject to review and approval in conjunction with the tentative tract map. 9.03.030 SITE DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS: A. Minimum Lot Size: 5000 square feet. 1. A smaller minimum lot size may be established pursuant to Section 9.03.022 in conjunction with a cluster subdivision or similar planned residen- tial development provided that the overall project density conforms to applicable regulations and that appropriate common open space and recreation areas have been provided. Within existing subdivided areas consisting of 5000-square-foot lots, the voluntary merger of existing lots of records into larger parcels shall be encouraged. B. Minimum Lot Dimensions: 1. Width: 50-feet width for interior lots, 55-feet width for corner lots, 30-foot width for cul-de-sac lots, except where smaller lot sizes are estab- lished pursuant to Section 9.03.030.A. 2. Depth: Depth of 90 feet which shall not exceed 2-1/2 times the width of the lot, except where smaller lot sizes are established pursuant to Section 9.03.030.A. c. Maximum Lot Coverage: The covered by buildings shall percent. This calculation trellises, covered patios unenclosed structures. D. Setbacks: maximum area of the lot not exceed sixty (60) shall not include and other similar Front Yard: All structures shall be set back a minimum of twenty (20) feet from the nearest point on front property line of the lot. (a) Double Frontage Lots: (1) Double Frontage Lot Requirements: A 20-foot front setback shall be provided against one frontage, and a 10-foot rear - 2 - setback shall be provided adjacent to the other frontage. (2) Selecting the Setback Location: Where double frontage setback locations are not specified by subdivision requirements or other applicable regulations, the Applicant may select the front setback street unless 50% of the lots on a double frontage block are developed with the same front yard orientation. In that case, all remaining lots are to orient their front setbacks with the majority. 2. Side Yard: All structures shall be set back a minimum distance from the side property line as follows: (a) Interior Lots: Side yards shall not be less than a width of 5 feet. (b) Corner Lots: The side setback on the street side of corner lots shall not be less than 10 feet from the right-of-way line. (c) Zero Lot Line Development: A group of dwelling units on adjoining lots may be sited so that all units abut one side property line, provided that: (1) The setback has been eliminated through the Subdivision Map approval; and (2) The modified setback requirements for the project are recorded as part of a land division map, deed restriction, or other enforceable restriction; and (3) The side yard setbacks opposite the zero setback property line are not less than 10 feet; and (4) The side yard setback shall not be elim- inated or reduced on the street side of a corner lot. (d) Common Wall Development: Any two dwelling units and their accessory garages may be constructed on adjoining lots without setbacks between them, provided that: (1) The setback has been eliminated through subdivision map; and - 3 - (2) A common wall or party wall agreement, deed restriction or other enforceable restriction has been recorded; and (3) The side yard setbacks opposite the common wall property line are not less than 10 feet; and (4) Common wall construction is in compliance with the Uniform Building Code and Uniform Building Code and Uniform Fire Code. 3. Rear Yard: All structures shall be set back a minimum of 10 feet from the rear property line of the lot. 4. Interior Setbacks: (a) Detached Accessory Structures: In addition to the general front, side and rear yard require- ments, the following shall be complied with: (1) No detached accessory building shall be located closer than 10 feet from the principal or main building. (2) No detached accessory building shall encroach upon the front half of the lot; however, this setback shall not exceed 75 feet from the front property line. (b) Residential Buildings: A principal residential building shall not be located less than 10 feet from another principal building when both structures are one story in height, and not less than 15 feet when one or both structures are two stories or higher in height. (c) Swimming Pools: Private swimming pools shall not be located nearer than five (5) feet to any dwelling excepting as provided by Section 18.25. 5. Exceptions to Setback Standards: The minimum set- back requirements shall apply to all uses, including accessory structures and mechanical equipment, except as provided by the following: (a) Fences or walls six -feet or less, excepting the twenty (20) foot corner cutback area where fence height shall be limited to a maximum of 3-1/2 feet above the top of curb, or 3 feet above the nearest pavement surface where there - 4 - 11 is no curb (Section 18.40). (b) Private swimming pools may be located no nearer than five (5) feet to any property line (Section 18.25). When a swimming pool is located within a front setback area, the appurtenance mechanical equipment may also be located within the front setback area, provided that the equipment is located no closer than five (5) feet from interior side yard property lines and it is enclosed within a masonry block noise attenuating enclosure. (c) outside stairways or landing places, if unroofed and unenclosed, may be extended into a required side yard for a distance of not more than three (3) feet and/or into the required rear yard a distance of not more than five (5) feet (Section 18.19). (d) Cornices, canopies, bay windows, chimney chases and other similar architectural features not providing additional floor space within the building may extend into a required yard not more than one (1) foot (Section 18.19). (e) Eaves may extend three (3) feet into a required yard (Section 18.19), unless otherwise restricted by the requirementss of the Uniform Building Code. (f) Concrete flatwork may extend tot he property lines. (g) Satellite receiving and similar communication dishes and devices six (6) feet or less in height when installed and located within the rear setback or rear yard area only. E. Maximum Building Height: 1. Maximum Building Height: The height of structures shall be limited to seventeen (17) feet or one story in height, whichever is less. 2. Measurement of Height: The height of the structure shall be measured as the verticle distance from the highest point of the structure to the point where the exterior walls touch the finish grade. For the determination of structure height, finish grade shall be the minimum pad height as required by the Uniform Building Code or applicable City ordinances relating to flood hazard management. - 5 - 3. Exceptions to the Height Limitation: (a) Chimneys and roof vents extending no more than two (2) feet above the height limitation speci- fied in this section. (b) Radio and television receiving antennas of the type customarily used for home radio and television receivers, when five (5) feet or less in height. (c) Solar collectors not more than five (5) feet above the height limitation specified in this section. 9.03.031 BUILDING DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS: All single-family residen- tial uses shall comply with the following development standards, unless an adjustment is approved pursuant to Section 9.03.040.B. A. Minimum Gross Livable Area: 1200 square feet, excluding the garage, as measured from the exterior walls of the dwelling. B. Bedroom Dimensions: A minimum of ten (10) foot clear width and depth dimensions, as measured from the interior walls of the room. C. Bathrooms: There shall not be less than 1-1/2 baths in one or two -bedroom dwellings, and not less than 1-3/4 baths in dwellings with three or more bedrooms, excepting that 1-1/2 baths may be permitted for the latter provided that both bathrooms have bathing facilities. D. Garage Dimensions: Each dwelling shall have a two -car garage with interior dimensions not less than twenty feet square (20' x 201), which space shall remain clear of mechanical equipment, appliances, or other improve- ments which conflict with its purpose to store vehicles. An additional three (3) feet shall be provided to the width or depth if mechanical equipment or appliances, i including but not limited to washer, dryer, and forced air unit, are ground mounted within the garage interior. A water heater is permitted without additional interior garage area being required provided that it is located so as not to conflict with vehicular parking or pedes- trian access. E. Access Between House and Garage: A separate pedestrian door into the garage shall be provided as either an interconnecting door providing direct access between the dwelling and the garage, or a pedestrian door leading outside to a paved walkway area which is - 6 - E sheltered by a minimum 36-inch roof eave, enclosed within a secured, walled area and provides direct access to a keyed entry into the dwelling. F. Mechanical and Related Equipment: Heating and cooling mechanical equipment, including satellite receiving and similar communication devices, shall be ground mounted, or completely screened from all sides by the roof structure. 9.03.032 SITE DESIGN STANDARDS: All single-family residential uses shall comply with the following design standards unless an adjustment is approved pursuant to Section 9.03.040.B. A. Landscaping: 1. The front yard of all lots, and in addition, the side yard of corner lots, shall be landscaped to property line. The landscaping shall include: a minimum of three, 15-gallon specimen size trees for interior lots, and five, 15-gallon specimen size trees for corner lots; ground cover, including but not limited to gravel or grass, which shall be contained by minimum 1" x 4" header board along the front and side boundaries. Plant materials shall generally conform to the Manual on Landscaped Standards as adopted by the Planning Commission. A minimum of three outdoor water spigots shall be provided. B. Screening: Refuse containers and bottled gas tanks shall be concealed by landscaping or other means. C. Underground Utilities: All electric services, overhead wires, or associated structures must be installed under- ground. D. Driveway Materials: The driveway shall be surfaced with concrete and have an asphaltic concrete connecting pave- ment edged with a 2" x 4" header to the existing street pavement, constructed in accordance with City Standards. E. Lighting: All exterior lighting shall be located and directed so as not to shine directly on adjacent properties or otherwise create a nuisance. - 7 - 9.03.040 APPLICATION PROCEDURES: A. Precise Plan: The following procedures shall apply to all applications for approval of a Precise Plan that is required by any section of this ordinance. Filing: Applications for consideration of a Precise Plan approval shall be made to the Planning Director. The application shall be accompanied by four (4) complete sets of plans consisting, as a minimum, of the site plan, floor plan and exterior building elevations, a deed showing the Applicant's ownership of the subject property or a letter of authorization from the property owner consenting to the submittal of this application, and a filing fee of twenty-five ($25) dollars. 2. Determination of Completeness: The Planning Department shall make a Determination of Completeness at the time of submittal of the appli- cation and shall not accept for processing any application which is not complete. This deter- mination shall be based upon a written checklist, a copy of which shall be provided to the Applicant if the application is determined to be incomplete. 3. Required Plans: The plans shall be drawn to scale and shall indicate clearly, and with full dimension- ing where applicable, the following: (a) Name and address of the Applicant. (b) Name and address of all property owners. (c) Legal description and assessor's parcel number. (d) Lot dimensions. (e) Location of adjacent streets, drainage structures, utilities and other features that may affect the use of the property. (f) The use and dimensions of all proposed buildings and structures, (including existing structures proposed for retention) and their setbacks from property boundaries and between buildings. (g) Location and construction of proposed driveways and off-street parking areas. (h) Exterior building materials and colors. �i 5. (i) Landscaping plan for the front yard and for the side yard adjacent to the street for corner lots which shall indicate the size, species and location of all materials. (j) Location and type of materials for all fences or walls, including retaining walls. (k) Grading and drainage plan showing existing elevations at one -foot contour intervals, proposed elevations, adjacent roadway eleva- tions, finish floor elevation of garage, finish elevations at each building corner and flow lines of surface water on and off the site. Findings Required For Approval: No Precise Plan shall be approved unless the Planning Director determines that it complies with the following standards: (a) The proposed use and design conform to all applicable requirements of the La Quinta General Plan and any other applicable specific plan adopted by the City and in effect at the date of approval. (b) The proposed development complies with the requirements of the zone in which it is located. (c) The architectural aspects of the development will be compatible with, and not detrimental to, the present and future logical development of the surrounding property. These aspects shall include but not be limited to the structure's size, shape, width, bulk, height, materials and architectural style. (d) Approval of the development shall not be a detriment to the public's health, safety and welfare. (e) The design takes into account the existing physical characteristics of the site, including topography, drainage, and trees. Review of Application: Within two weeks after acceptance of a complete application, the Planning Director shall approve, conditionally approve, or deny the Precise Plan application; or shall advise the Applicant that an adjustment must be requested. - 9 - 6. Term for Approval: A Precise Plan shall be approved for a period of time not to exceed six (6) months, by which time a building permit shall have been obtained. Upon securing a building permit, time limits set forth in the Uniform Building Code shall apply. B. Adjustments Procedure: C. Appeals Procedure: An Applicant or any other interested party may appeal, in writing, stating the reasons there- fore, the decision of the Planning Director to the Planning Commission within fifteen (15) calendar days of the date of decision, in accordance with the provisions of Section 18.30 (e). - 10 - Nag pit ELIMIN/rR--/ DR^/FT / /�f2ofEss/yam /ado 7;4.� /Jric alf. roe /5�p// /�1 {� C'� l /d //[„M✓�v �[ ,�evelrfl.,/ t., f/ l�f�wvft n la t, / L 1 /2VCaIJ-, Zf Tyc S/TE 19A/4) /31/4D/IV6 fL/9/V - Ce—,dC % 4//7-1-1 TN6 G/V 5-71*vz�912O.r ,9/VO CR /7ER/A/ Dom' /F T/fC- %/'/°L / C,-2,v r AGR.EES TD /1/c ! EJfi9 �' Y /no0if/C/9 r/v r/s 7p Th'F /JEr[�/t% f2E /%U./lt'D ,(3Y 7h'6 lownpu?// rY l%V6LUP/nEiUT D/RG tTUR fOR-C./.7_iL/A[UCE �//TH Tffc 71�(�C/iRE/nF/i171 of Th[/.I a.�'/�//tl[saJt,c/ 7/s� Pc[92U 4//1c FDRC. /sR06D 7d TrtE 13u/c 0/�J� �iU/J/�nJ fa L .Z� ),4e ADfJ I//Cl.. �' /✓FH �S /D G/��G/ tLG //✓%/On 1 //�f�sli'dn,i.��0.. p.� 6tg QMe,-tl /�vi /c%..y U/��,qy / R w.-.'err, rzZ ur✓t ✓�. // �c / ✓/ sdlH Jlei, f4c/ !�✓ov,Jo <t /G�j��1+n[. t- fLl l /Fai . J Co 7J '.n GT G rf�✓la Gj JG4Gc�//! lyr C ff,i.g hG /..fedn[r �La., 7l<, 60) -/4 y✓ /Adi tLF-. 3u d T✓i..+ rtc fi�i otl //L[ vro.�crt. Udd/r Ldm/�/L/70n jp' f .fJU///�i.y /Uid�✓/`drop �/sfn f�Cc/</ ina,:. 7 ?'L CJ .i/iw l/✓ bG /%H,Q /Jr,l�r /3!✓u' [G- L>F %Lc t. 1 h Gclo/ hwr/ vtv/, l�ca�70� Ur �y�+ C«t a/t 21 14c 1^,oP c/ f7r„XP9fi�.n ,71 f4 e {rc 1, ;Z e- •-i�_ .:' be ,r„c�.�•'��P ANY WORK STARTED PRIOR 1O THE ISSUANCE OF A BUILDING PE IT WILL RESULT IN ADDITIONAL CHARGES TO THE PER=. THIS nK7XDES DROPPING OF FILL DIRT AND GRADING. DES/G/✓ .GfY/FW 7Ze- (fv,Y/tr,a� L,/. eVq /Uv/ii q ✓ f9 Lkl /�o./Je Oejr7.4 S • Cu.n�/r am CG L✓, f� f/7G La POA ft G e.,tr e / �d�1�/rAhCe cl,'i� 1�/e Gdo�/ra/ Zoa/; aaC/ COMP//G � br I/ ty Lf// / La i!6/ Q LCLs// I�CdL/l//J� Gr7 f lhL/✓if sy `//Cd/�./i f/L✓�(%i irr OT �/iG f3'1�d 4/i..q. • dUr /�✓ /S .Si'ze/ v/dtc, /,C�q / G�,Cl/ 4aA �7 • %'OO Y-I'./�,j/` j 4., � Ji � �q �.1�1v//it1�,S lL., Lt Co /.r-..r • PrUvr,r.0,'r oT .S�CcrCI ✓(�L✓��•• rrts7lhG�+/J /b /4 e, ial lo.;•q J r/da �j w/;Jal C,„ / t.7 fvy -q , cl Ot4Gr C,-74.,%f.J�c4�v.� uTUrIJ 4,14-C✓4 Cvta iC rvn 4 Apo -a e,4 U 4 ra//),z'4v4ACG rnGn �% d1' Q dGJi �-qi�G !fG✓iqh Sf"Q�.Osu-� Tl✓ Ae4% 44)UJ4I ,SPw.rG/y dcrelo�s Ar�u.r. / • �aF r;rfa. c✓y w,'fG, ado�h'c/ fC /2 �..r re • A� � d� �ibtik / ���,d�.-. h�..,r die /o v..�✓,.., / fIPPL®/C��� /fir �Y/i/zF/nEivTs TA c avv/'[,ht <LI«,r s�<// l/n/J.n 4// / 7L4e /�//J✓µ, /%/<•.! 4 /- 1Jh/+^wflC /.vlOrvcETt f1�/���C.9r✓✓✓//ofv �s�c.rsc�r w/mac /1/or 3E A-eel-l7F�7. /�Cwb i/ /JwC(a�cG SC.[// !<n f3•n %'l.0 /'d /�[1.Jr� ��4h.j GnL/ • TiG.sc /3� ca .%o/c/c Sed of lz /IAA.r Twd t Z) Jtti e O Ti f/c 2 Y c'. e•�� cw / c d/ h ✓/ /.�J/t�E� /lo./,,�/r:cw�t • Twa lZ) .Sell dl rOZI /rol./ Cw/C U/of)./..J /✓, %{ /AG o�/«/ /I;,,AX. • Ail ?i .✓ 46e /G ✓� f✓ J/. fG /3' � /%r[i. fGwf �- c/ J�A/J �tc/ fU hY.•rs COm��t r�C JG YES. 4 /.O li/✓1�4r C�1 /�41M /' • /�/AwJ ft✓ f�1lc-/.isnr//y k/�ael Na..+c C/.Lie(/•:•9J hiJf /n.l.a 17.4✓-� �1.i[l .IT++✓�J /n ��r'�f /may 6G Pr l�c[.- r /d /6y Fn� vn G. �1� Cv /i fGs/f i✓.U✓�i/ [aG Prll�G.-rQ' by✓ L7 OCl/✓Uti �l9�Jkvtd 7iD 6o S o. �o[.rf .!/1Ylua/u✓!.r //�<<(/,cr f�.s Z/S /��f o✓ l�qr�!✓ /•-[... G/a0A6 1�in+G Marl [X f%vt�rCo� b✓s u rCyi.%ftrul ca9�'�cer a- 4�cL.fcct�/aHL� • scot, L Srn Sft •++S ll UJ'- &G A�/" UJ C[J '-y F•JfiJ,d� /,14 A"r/".. rHf 1 e✓/A4 /4 � • {l Submit list of contractors, sub -contractors, their state License # and City Business License number. SGa// 6L f��w-•'�� �✓,%� �e �{S ✓,�.✓� ih �».s has. /- PLOT PLAN (suggested scale - 1/8" = 1-0") a. Legal description and general location and Assessor's Parcel Number. b. Owner's name, address and telephone number. e. Vvvwe�s.oU S 6{ (of I CA h'&n 4,( h&. iC.S 6T A%Uttl y f Slrt GfS ( hi'k, CIeq /- I ,l p. LO CA {�•n / S,2,e G..A Use of �Vp OJesl And ey,-s h-n j SIV�cFDres[(nC(ad., t-erpin. 'n� ww�ls�^wdticNJ'Ons o� 5hv✓chy -Cj Ana scF CALLS . C. (-OCAha. [ s✓/Ze�n� M4 fl'✓�GI �T jv"6"e4/41 and A.I�,w,i aft as. �. LaLAh,.., o f eyr '5 h j 1 S'e'-1G7c /c_(."s posct St�S �LH+J (Y 1,+ �J�(iL 5C.JGe S�.d w1 IJ Ca f�a1 OT Ic. �c l/t� Lac.hr. O{ .{e.4•,/�/w/...L' n•csle..�/.✓ et ✓.Ptw. �./. Pvoj...A i+..LI �,. � �tVA}i UnS G1 IBC (o ui la[.� /S�[ (f a� 1'InG S✓✓vu✓h�'� �rJ t IuJ rcl,'•c jSy VAre- 1v O;gje OT Cu-Ca CO✓b td {oq IJ✓I c(. ••�.T 4nc� �A✓t nn-M- J 2. FlooR PLAN (suggested scale - 1/4" = 11011) a. Dimensioned floor plan for each floor showing use of roans. b. Porches, balconies, breezeway, carports, garages, etc. c. Door and window sizes, locations and types. Sizes of headers. d. Size, spacing, and direction of floor, ceiling and roof members. e. Location of plumbing fixtures, including those for the handicapped. f. location and type of heating and air-conditioning system. g. For mechanical ventilation, show means for providing air changes. h. Complete electrical layout (lights, plugs, switches, etc.) i. Electrical service information, diagram and load calculations. j. Show location of smoke detector. ® 0 1 III 3, ELEVATIONS (Provide t elevations of the exterior of the building drawn to scale) awe evisrs a. Exterior wall finishesAand location and extent of all shear walls and/orb gracing. +, •'•r flat H roe+ cwar•'. ec ur.cli• b. Type „o rcofing�and pitch of the roof.( S Y c. Complete set of vertical dimensions, including basenents or c�Llars. d. Elevations should show the true site conditions. e. Location of all windows and doors in the perimeter walls. Show glass thickness on large glass areas. f '_Det Is oi S�tc,G( desiNn ir�a%vnc +s �u n �xls ��o✓s C.4 L✓aIIS. y, FOUNDATION PLAN (suggested scale 1/4" = 1'0") a. Dimensioned plan of the foundations, pad footings and piers. b. Size, location, direction and spacing of girders and joists. c. Location of crawl -holes and screened vents, location and size of underfloor furnace, passageway to the furnace and switched light at the furnace. d. Any special construction required by the structure or site conditions. For Concrete Floors a. Dimensioned plan of the foundations and pad footings. b. Extent and thickness of the concrete slab. C. Any special construction required by the structure or site conditions. S. FRAMING SECrIONS (Suggested Scale " = l'0") a. Dimensioned cross -sections of the various footings, underfloor conditions and construction. b. Dimensioned cross -sections of the entire building, showing the typical construction to be used. Detail connections. Indicate lumber species and grade. c. Cross -sections of lofts, walking decks, balconies, carports, etc. Detail connections. d. Cross -sections of any unusual construction, walls, connections, dormers, frames, etc. e. Cross-section of the fireplace and supplementary details when more than one story in height. Show spark arrester. f. Cross-section of A -frames that are not typical A -frames. g. If the gable end is an all -glass type, detail the entire end wall to show connections between millions, jambs, wind posts S frames. h. Framing elevation of shear walls including tie -down details, plywood thickness, and nailing and shear transfer connections. i. On multistory structures, a floor or roof framing plan may be requiied. j. Type and location of energy insulation. G WING PLANS (Drawn to scale) a. Vicinity nap. b. contours of existing and proposed grades. c. Details of drainage devices, and drainage area with estimated runoff. d. Location of buildings or structures on the property, and any buildings or structures that are within 15'0" of property line on adjacent properties. �. L �NJSC AVE f�L 9N �!%ik✓-, /o ScF /t 2. She✓ i✓anf yG / /i frr ire �dtSi �i/nf /f4/4/ M. J b. loc.6.^ al' pr�l,� i,�rJ, -rk�/v,e-r , L/,. �-'C�y/ 5 L�6L Sa�.i tC is. / Gh L/ .thI Ae4 /////�f� MICL�..,•Gt/ Yy�pi..,c%f Or do/`f/!� q✓�� ls�/a/,��rr /h %L� y�� Q/mot C. L/ULa /%sn e, `uG4 /1 B� 4^6 �f-/Lr/P� Bi ✓/4L_L�Jl4 /�/hy /7"u /�-/�R/r e/uCr t• La LG•fl In Rwa M{j//t rcr/G/3 !�✓fC/l(r/.J OO/Ke CrI !!!111 ��I �F/c.Plf.�fyG A-C4J G/Un' /4� /nf fI�6 i/(F� L✓B�✓/Y/ //h ff_ L�C�fie , C jC`f �.. 'LLCM;.. I(Ad ve Sl 6912917,61,VAG IPZ 191 Js 44W /121FOQ/nA7-iDaJ Tze 2.On large or unusual structures, additional plans may be required covering such things as electrical, water, gas or sewer pipe sizing and layout, heating and air-conditioning duct system, or fire extinguishing system or the like. b. Show means of support and seismic connections for roof nounted heating and cooling equipment. G•� %Zc h�l �tJ G c�JY/ff J4h // �G S'�Jecete 4325 (9ZSo ty`Id,�9 �(� Cll�6\ c�t��s,'f, b7s ✓iLO W acwGf �LUc rJ/,n, G J U) PC✓�„'1 fCC� G/J �C�c+'�++ii. C d ar. G CG J C ' Ey C4 Jt b a,J �i f�l�ll�Q C�+f v�Dn //ti�J✓AUCN+c �1 o7/OlC� 4 e / `L Q% o 4a,'1-4 pc✓..','f C3� ,Soso (-Zs+.�A< f �✓J."h� � �2» �te � g�o Z8 �t� ✓t// y NOT- F-ee 14a-W A Se4-ol /Z/�c • � /, L rCG 4/1 ?ee-A ra--+/h C/ Oj�%j�i;A/�u. /��lJ!/C /� `��QD �Jds a c�/^c o✓/ /%c%6sq /0.lrtdT/ iL✓ H�JG! !✓i f�i'-. fhe ACC c�v✓q Oy1 /y 13 i E SITE REQUIREMENTS INTERIOR LOT FRONTYARD: 20 FT. ['II N I MUM SIDEYARDS: 5 FT. MIN. EACH SIDE i !w, o.0 f c 4 f�Aw �f Connlu{n1 y/j SEPARATION BETWEEN DETACHED STRUCTURES: 10 FT. MINIMUM REARYARD: 10 FT. MINIMUM NO mCG �. an.1N/ C4y�tM Cnf �7L/�+rCd /i7 ✓Lqy%<CI SC!64C IG S. /3o elect 4 tj con 7g4,^c.s /� �d. fy .,rl� r t� v,: � /0 6e Jc� ct. ccl TinsA, en✓i: &,f,*^ c 5 a.,- Can AaI n i-,,J M 6C scr mot/. C.14/ SITE REQUIREMENTS Q MEIVTS CORNER LOT REARYARD: 10 FT, MINIMUM FRONTYARD: 20 FT, MINIMUM SIDEYARD: 5 FT, SIDEYARD: 10 FT, MINIMJM MINIMUM ------------------ Area 1t do i Lukdse4ped Cvn 6rrc,+c / 1---� gSpalt' R V Lin Gt'� � ��z4x9- ik.Je,3 LOCATE DRIVEWAY AWAY FROM THE INTERSECTION / No MCG/khi Ga/ C / ✓ �l`H enf //1 rt virtu je yy Cvnfa:ncrs in �a..t 4rc/ w S��r N'� as/Fctn% fp ,ftrtct S4.// r be e^e—W Y ., _ i SITE REQUIREMENTS CORNER LOT SIDEYARD: 5 FT, GARAGE SETBACK: 20 MINIMUM —� MIN REARYARD: 0 FT,I Cc�cr I LOCATE DRIVEWAY AWAY FROM THE INTERSECTION, \ I 45P l4 Conwcciti 2'k y" htaclws I I Area +v 6G L Cd.d 5 [A PLd FRONTYARD: 20 FT! I �� MINIMUM `— ---—-— - —- — -— SIDEYARD: 10 FT. MINIMM iz, s l 7'fl "I yas cdntf.;.t s in y.,,d1 .114'.cc-f /a Ste. -cols jZx // 6c ,5c.ccrecf /y4f6 e4c(aJvrs.r cY ed. A ;it�j /ARCHITECTURAL STYLES rA: 1V ��i'✓..p gLnciws)(1CJ 16.,f / rdel- , Hell- f'4fJC S1yle.1 1!✓i /� rel d.-C &'14n n.n,7 Cu... w.iJJ/tyitY.'r../ 4..r� i�/+/d✓4 �, r BUILDING DESIGN REQUAMENTS EXTERIOR MAXIMUM HEIGHT: 17 FEET IN THE R- ZONE 35 FEET IN THE R-1 ZONE, SUBJECT TO DESIGN APPROVAL BY THE PLANNING COMMISSION. EXTERIOR MATERIALS: SIDING SHALL BE STUCCO, PLASTER, MASONARY OR SIMILAR MATERIAL. WOOD, OR MATERIALS OF A SIMILAR APPEARANCE, SHALL BE LIMITED TO USE AS TRIM OR DESIGN ACCENTS; THIS MATERIAL MAY BE USED ON A MAXIMUM OF 20 PERCENT OF THE SURFACE WALL AREA ON ANY ONE SIDE OF THE HOUSE, ALL ROOFING MATERIALS SHALL BE RATED AS "CLASS A". ROOF DESIGN: ROOF EAVES SHALL EXTEND A MINIMUM OF 18-INCHES FROM THE WALL. EAVES SHALL BE LARGER WHERE NECESSARY TO PROVIDE ADEQUATE PROTECTION OVER DOOR OPENINGS. BUILDING COLORS: EXTERIOR SIDING, ROOF AND TRIM COLORS ARE SUBJECT TO APPROVAL. bUILDINil FLOOR PLAN DESIGN 3 6rdroo^ W la.-� e,,' 6444S U � Fifai^ (if n 4 g . RFguIkEmENTs 4'-ou mean 0.� ne - -iTT r yrY. .1.r lMc� its/ a, ��. J�p ww �fi-'� am L'c` i•n���Y.nn iru�a/.Hn� 4�aL'a.ces , . � Vp.Wh1YL 1 m.w..re •, Lw, .a •� I,Y� y I� ♦� Mini w.u/w 20'X20' Y 1 ►+den cr dl.+. e.+S; e.s " � ' rn . hGCICS+r: ivy � i+l ihb +ke, kouSG , r ' W1•n(.�Wn lo'xio' cle.Y 1 h iMi�r d.,heh S/pns 3 D✓odour (,gyp+N Slug &is Mlh;. V. boss )i./40e 4vc4 1 AS .,%eajc4-cJ i✓nm GXI1'v.'or Ua�� 04 +kc $}ralclvre : .SOO Sr1JFi-c kcf- ��. J�p ww �fi-'� am L'c` i•n���Y.nn iru�a/.Hn� 4�aL'a.ces , . � Vp.Wh1YL 1 m.w..re •, Lw, .a •� I,Y� y I� ♦� Mini w.u/w 20'X20' Y 1 ►+den cr dl.+. e.+S; e.s " � ' rn . hGCICS+r: ivy � i+l ihb +ke, kouSG , r ' W1•n(.�Wn lo'xio' cle.Y 1 h iMi�r d.,heh S/pns 3 D✓odour (,gyp+N Slug &is Mlh;. V. boss )i./40e 4vc4 1 AS .,%eajc4-cJ i✓nm GXI1'v.'or Ua�� 04 +kc $}ralclvre : .SOO Sr1JFi-c kcf- LANDSCAPE REQUIREMENTS ut� ft. -; Ito — —4 r — — I � 4AR6GE Iff 1 r _'oe-sore [a+tiTR `-Y - -61G4CZR N6R,Ur-56n L. TRNi:.,ai y eSEw', L6✓GO�µ�e .q,f jt Nw w% Pjr �s�Y:fM it i,AL REQUIRED LANDSCAPING: THE FRONTYARD, IN ADDITION TO THE SIDEYARD ADJACENT TO THE STREET ON CORNER LOTS, SHALL BE FULLY LAND- SCAPED PRIOR TO FINAL INSPECTION ON THE HOUSE. IF A FIVE FOOT OR HIGHER WALL IS PROPOSED ALONG THE PROPERTY LINES) ADJACENT TO A STREET FRONTAGE, A MINIMUM FIVE (5) FOOT WIDE AREA SHALL BE PLANTED ALONG THE OUTSIDE OF THIS WALL, A MINIMUM OF TWO (2) 15-GALLON TREES SHALL BE PLANTED IN THE FRONTYARD OF INTERIOR LOTS, AND A MINIMUM OF FOUR (4) 15-GALLON TREES SHALL BE PLANTED IN THE YARDS ADJACENT TO THE STREETt_oKi GoRN F_2 Lc 7 S., LANDSCAPE DESIGNS WHICH INCORPORATE DROUGHT -TOLERANT AND LOW-WATER USAGE PLANTS ARE ENCOURAGED, PLANTINGS LOCATED WITHIN THE 20-FOOT CORNER -CUTBACK AREA OF CORNER LOTS SHALL BE MAINTAINED SO THAT VISIBILITY AT THE INTERSECTION IS UNOBSTRUCTED, HEADERS (2"XW') SHALL ENCLOSE THE FRONT AND SIDES OF LANDSCAPED AREAS. ALL TREES SHALL BE PLANTED A MINIMUM OF 10 FEET FROM THE SEPTIC TANK DISPOSAL SYSTEM, � 'I In 406/'/ i tD f/� ! �GC/! �U i7 rti Cn CT7J a c�arpf� f�G .n /L^.f Ot �SN <y�n4N�c_! /✓ �D t�.c U✓rFU� ahl--A cXi e- Al e. r✓ u�.c� ✓. // /nw, lCA o.� d�iF�c G (/✓Lrf �� a//_ lb -ea!! /'/fAnJ /lJ (.�GLi U/J✓a� /h �L.'<✓� .hGr✓aIG- %L� // /'Uv� �l✓rqn/ /` CfCl,�1! /C/JC� � �✓.:�d�,✓J G�.GY !/JL !if t✓00� / �I�v.0 Ur /'+�a/U�+Gl//y a✓' �h-, �r 6/CC Da /4G✓G aG�C A�'+G� J`Yc, a. C�l �h / A-CF fi„ -- f of ✓UG 1, / ft�✓ 4✓ C/ a iU7 C- G4Jvi✓_ Ll ROOF DESIGN BASIC TYPES GABLE ...........................................::::....... ................. ......................... 0 l _HIP 11 MANSARD .IN6 SHED FLAT muo c n�a� 0 ROOF DESIGN VARIATIONS i�ri�- /i oral ��� Svk / in k✓r✓� de cyn REPEAT SAME ROOF TYPE #AIX ROOF TYPES 11 l4n 66 Cr e- %I-e A by 4Gf✓7 �' / 4e ✓drJ J m VARY ROOF PITCHES VARY ROOF LINE � t � C� „ 0 WINDOW DESIGN E TRIM AND SHELVES AS ACCENTS 0 WALL TREATMENTS STONE AND MASONARY ACCENTS SPECIAL TREATMENT z OF ATTIC VENTS aeeo I I _,- - _ cRS •vr 'SiuC(O C II SKLO &0I GARAGE DOORS `:1 MEIMMMMO ElOE70C1CGCi ncr�71nro J ATRIUMS & PATIOS VIU 20�M /V/Aj<; � b 1. ��CIi00wN y -�OtOOCC4 I i I I n I Ar.' I,O SIDiNO 006c ONi7 'L oix"da se zolu4!¢it4) - 1 S7'P ON. .MV Q✓I?A'> ` n..c ti� ` 7 r � - WALL IFM e' s'r 7T- w .vs» 1 ! i �, BT C Jc iO/N ;t r s=o` J ezoSi osm. r ooc Ooc •usn tse' IED.?OEM ,v /(Y ^ 0.+� tl �✓O�OJ ZG� .%/T (s ��"G✓/ �/iiff� Ca RL!/ /�OrQ� /,� r�!/.r,,C / Ovfl�dU✓ (.(�'ti.J CFr /On St Crt f"C6 bra / G /i�Cur f7U.�a /i i, 4 lvdriy ur J d 17AI C4 /u✓ /df✓ u/i %Cudf � C/i CLaJ / c✓�ZvC // Cl CJ . n.... Ave UJC Q /%r' 7�D L1 C Odr•�� ��iP {^o G�— �✓���✓;4,i- LANDSCAPING & IRRIGATION H0W TO SAVE WATER IN THE LANDSCAPE DESIGN Four of the basic elements in landscape: the plants, the irrigation, the soil, and the caving. Each of these element c�n'ea ily be developed to save water. \ \ 111 // .A. • / r • ,5 • °0 i THE PLANTS 1. Use low water consuming plants and group them according to their water requirements. 2. Instead of thirsty and time consuming lawns, use colorful groundcovers in areas not used for recreation. 3. If you must include lawn, use low water using species. 4. Preserve existing trees and shrubs. Established plants are often adapted to low water conditions, and provide shade which reduces tra.nsDi-ration _n adjacent plantings. 5. When retrofitting or replacing areas of an existing landscape, consider using drought resistant plant material and retrofitting the irrigation system to apply the correct amount of water. 6. Place all plants that require summer watering in sites protected from drying ;rinds and out of direct sunlight. January 1982 "MAINTENANCE Listed below are several ways to save water :chile maintaining a landscape. 1. Don't over water. dater only when the soil is dry. Stick a pencil about 4 to 6 inches into the ground. If the tip gets damp, no water is necessary. 2. Don't let water run off the landscape while watering, which occurs when the soil is unable to absorb water as fast as it is given. Generally, it is important to water thoroughly, making sure the plant's entire root zone receives moisture. Sandy soils dry out quickly, and require frequent watering. Clay soils (which hold more water than sandy soils) dry out slowly, because drainage is slow, and require slow, infrequent watering. Loam soils, which are intermediate between the extremes of clay and sandy, drain well but do not dry out too quickly. 3. Check for and repair leaky hose connections and sprinkler valves. Small leaks can be highly wasteful. 4. Use a broom to sweep the paving, not a hose. Thousands of gallons of water per year can be wasted cleaning a sidewalk. 5. Raise the height of the lawn mower (2 to 3 inches). Longer grass blades will shade each other and the soil, cutting down on evaporation. 6. When replacing plants, use the same species or one with similar water requirements. Also, add compost to the soil to improve its water holding capacity. 7. Maintain at least a 2-inch layer of mulch at all times to reduce evaporation, soil compaction, and weeds. 8. In winter, water plants in leaf infrequently as they can exist for days or weeks on much less water than they demand in summer. DESERT WATER AGENCY 0 IRRIGATION AND LANDSCAPE DESIGN GUIDELINES 1. IRRIGATION SYSTEM AND AUTOMATIC CONTROLS ARE TO BE DESIGNED TO ACCOMODATE PLANT GROUPS BY USE CLASSIFICATION. 2. PLANTINGS ARE TO BE GROUPED BY WATER USE CLASSIFICATIONS: LOW WATER USE: CACTUS AND NATIVES MEDIUM WATER USE: NON-NATIVE TREES S SHRUBS HIGH WATER USE: LAWNS 3. TIME CLOCKS SHOULD BE SUFFICIENTLY SOPHISTICATED TO PERMIT WATERING DURATIONS AS SHORT AS 5 MINUTES. 4. ENCOURAGE THE USE OF: DRIP IRRIGATION SYSTEMS TENSIOMETERS (MOISTURE PROBES) LOW WATER USE PLANT MATERIAL 5. INSTALL AND MAINTAIN IRRIGATION SYSTEMS SO THAT WATER IS RETAINED ON -SITE AND NOT ALLOWED TO RUN INTO THE STREET,OR ADJOINING PROPERTIES. 6. STEEP SLOPES ARE TO BE IRRIGATED BY A DRIP SYSTEM TO PREVENT WATER RUN-OFF. 7. AUTOMATIC TIME CLOCK CONTROLS ARE REQUIRED. 8. ALL IRRIGATION SYSTEMS WILL BE MAINTAINED IN GOOD REPAIR SO THAT THERE ARE NO LEAKS, NO MISSING HEADS, NO RESTRICTED HEADS, AND THAT ALL HEADS ARE PROPERLY ADJUSTED TO ELIMINATE ANY OVERSPRAY ON PAVED AREAS, BUILDINGS OR WALLS. AUTOMATIC CONTROL SYSTEMS ARE TO BE CHECKED PERIODICALLY (AT LEAST MONTHLY) TO INSURE PROPER SETTINGS. 9. AUTOMATIC CONTROL SYSTEMS ARE TO BE RE -SET AFTER THE SUMMER WATERING SEASON. 10. SUMMER SEASON WATERING SHOULD BE DONE AT NIGHT. 11. INSTALL SPRAY HEADS NO CLOSER THAN 6" TO ANY PAVED AREA, BUILDING OR WALL. 12. SITE GRADING WILL BE DESIGNED AND CONSTRUCTED TO PREVENT IRRIGATION RUN-OFF FROM THE PROPERTY. ITEM NO. DATE PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MOTION BY: BRANDY DE GASPERIN MORAN M LLING THOIMURMI SECOND BY: BRANDT DE GASPERIN MORAN WALLING THORNBURGH DISCUSSION: ROLL CALL VOTE: CODIMIS S IONERS : AYE NO ABSTAIN ABSENT PRESENT UNANIMOUSLY ADOPTED: YES 140 MEMORANDUM CITY OF LA OUINTA 3.(2 TO: The Honorable Chairman and Members of the Planning Commission FROM: Community Development Department DATE: April 22, 1986 SUBJECT: CHANGE OF ZONE NO. 86-022 LOCATION: Generally the Cove Area and Areas East of Washington Street in the Vicinity of Avenue 50 and Calle Tampico APPLICANT: City Initiated REQUEST: Approve a Rezoning to "Special Residential" to Provide for General Plan and Zoning Consistency. 1. General Plan: Low Density Residential (2-4 units/acre); Medium Density Residential (4-8 units/acre). (Refer to Attachment No. 1) 2. Zoning: R-l* (One -Family Dwellings, 1200 Sq.Ft. Minimum Dwelling Size); R-1*++ (One -Family Dwellings, 1200 Sq.Ft. Minimum Dwelling Size, 17-Ft. Height Limit); R-2*-4000 (Multiple -Family Residential, 4000 Sq.Ft. Net Lot Area Per Dwelling, 1200 Sq.Ft. Minimum Dwelling Size); R-3* (General Residential, 1200 Sq.Ft. Minimum Dwelling Size). (Refer to Attachment No. 2) 3. Existing Conditions: As shown on Exhibit "A", the majority of the area proposed for rezoning consists of 50' x 100' lots created by the Santa Carmelita and Desert Club Subdivisions. Larger lots are located in the area immediately east of Desert Club Drive and in the vicinity of Calle Tampico east of Washington Street. The only unsubdivided areas proposed for rezoning is the property on the east side of Washington Street immediately north and south of Avenue 50, and a small area on the north side of La Fonda east of Avenida Buena Ventura. There are several areas within the proposed zoning boundaries which are developed with uses other than single-family houses. These are as follows: STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 2. West side of Eisenhower Drive between Calle Tampico and 100-feet south of Avenida Montezuma - for duplexes, one triplex, one 5-unit apartment building, and a real estate office. North Side of Avenida Buena Ventura, east of Desert Club Drive, one 5-unit apartment building. * Avenida La Fonda east of Washington Street and the east side of Washington Street at Calle Paloma, several 15 to 20-year old duplexes and 5-unit or less apartment buildings. 4. Project Description: This is a City -Initiated proposal to rezone certain property shown on Exhibit "A" to "Special Residential". This new zoning classi- fication regulates single-family residential development which is generally in the density range of 4 to 8 dwellings per acre. The intent of this proposal is the following: * Bring the zoning into compliance with the recently amended La Quinta General Plan. Bring the existing development, which is generally on smaller lots, into conformance with the City's zoning ordinance and interim development policies. Environmental Assessment: An environmental assessment was completed on the proposed rezoning and it was determined that approval of the project will not result in a significant adverse impact on the environment. If approved, the "Special Residential" Zone will permit development which is the same density as currently permitted by the adopted General Plan. A master environmental assessment was prepared on the La Quinta General Plan and was certified by the City Council on November 19, 1985. STAFF COMMENTS AND ANALYSIS General Comments As discussed in the report on the amendment to the Municipal Land Use ordinance which creates the "Special Residential" Zone, this desig- nation consolidates the standards and policies currently being imposed STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 3. on new single-family residential construction. Therefore, for the vast majority of the property proposed for this rezoning, the redesignation to "Special Residential" will not result in significant changes from the current development standards. The main benefit of the new zone is that it provides a simpler and quicker design review process. Instead of the current two-step application submittal process for Planning Commission approval and then building permit approval, the "Special Residential" Zone provides for the developer of a new single-family house to make one submittal of the plans to the Community Development Department for review and approval by the Planning and Building Divisions Staff. As will be discussed later in this report, there are two areas where the proposed "Special Residential" Zoning provides for a lower density than the current zoning seemingly permits. In both cases, the current zoning is inconsistent with the current General Plan land use desig- nations. The rezoning of these areas is required by the State Government Code. The following is a brief discussion of the areas proposed for rezoning. Cove Area The single-family area within the Cove or Santa Carmelita at Vale Subdivisions is designated on the General Plan as Medium Density Residential (4 to 8 units per acre) and is zoned R-1*++ (One -Family Dwellings, 1200 Sq.Ft. Minimum Dwelling Size, 17-Ft. Height Limit). This designation requires a minimum 7200 sq.ft. lot size. Since this minimum lot size requirement exceeds the actual size of almost all the lots in the Cove area, it is appropriate and necessary to rezone this area to "Special Residential" which permits a minimum 5000 sq.ft. lot. This rezoning will retain the current minimum dwelling size require- ment and height limitation. West Side of Eisenhower Drive, South of Calle Tampico As shown on Attachment No. 1, there is currently a small strip of lots zoned R-3 (General Residential). This zone allows up to one unit per 2500 sq.ft. of net lot area, or a density of 17.42 units per acre. This area was redesignated on the recently amended La Quinta General Plan from High Density Residential (10-20 units/acre) to Medium Density Residential (4-8 units/acre). Therefore, the current R-3 zoning in this area is inconsistent with the General Plan in that the density it permits exceeds that allowed by the plan. Because State Law requires the two to be consistent, the property must be rezoned appropriately to "Special Residential". STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 4. East of Desert Club Drive, West of Washington Street This area contains a variety of lot sizes, with larger parcels located in the western portion and 50' x 100' lots located in the eastern portion. As discussed in the section on the Cove area, the rezoning will bring the smaller lots into conformance with the standards of the Municipal Land Use Ordinance. The zoning will be appropriate for the larger lots which fall into the density range of 4-5 units per acre and will also provide for consistent zoning standards in this area. As shown on Attachment No. 3, there is an area currently zoned R-2-4000 (Multiple -Family Residential, 4000 Sq.Ft. Net Lot Area Per Dwelling) which technically provides for a density of 10.89 units per acre. The General Plan Land Use designation for this area was recently amended to Low Density Residential (2-4 units/acre) and Medium Density Residential (4-8 units/acre). Therefore, as with the area along Eisenhower Drive, a rezoning to a designation consistent with the General Plan is required by State Law. East of Washington Street, Calle Tampico Area The lots in this area are generally larger and in the density range of 4-5 units per acre. While the existing development is not incon- sistent with the standards of the current R-l* Zoning, the rezoning to "Special Residential" will retain the design review and approval requirements which have been enforced in this area, including the 17-foot height limitation that the current zoning alone, does not impose. East of Washington Street, Bottlebrush Drive Area This subdivision is similar to the Cove area in that the lots are 50' x 100'. As discussed in the previous section, the rezoning will bring this area into compliance with the Municipal Land Use Ordinance. The proposed rezoning south of this area to the La Quinta Stormwater Channel is recommended in order to provide for a uniform zoning along the east side of Washington Street in this area. This will also eliminate the last remaining area of R-1*++ Zoning and complete the transition from this older more awkward zoning classification to the new "Special Residential" Zone. CONCLUSIONS 1. The recommended "Special Residential" Zone is consistent with the General Plan designations of Low Density (2-4 units/acre) and Medium Density (4-8 units/acre) Residential. STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 5. 2. The terrain of the area proposed for rezoning is flat or gently sloping and no special constraints to development exist. 3. All necessary services are existing or available to the parcels proposed for rezoning. 4. The proposed rezoning to "Special Residential" will bring existing subdivided areas in the Cove and west of Washington Street into compliance with the standards of the Municipal Land Use Ordinance. 5. The proposal will bring the zoning in the area along the west side of Eisenhower Drive, south of Calle Tampico, and in the area immediately east of Desert Club Drive, into compliance with the current General Plan Land Use designations for this area. 6. Rezoning the areas east of Washington Street and generally south of the Bottlebrush Drive subdivision will help provide consistent zoning standards for development in this area while still being consistent with the Low Density Residential designation. 7. Approval of the proposal will not result in any significant adverse impacts on the environment. FTmnTKnq 1. The proposed "Special Residential" zoning is consistent with the La Quinta General Plan. 2. The proposed zoning is consistent and compatible with existing and anticipated area development. 3. The zoning is appropriate and consistent with existing utilities and services. 4. Approval of the request will not result in a significant impact on the environment. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Based upon the above findings, the Community Development Department recommends approval of Change of Zone No. 86-022, rezoning certain property from R-1*, R-1*++, R-2*-4000, and R-3* to SR (Special Residential), in accordance with Exhibit "A", and adoption of the negative declaration for the Environmental Assessment No. 86-045. C 11 STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 6. PREPARED BY: `'� /'Sandra Bonner Principal Planner SLB:dmv 7APP OVED BY:/ -O Lawrence L. Stevens, AICP Community Development Director Atchs: 1. Exhibit "A" 2. No. 1 - General Plan 3. No. 2 - Current Zoning 4. No. 3 - Detail; Areas of Inconsistent Zoning w a N N 6 W FRED WARING ENVE HO 1 „ CITY OF LA QUINTA LAND USE PLAN RESIDENTIAL ❑ VERY LOW DENSITY I I LOW DENSITY aMEDIUM DENSITY HIGH DENSITY COMMERCIAL VILLAGE COMMERCIAL ElTOURIST COMMERCIAL El SPECIAL COMMERCIAL El MIXED COMMERCIAL GENERAL COMMERCIAL In COMMERCIAL PARK MISCELLANEOUS 0-2 dwellings/acre 2-4 dwellings/acre 4-8 dwellings/acre 8-16 dwellings/acre ® WATERCOURSE/FLOOD CONTROL ❑ OPEN SPACE E,,,, CITY LIMITS EJ SPHERE OFINFLUENCE AT+ACHMENT NO. 1 07Y➢1�1'f1Y ii��Y'1��' II1i11111l{111 Iits i1 111111 �11111 ,1111111111�� lililil�l,�,l 1hl NORTH MEDIUM DENSITY RESIDENTIAL (4-8 dwellings/acre) LOW DENSITY RESIDENTIAL (2-4 dwellings/acre) %, AREA PROPOSED FOR REZONING FOR GENERAL PLAN CONSISTENCY ATTACHMENT NO. 3 ITEM NO. / • 'T i /I/. DATE PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING RE: MOTION BY: BRANDT DE GASPE MD AN� ING THORNBURGH SECOND BY: BRANIDT DE GASPERIN IDRAXJM HORNBURGH DISCUSSION: ROLL CALL VOTE: COMMISSIONERS: AYE NO ABSTAIN ABSENT PRESENT UNANIMOUSLY ADOPTED: YES NO Aft • MEMORANDUM CITY OF LA OUINTA 4-A TO: The Honorable Chairman and Members of the City Council FROM: Community Development Department DATE: April 22, 1986 SUBJECT: PLOT PLAN NO. 86-279 LOCATION: West Side of Avenida Montezuma; 106' Northwest of Calle Potrero APPLICANT: Rick Johnson Construction REQUEST: Approval to Construct a Single -Family Dwelling Intended for Sale. BACKGROUND 1. General Plan: Medium Density Residential (4-8 Dwellings Per Acre). 2. Zoning: R-1*++ (One Family Dwellings, 17' Height Limit, 1200- Sq.Ft. Minimum Dwelling Size). 3. Existing Conditions: The site is a 6,000 sq.ft. Cove lot located on the west side of Avenida Montezuma, about 106' northwest of Calle Potrero. Montezuma has an existing R-O-W of 60 feet which is adequate for a local street, as designated by the La Quinta General Plan. Existing development is moderately established in the area. Most of the units are stucco sided, with either tile or rock roof coverings. Building heights are generally 141, with variable -pitch, gabled roofs being common in the area. Color schemes incorporate lighter earthtones. The site backs up to the ongoing Bear Creek Flood Control Project to its west. Marywood Day School is also nearby to the southeast of the site. 4. Environmental Assessment: The project is categorically exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and a Notice of Exemption will be filed with the County Recorder. STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 2. 5. Description of Request: The Applicant proposes a three -bedroom house with approximately 1456 sq.ft. of net usable living area. The number of bathrooms is not clear, as the floor plan does not show any tub/shower combinations. All bedrooms meet the 10' x 10' clear dimension as required. The garage exceeds the 20' x 20' clear dimension requirement, providing an additional 3' in depth to accommodate laundry facilities. The garage area has side yard access: and interior access to the dwelling via the tiled front entry area. This floor plan was also submitted under Plot Plan No. 86-280 concurrent with this request. The siting of the unit provides the following setbacks: * Front Yard - 24 Feet * Side Yards - 5 Feet * Rear Yard - 20 Feet The exterior of the house will be blue -grey stucco with popout windows on the south side and rear elevations. The height of the house is 14' and will have a gabled room with a twin -gable style roof over the garage. The roof pitch is 4 and 12 and will be concrete tile colored slate grey. The trim for the house will be dove grey. The exterior will also have railroad tie planter beds along the side and front elevations. STAFF COMMENTS Rick Johnson has received 43 single-family approvals; most of these units have been completed and sold; the rest are being built or have been recently approved. Plot Plan No. 86-280 is also under considera- tion at this meeting. Regarding other considerations, the garage should be deepened 1' to allow for laundry facilities per FHA, and tub/shower combinations need to be indicated, as currently the floor plan shows only 1-1/2 bathroom connections instead of the required 1-3/4. FINDINGS 1. The project will not have a significant adverse impact on the environment. 2. The request is consistent with the requirements of the R-1*++ Zone and goals and objectives of the La Quinta General Plan. STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 3. 3. The building design is compatible with the area development contingent upon the conditions of approval. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Based upon the above findings, the Community Development Department recommends; approval of Plot Plan No. 86-279 in accordance with Exhibits A, B and C and subject to the attached conditions. PREPARED BY: Wallace Nesbit Planning Assistant WN:dmv Atchs: 1. Conditions 2. Exhibits A, B and C APPROVED BY: 6 � 0-e Lawrence L. Stevens, AICP Community Development Director E E THIS APPROVAL IS SUBJECT TO THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS: 1. The development of the site shall be in conformance with the Exhibits A through C contained in the file for Plot Plan No. 86-279, unless otherwise amended by the following conditions. 2. The approved plot plan shall be used within two years of the approval date; otherwise, it shall become null and void and of no effect whatsoever. By "use" is meant the beginning of substantial construction, not including grading, contem- plated by this approval which is begun with the two-year period and is therefore diligently pursued to completion. 3. Water and sewage disposal facilities shall be installed in accordance with the requirements of the Riverside County Health Department. 4. Fire protection shall be provided in accordance with the standards of the Uniform Fire Code as adopted by the City of La Quinta. 5. Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the developer shall submit and have approved, a detailed landscape plan for the front yard showing the species, size, location and spacing of all planting materials, including a minimum of two (2), 15-gallon, street trees. The plan shall indicate the irriga- tion system and the location of the required three (3) outdoor water spigots. Prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, the Applicant shall install landscaping in accordance with the approved landscape plan. All trees and plants shall be maintained in viable condition for the life of the approved use. 6. The heating and cooling mechanical equipment shall be ground mounted, or screened entirely by the roof structure. 7. Refuse containers and bottled gas containers shall be concealed by fencing or landscaping. The driveway shall be surfaced with concrete and have asphaltic concrete connecting pavement (a 2" x 4" header) to the existing street pavement. 9. The Applicant shall obtain clearances and/or permits from the following agencies prior to submitting these plans to the Building Department for plan check: * Riverside County Health Department * City Fire Marshal * Community Development Department, Planning Division * Desert Sands Unified School District CONDITIONS (Cont'd) - PLOT PLAN NO. 86-279 10. The Applicant shall pay a school development fee as determined by the Desert Sands Unified School District in accordance with the school mitigation agreement as approved by the City Council and in effect at the time of issuance of a building permit. A letter from Desert Sands Unified School District stating that these fees have been paid shall be presented to the Community Development Department, Building Division, prior to issuance of a building permit. 11. The structure shall have a Class "A" roof covering. 12. The garage area shall allow a 4' depth for laundry facili- ties. This area shall not encroach into the 20' x 20' clear dimension currently provided. This change shall be noted on the plans for plan check submittal. 13. The plans submitted for plan check shall show any bathtub and shower connections which are proposed. MEMORANCILTm K CITY OF LA OUINTA CEy OF TO: The Honorable Chairman and Members of the City Council FROM: Community Development Department DATE: April 22, 1986 SUBJECT: PLOT PLAN NO. 86-280 LOCATION: East Side of Avenida Vallejo; 150' North of Calle Ensenada APPLICANT: Rick Johnson Construction REQUEST: Approval to Construct a Single -Family Dwelling Intended for Sale. BACKGROUND 1. General Plan: Medium Density Residential (4-8 Dwellings Per Acre). 2. Zoning: R-1*++ (One Family Dwellings, 17' Height Limit, 1200- Sq.Ft. Minimum Dwelling Size). 3. Existing Conditions: The site is a 5,000 sq.ft. Cove lot located on the east side of Avenida Vallejo, 150' north of Calle Ensenada. Vallejo has an existing R-O-W of 60 feet which is adequate for a local street, as designated by the La Quinta General Plan. Existing development is minimal in the area, and these units are stucco or wood -sided, with either asphalt shingle or gravel roof coverings. Building heights vary from 12' to 141, with 3 and 12 to 5 and 12 gabled roofs being common in the area. Color schemes incorporate lighter earthtones, and the existing units are generally older. 4. Environmental Assessment: The project is categorically exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and a Notice of Exemption will be filed with the County Recorder. El STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 2. 5. Description of Request: The Applicant proposes a three -bedroom house with approximately 1456 sq.ft. of net usable living area. The number of bathrooms is not clear, as the floor plan does not show any tub/shower combinations. All bedrooms meet the 10' x 10' clear dimension as required. The garage exceeds the 20' x 20' clear dimension requirement, providing an additional 3' in depth to accommodate laundry facilities. The garage area has side yard access and interior access to the dwelling via the tiled front entry area. This floor plan was also submitted under Plot Plan No. 86-279 concurrent with this request. The siting of the unit provides the following setbacks: * Front Yard - 20 Feet * Side Yards - 5 Feet * Rear Yard - 13 Feet The exterior of the house will be cream stucco with popout windows on the south side and rear elevations. The height of the house; is 14' and will have a gabled room with a twin -gable style roof over the garage. The roof pitch is 4 and 12 and will be asphalt shingle of medium brown color. The trim for the house will be brown. The exterior will also have railroad -tie planter beds along the side and front elevations. STAFF COMMENTS Rick Johnson has received 43 single-family approvals; most of these units have been completed and sold; the rest are being built or have been recently approved. Plot Plan No. 86-279 is also under considera- tion at this meeting. Regarding other considerations, the garage should be deepened l' to allow for laundry facilities per FHA, and tub/shower combinations need to be indicated, as currently the floor plan shows only 1-1/2 bathroom connections instead of the required 1-3/4. FINDINGS 1. The ;project will not have a significant adverse impact on the environment. 2. The request is consistent with the requirements of the R-1*++ Zone and goals and objectives of the La Quinta General Plan. STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 3. 3. The building design is compatible with the area development contingent upon the conditions of approval. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Based upon the above findings, the Community Development Department recommends approval of Plot Plan No. 86-280 in accordance with Exhibits A, B and C and subject to the attached conditions. PREPARED BY: Wallace Nesbit Planning Assistant WN:dmv Atchs: 1. Conditions 2. Exhibits A, B and C APPROVED BY: /Cl�v- Lawrence L. Stevens, AICP Community Development Director THIS APPROVAL IS SUBJECT TO THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS: 1. The development of the site shall be in conformance with the Exhibits A through C contained in the file for Plot Plan No. 86-280, unless otherwise amended by the following conditions. 2. The approved plot plan shall be used within two years of the approval date; otherwise, it shall become null and void and of no effect whatsoever. By "use" is meant the beginning of substantial construction, not including grading, contem- plated by this approval which is begun with the two-year period and is therefore diligently pursued to completion. 3. Water and sewage disposal facilities shall be installed in accordance with the requirements of the Riverside County Health Department. Fire protection shall be provided in accordance with the standards of the Uniform Fire Code as adopted by the City of La Quinta. Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the developer shall submit and have approved, a detailed landscape plan for the front yard showing the species, size, location and spacing of all planting materials, including a minimum of two (2), 15-gallon, street trees. The plan shall indicate the irriga- tion system and the location of the required three (3) outdoor water spigots. Prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, the Applicant shall install landscaping in accordance with the approved landscape plan. All trees and plants shall be maintained in viable condition for the life of the approved use. 6. The heating and cooling mechanical equipment shall be ground mounted, or screened entirely by the roof structure. Refuse containers and bottled gas containers shall be concealed by fencing or landscaping. The driveway shall be surfaced with concrete and have asphaltic concrete connecting pavement (a 2" x 4" header) to the existing street pavement. 9. The Applicant shall obtain clearances and/or permits from the following agencies prior to submitting these plans to the Building Department for plan check: * Riverside County Health Department * City Fire Marshal * Community Development Department, Planning Division * Desert Sands Unified School District CONDITIONS (Cont'd) - PLOT PLAN NO. 86-280 10. The Applicant shall pay a school development fee as determined by the Desert Sands Unified School District in accordance with the school mitigation agreement as approved by the City Council and in effect at the time of issuance of a building permit. A letter from Desert Sands Unified School District stating that these fees have been paid shall be presented to the Community Development Department, Building Division, prior to issuance of a building permit. 11. The structure shall have a Class "A" roof covering. 12. The garage area shall allow a 4' depth for laundry facili- ties. This area shall not encroach into the 20' x 20' clear dimension currently provided. This change shall be noted on the plans for plan check submittal. 13. The plans submitted for plan check shall show any bathtub and shower connections which are proposed. MEMORANDUM CITY OF LA QUINTA �c TO: The Honorable Chairman and Members of the City Council FROM: Community Development Department DATE: April 22, 1986 SUBJECT: PLOT PLAN NO. 86-282 LOCATION: Southwest Corner of Avenida Carranza and Calle Nogales APPLICANT: Marian Adair REQUEST: Approval to Construct a Single -Family Dwelling Intended for Sale. BACKGROUND 1. General Plan: Medium Density Residential (4-8 Dwellings Per Acre). 2. Zoning: R-1*++ (One Family Dwellings, 17' Height Limit, 1200- Sq.Ft. Minimum Dwelling Size). 3. Existing Conditions: The site is a 5,000 sq.ft. Cove area corner lot located on the southwest corner of Avenida Carranza and Calle Arroba. Both streets have existing right-of-ways of 60 feet which is adequate for a local street, as designated by the La Quinta General Plan. Existing development is fairly well established in the area. Most of the units are stucco sided, with either asphalt shingle, tile, or rock roof coverings. Building heights are generally 14' with 4 and 12 pitch, gabled roofs being common in the area. Color schemes incorporate primarily earthtones, but a few differing tones are scattered in the surrounding area. The majority of the units are older and in varying states of mainte- nance. Plot Plan No. 86-283, also being considered this evening, is proposed adjacent to the south of this proposal, and is to incor- porate a similar color scheme. 4. Environmental Assessment: The project is categorically exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and a Notice of Exemption will be filed with the County Recorder. STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 2. 5. Description of Request: The Applicant proposes a three -bedroom house with approximately 1224 sq.ft. of net usable living area. The number of bathrooms is not clear, as the floor plan does not show any tub/shower combinations. All bedrooms meet the 10' x 10' clear dimension as required. The garage is under the 20' x 20' clear dimension requirement, providing a 19' x 19' clear area. The garage area has side yard access and interior access to the dwelling via a laundry area adjacent to the front entry area. This plot plan was submitted concurrently with Plot Plan No. 86-283 located to the south of this proposal. These units will be located adjacent to each other, with differing floor plans/ elevations. The siting of the unit provides the following setbacks: * Front Yard - 20 Feet * North Side Yard - 10 Feet * South Side Yard - 5 Feet * Rear Yard - 10 Feet The exterior of the house will be beige stucco with a light beige trim color. The height of the house is about 14' and will have a gabled roof, with a hip style roof over the garage. The roof pitch is 4 and 12 and will be concrete tile of a rusty -brown color. STAFF COMMENTS The Applicant has had no prior development approvals regarding single- family dwellings, and is seeking approval of this request along with Plot Plan No. 86-283. The most important consideration relative to this proposal is a need for color scheme variation from the Applicant's adjacent application. More significant color variations between Plot Plans Nos. 86-282 and 86-283 need to be provided. Regarding other considerations, depth and width of the garage should be increased 1' to allow for a 20' x 20' clear dimension as required, and tub/shower combinations need to be indicated, as currently the floor plan shows only 1-1/2 bathroom connections instead of the required 1-3/4. FINDINGS The project will not have a significant adverse impact on the environment. The request is consistent with the requirements of the R-1*++ Zone and goals and objectives of the La Quinta General Plan. 0 STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 3. 3. The building design is compatible with the area development contingent upon the conditions of approval. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Based upon the above findings, the Community Development Department recommends approval of Plot Plan No. 86-282 in accordance with Exhibits A, B and C and subject to the attached conditions. PREPARED BY: Wallace Nesbit Planning Assistant WN:dmv Atchs: 1. Conditions 2. Exhibits A, B and C APPROVED BY: C�z C", 9*v Lawrence L. Stevens, AICP Community Development Director 1 THIS APPROVAL IS SUBJECT TO THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS: 1. The development of the site shall be in conformance with the Exhibits A through C contained in the file for Plot Plan No. 86-282, unless otherwise amended by the following conditions. 2. The approved plot plan shall be used within two years of the approval date; otherwise, it shall become null and void and of no effect whatsoever. By "use" is meant the beginning of substantial construction, not including grading, contem- plated by this approval which is begun with the two-year period and is therefore diligently pursued to completion. 3. water and sewage disposal facilities shall be installed in accordance with the requirements of the Riverside County Health Department. 4. Fire protection shall be provided in accordance with the standards of the Uniform Fire Code as adopted by the City of La Quinta. Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the developer shall submit and have approved, a detailed landscape plan for the front yard showing the species, size, location and spacing of all planting materials, including a minimum of two (2), 15-gallon, street trees. The plan shall indicate the irriga- tion system and the location of the required three (3) outdoor water spigots. Prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, the Applicant shall install landscaping in accordance with the approved landscape plan. All trees and plants shall be maintained in viable condition for the life of the approved use. 6. The heating and cooling mechanical equipment shall be ground mounted, or screened entirely by the roof structure. 7. Refuse containers and bottled gas containers shall be concealed by fencing or landscaping. 8. The driveway shall be surfaced with concrete and have asphaltic concrete connecting pavement (a 2" x 4" header) to the existing street pavement. 9. The Applicant shall obtain clearances and/or permits from the following agencies prior to submitting these plans to the Building Department for plan check: * Riverside County Health Department * City Fire Marshal * Community Development Department, Planning Division * Desert Sands Unified School District E CONDITIONS (Cont'd) - PLOT PLAN NO. 86-282 10. The Applicant shall pay a school development fee as determined by the Desert Sands Unified School District in accordance with the school mitigation agreement as approved by the City Council and in effect at the time of issuance of a building permit. A letter from Desert Sands Unified School District stating that these fees have been paid shall be presented to the Community Development Department, Building Division, prior to issuance of a building permit. 11. The structure shall have a Class "A" roof covering. 12. The garage area shall be increased in depth and width in order to provide the 20' x 20' clear dimension required. This change shall be noted on the plans for plan check submittal. 13. The plans submitted for plan check shall show any bathtub and shower connections which are proposed. 14. Sufficient color variations shall be provided at plan check submittal in order to establish adequate variation between Plot Plans Nos. 86-282 and 86-283. 0 MEMORANDUM CITY OF LA QUINTA �f U. TO: The Honorable Chairman and Members of the City Council FROM: Community Development Department DATE: April 22, 1986 SUBJECT: PLOT PLAN NO. 86-283 LOCATION: West Side of Avenida Carranza; 50' South of Calle Nogales APPLICANT: Marian Adair REQUEST: Approval to Construct a Single -Family Dwelling Intended for Sale. BACKGROUND 1. General Plan: Medium Density Residential (4-8 Dwellings Per Acre). 2. Zoning: R-1*++ (One Family Dwellings, 17' Height Limit, 1200- Sq.Ft. Minimum Dwelling Size). 3. Existing Conditions: The site is a 5,000 sq.ft. Cove, interior lot located on the west side of Avenida Carranza, 50' South of Calle Nogales. Carranza has an existing R-O-W of 60 feet which is adequate for a local street, as designated by the La Quinta General Plan. Existing development is fairly well established in the area. Most of the units are stucco sided, with either asphalt shingle, tile, or rock roof coverings. Building heights are generally 14' with 4 and 12 pitch, gabled roofs being common in the area. Color schemes incorporate primarily earthtones, but a few differing tones are scattered in the surrounding area. The majority of the units are older and in varying states of mainte- nance. Plot Plan No. 86-282, also being considered this evening, is proposed adjacent to the north of this proposal, and is to incor- porate a similar color scheme. 4. Environmental Assessment: The project is categorically exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and a Notice of Exemption will be filed with the County Recorder. 0 STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 2. 5. Description of Request: The Applicant proposes a three -bedroom house with approximately 1224 sq.ft. of net usable living area. The number of bathrooms is not clear, as the floor plan does not show any tub/shower combinations. All bedrooms meet the 10' x 10' clear dimension as required. The garage is under the 20' x 20' clear dimension requirement, providing a 19' x 19' clear area. The garage area has side yard access and interior access to the dwelling via a laundry area adjacent to the front entry area. This plot plan was submitted concurrently with Plot Plan No. 86-282 located to the north of this proposal. These units will be located adjacent to each other, with differing floor plans/ elevations. The siting of the unit provides the following setbacks: * Front Yard - 20 Feet * Side Yards - 5 Feet * Rear Yard - 10 Feet The exterior of the house will be cream -colored stucco with an off-white trim color. The height of the house is about 14' and will have a gabled roof. The roof pitch is 4 and 12 and will be concrete tile of a dark brown color. STAFF COMMENTS The Applicant has had no prior development approvals regarding single- family dwellings, and is seeking approval of this request along with Plot Plan No. 86-282. The most important consideration relative to this proposal is a need for color scheme variation from the Applicant's adjacent application. More significant color variations between Plot Plans Nos. 86-282 and 86-283 need to be provided. Regarding other considerations, depth and width of the garage should be increased 1' to allow for a 20' x 20' clear dimension as required, and tub/shower combinations need to be indicated, as currently the floor plan shows only 1-1/2 bathroom connections instead of the required 1-3/4. FINDINGS 1. The project will not have a significant adverse impact on the environment. 2. The request is consistent with the requirements of the R-1*++ Zone and goals and objectives of the La Quinta General Plan. STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 3. 3. The building design is compatible with the area development contingent upon the conditions of approval. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Based upon the above findings, the Community Development Department recommends approval of Plot Plan No. 86-283 in accordance with Exhibits A, B and C and subject to the attached conditions. PREPARED BY: Wallace Nesbit Planning Assistant WN:dmv Atchs: 1. Conditions 2. Exhibits A, B and C APPROVED BY: AG /k Lawrence L. Stevens, AICP Community Development Director 0 THIS APPROVAL IS SUBJECT TO THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS: The development of the site shall be in conformance with the Exhibits A through C contained in the file for Plot Plan No. 86-283, unless otherwise amended by the following conditions. 2. The approved plot plan shall be used within two years of the approval date; otherwise, it shall become null and void and of no effect whatsoever. By "use" is meant the beginning of substantial construction, not including grading, contem- plated by this approval which is begun with the two-year period and is therefore diligently pursued to completion. 3. Water and sewage disposal facilities shall be installed in accordance with the requirements of the Riverside County Health Department. 4. Fire protection shall be provided in accordance with the standards of the Uniform Fire Code as adopted by the City of La Quinta. 5. Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the developer shall submit and have approved, a detailed landscape plan for the front yard showing the species, size, location and spacing of all planting materials, including a minimum of two (2), 15-gallon, street trees. The plan shall indicate the irriga- tion system and the location of the required three (3) outdoor water spigots. Prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, the Applicant shall install landscaping in accordance with the approved landscape plan. All trees and plants shall be maintained in viable condition for the life of the approved use. 6. The heating and cooling mechanical equipment shall be ground mounted, or screened entirely by the roof structure. Refuse containers and bottled gas containers shall be concealed by fencing or landscaping. 8. The driveway shall be surfaced with concrete and have asphaltic concrete connecting pavement (a 2" x 4" header) to the existing street pavement. 9. The Applicant shall obtain clearances and/or permits from the following agencies prior to submitting these plans to the Building Department for plan check: * Riverside County Health Department * City Fire Marshal * Community Development Department, Planning Division * Desert Sands Unified School District 11 CONDITIONS (Cont'd) - PLOT PLAN NO. 86-283 10. The Applicant shall pay a school development fee as determined by the Desert Sands Unified School District in accordance with the school mitigation agreement as approved by the City Council and in effect at the time of issuance of a building permit. A letter from Desert Sands Unified School District stating that these fees have been paid shall be presented to the Community Development Department, Building Division, prior to issuance of a building permit. 11. The structure shall have a Class "A" roof covering. 12. The garage area shall have a 20' x 24' clear interior dimension as required by City policy. This change shall be noted on the plans for plan check submittal. 13. The plans submitted for plan check shall show any bathtub and shower connections which are proposed. 14. Sufficient color variations shall be provided at plan check submittal in order to establish adequate variation between Plot Plans Nos. 86-282 and 86-283. MEMORANDUM CITY OF LA OUINTA TO: The Honorable Chairman and Members of the City Council FROM: Community Development Department DATE: April 22, 1986 SUBJECT: PLOT PLAN NO. 86-287 LOCATION: East Side of Avenida Diaz; 100' North of Calle Tecate APPLICANT: Pine Creek Development/James Laier REQUEST: Approval to Construct a Single -Family Dwelling Intended for Sale. BACKGROUND 1. General Plan: Medium Density Residential (4-8 Dwellings Per Acre). 2. Zoning: R-1*++ (One Family Dwellings, 17' Height Limit, 1200- Sq.Ft. Minimum Dwelling Size). 3. Existing Conditions: The site is a 5,000 sq.ft. Cove lot located on the east side of Avenida Diaz, 100' north of Calle Tecate. Diaz has an existing R-O-W of 60 feet which is adequate for a local street, as designated by the La Quinta General Plan. Existing development is limited, with only 7 units in the area. All of the units are stucco sided with asphalt shingle or gravel roof coverings. Building heights are generally 14' with 3 and 12 or 5 and 12 pitch gabled roofs being common in the area. Color schemes incorporate lighter earthtones and whites. Of 24 lots on the block, only 4 are currently developed. Structures in the area vary in age and architecture. 4. Environmental Assessment: The project is categorically exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and a Notice of Exemption will be filed with the County Recorder. 5. Description of Request: The Applicant proposes a three -bedroom house with approximately 1279 sq.ft. of net usable living area. Two full bathrooms are provided on the floor plan. Bedroom #3 does not meet the required 10' x 10' clear interior dimension requirement, measuring 9.5' x 10.51. The garage has a 19' x 24' clear dimension providing an additional 4' depth to accommodate STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 2. laundry facilities. The garage area has pedestrian access from the front porch area to the dwelling via the front door/entry area. This floor plan was also submitted under Plot Plans Nos. 86-288 and 86-289 concurrent with this request. The site plan indicates an optional pool surrounded by a 6'-high, masonry wall located in the front yard. The siting of the unit provides the following setbacks: * Front Yard - 34 Feet * Side Yards - 5 Feet * Rear Yard - 10 Feet The exterior of the house will be oatmeal (medium brown) stucco. The height of the house is 12.5' and will have a twin gabled roof at the front elevation. The roof pitch is 2 and 12 and will be marigold brown tile. The trim for the house will be brown. STAFF COMMENTS The Applicant has received no single-family approvals, but the floor plan has been previously submitted under Desert Design and Development, which has had 9 prior approvals. Although the three houses will not be in the immediate vicinity of each other, archi- tectural variations should be provided to distinguish the units from each other in order to increase sales potential by providing prospec- tive buyers with a choice relative to the units' appearance. Regarding other considerations, the garage shall be widened 1' to allow for a 20' x 24' clear dimension as required. Access from the garage to the porch shall be covered, and bedroom #3 shall provide 10' x 10' clear interior dimensions. The elevations should show the chimney extension for the optional fireplace. Air-conditioning and swimming pool equipment may not be located in any required setback area. The proposed optional pool must be located as not to be within 5' of any property line, as required by ordinance. Due to the predominantly vacant nature of the area, the proposed color scheme should be changed to allow a greater variety of compatible tones in the Cove by establishing subtle color variation in the area. PTNnTNrS 1. The project will not have a significant adverse impact on the environment. 2. The request is consistent with the requirements of the R-1*++ Zone and goals and objectives of the La Quinta General Plan. E STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 3. 3. The building design is compatible with the area development contingent upon the conditions of approval. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Based upon the above findings, the Community Development Department recommends approval of Plot Plan No. 86-287 in accordance with Exhibits A, B and C and subject to the attached conditions. PREPARED BY: Wallace Nesbit Planning Assistant Atchs: 1. Conditions 2. Exhibits A, B and C APPROVED BY: 6; ' CY ill Lawrence L. Stevens, AICP Community Development Director THIS APPROVAL IS SUBJECT TO THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS: 1. The development of the site shall be in conformance with the Exhibits A through C contained in the file for Plot Plan No. 86-287, unless otherwise amended by the following conditions. 2. The approved plot plan shall be used within two years of the approval date; otherwise, it shall become null and void and of no effect whatsoever. By "use" is meant the beginning of substantial construction, not including grading, contem- plated by this approval which is begun with the two-year period and is therefore diligently pursued to completion. 3. Water and sewage disposal facilities shall be installed in accordance with the requirements of the Riverside County Health Department. 4. Fire protection shall be provided in accordance with the standards of the Uniform Fire Code as adopted by the City of La Quinta. 5. Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the developer shall submit and have approved, a detailed landscape plan for the front yard showing the species, size, location and spacing of all planting materials, including a minimum of two (2), 15-gallon, street trees. The plan shall indicate the irriga- tion system and the location of the required three (3) outdoor water spigots. Prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, the Applicant shall install landscaping in accordance with the approved landscape plan. All trees and plants shall be maintained in viable condition for the life of the approved use. 6. The heating and cooling mechanical equipment shall be ground mounted, or screened entirely by the roof structure. 7. Refuse containers and bottled gas containers shall be concealed by fencing or landscaping. 8. The driveway shall be surfaced with concrete and have asphaltic concrete connecting pavement (a 2" x 4" header) to the existing street pavement. 9. The Applicant shall obtain clearances and/or permits from the following agencies prior to submitting these plans to the Building Department for plan check: * Riverside County Health Department * City Fire Marshal * Community Development Department, Planning Division * Desert Sands Unified School District 1 CONDITIONS (Cont'd) - PLOT PLAN NO. 86-287 10. The Applicant shall pay a school development fee as determined by the Desert Sands Unified School District in accordance with the school mitigation agreement as approved by the City Council and in effect at the time of issuance of a building permit. A letter from Desert Sands Unified School District stating that these fees have been paid shall be presented to the Community Development Department, Building Division, prior to issuance of a building permit. 11. The structure shall have a Class "A" roof covering. 12. The garage area shall be widened 1' in order to allow for required 20' x 24' clear dimension. This change shall be noted on the plans for plan check submittal. 13. Covered breezeway shall be provided from the garage pedes- trian access to the front door of the unit, as required by City policies. 14. Any exterior mechanical equipment shall be located out of any setback areas required by ordinance. 15. Elevations shall show the chimney extension for the optional fireplace. This shall be shown on the plans submitted for plan checking. 16. Bedroom #3 shall be revised to provide 10' x 10' minimum clear dimensions. This shall be verified at time of plan check submittal. 17. The optional pool as proposed shall not be located within 5' of any property line, as required by Section 18.25 of the Municipal Land Use Ordinance. The surrounding wall shall match the color and siding material of the dwelling. o` s MEMORANDL m z K CITY OF LA QUINTA CEO OF TO: The Honorable Chairman and Members of the City Council FROM: Community Development Department DATE: April 22, 1986 SUBJECT: PLOT PLAN NO. 86-288 LOCATION: East Side of Avenida Velasco; 100' South of Calle Chihuahua APPLICANT: Pine Creek Development/James Laier REQUEST: Approval to Construct a Single -Family Dwelling Intended for Sale. BACKGROUND 1. General Plan: Medium Density Residential (4-8 Dwellings Per Acre). 2. Zoning: R-1*++ (One Family Dwellings, 17' Height Limit, 1200- Sq.Ft. Minimum Dwelling Size). 3. Existing Conditions: The site is a 5,000 sq.ft. Cove lot located on the east side of Avenida Velasco, 100' south of Calle Chihuahua. Velasco has an existing R-O-W of 60 feet which is adequate for a local street, as designated by the La Quinta General Plan. Existing development is fairly well established in the area. Most of the units are stucco sided with rock or gravel roof coverings. Building heights are generally 13' or 14' with 3 and 12 or 4 and 12 pitch gabled roofs being common in the area. Color schemes incorporate lighter earthtones, with a a few mustard -colored stucco units in the surrounding area. 4. Environmental Assessment: The project is categorically exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and a Notice of Exemption will be filed with the County Recorder. 5. Description of Request: The Applicant proposes a three -bedroom house with approximately 1279 sq.ft. of net usable living area. Two full bathrooms are provided on the floor plan. Bedroom #3 does not meet the required 10' x 10' clear interior dimension requirement, measuring 9.5' x 10.51. The garage has a 19' x 24' clear dimension providing an additional 4' depth to accommodate STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 2. laundry facilities. The garage area has pedestrian access from the front porch area to the dwelling via the front door/entry area. This floor plan was also submitted under Plot Plans Nos. 86-287 and 86-289 concurrent with this request. The site plan indicates an optional pool surrounded by a 6'-high, masonry wall located in the front yard. The siting of the unit provides the following setbacks: * Front Yard - 34 Feet * Side Yards - 5 Feet * Rear Yard - 10 Feet The exterior of the house will be oatmeal (medium brown) stucco. The height of the house is 12.5' and will have a twin gabled roof at the front elevation. The roof pitch is 2 and 12 and will be marigold brown tile. The trim for the house will be brown. STAFF COMMENTS The Applicant has received no single-family approvals, but the floor plan has been previously submitted under Desert Design and Development, which has had 9 prior approvals. Although the three houses will not be in the immediate vicinity of each other, archi- tectural variations should be provided to distinguish the units from each other in order to increase sales potential by providing prospec- tive buyers with a choice relative to the units' appearance. Regarding other considerations, the garage shall be widened 1' to allow for a 20' x 24' clear dimension as required. Access from the garage to the porch shall be covered, and bedroom #3 shall provide 10' x 10' clear interior dimensions. The elevations should show the chimney extension for the optional fireplace. Air-conditioning and swimming pool equipment may not be located in any required setback area. The proposed optional pool must be located as not to be within 5' of any property line, as required by ordinance. Due to the predominantly vacant nature of the area, the proposed color scheme should be changed to allow a greater variety of compatible tones in the Cove by establishing subtle color variation in the area. FINDINGS 1. The project will not have a significant adverse impact on the environment. 2. The request is consistent with the requirements of the R-1*++ Zone and goals and objectives of the La Quinta General Plan. STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 3. 3. The building design is compatible with the area development contingent upon the conditions of approval. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Based upon the above findings, the Community Development Department recommends approval of Plot Plan No. 86-288 in accordance with Exhibits A, B and C and subject to the attached conditions. PREPARED BY: Wallace Nesbit Planning Assistant WN:dmv Atchs: 1. Conditions 2. Exhibits A, B and C APPROVED BY: Lawrence L. Stevens, AICP Community Development Director THIS APPROVAL IS SUBJECT TO THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS: 1. The development of the site shall be in conformance with the Exhibits A through C contained in the file for Plot Plan No. 86-288, unless otherwise amended by the following conditions. 2. The approved plot plan shall be used within two years of the approval date; otherwise, it shall become null and void and of no effect whatsoever. By "use" is meant the beginning of substantial construction, not including grading, contem- plated by this approval which is begun with the two-year period and is therefore diligently pursued to completion. 3. Water and sewage disposal facilities shall be installed in accordance with the requirements of the Riverside County Health Department. 4. Fire protection shall be provided in accordance with the standards of the Uniform Fire Code as adopted by the City of La Quinta. 5. Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the developer shall submit and have approved, a detailed landscape plan for the front yard showing the species, size, location and spacing of all planting materials, including a minimum of two (2), 15-gallon, street trees. The plan shall indicate the irriga- tion system and the location of the required three (3) outdoor water spigots. Prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, the Applicant shall install landscaping in accordance with the approved landscape plan. All trees and plants shall be maintained in viable condition for the life of the approved use. 6. The heating and cooling mechanical equipment shall be ground mounted, or screened entirely by the roof structure. 7. Refuse containers and bottled gas containers shall be concealed by fencing or landscaping. 8. The driveway shall be surfaced with concrete and have asphaltic concrete connecting pavement (a 2" x 4" header) to the existing street pavement. 9. The Applicant shall obtain clearances and/or permits from the following agencies prior to submitting these plans to the Building Department for plan check: * Riverside County Health Department * City Fire Marshal * Community Development Department, Planning Division * Desert Sands Unified School District I L1I El CONDITIONS (Cont'd) - PLOT PLAN NO. 86-288 10. The Applicant shall pay a school development fee as determined by the Desert Sands Unified School District in accordance with the school mitigation agreement as approved by the City Council and in effect at the time of issuance of a building permit. A letter from Desert Sands Unified School District stating that these fees have been paid shall be presented to the Community Development Department, Building Division, prior to issuance of a building permit. 11. The structure shall have a Class "A" roof covering. 12. The garage area shall be widened l' in order to allow for required 20' x 24' clear dimension. This change shall be noted on the plans for plan check submittal. 13. Covered breezeway shall be provided from the garage pedes- trian access to the front door of the unit, as required by City policies. 14. Any exterior mechanical equipment shall be located out of any setback areas required by ordinance. 15. Elevations shall show the chimney extension for the optional fireplace. This shall be shown on the plans submitted for plan checking. 16. Bedroom #3 shall be revised to provide 10' x 10' minimum clear dimensions. This shall be verified at time of plan check submittal. 17. The optional pool as proposed shall not be located within 5' of any property line, as required by Section 18.25 of the Municipal Land Use Ordinance. The surrounding wall shall match the color and siding material of the dwelling. 18. Roof pitch shall be increased to insure that the house con- forms to the general height and roof pitch characteristics of the surrounding area and current design trends being reviewed by the City. ® MEMORANDA CITY OF LA OUINTA fG TO: The Honorable Chairman and Members of the City Council FROM: Community Development Department DATE: April 22, 1986 SUBJECT: PLOT PLAN NO. 86-289 LOCATION: East Side of Avenida Ramirez; 50' North of Calle Monterey APPLICANT: Pine Creek Development/James Laier REQUEST: Approval to Construct a Single -Family Dwelling Intended for Sale. BACKGROUND 1. General Plan: Medium Density Residential (4-8 Dwellings Per Acre). 2. Zoning: R-1*++ (One Family Dwellings, 17' Height Limit, 1200- Sq.Ft. Minimum Dwelling Size). 3. Existing Conditions: The site is a 5,000 sq.ft. Cove lot located on the east side of Avenida Ramirez, 50' north of Calle Monterey. Ramirez has an existing R-O-W of 60 feet which is adequate for a local street, as designated by the La Quinta General Plan. Existing development is fairly well established in the area. Most of the units are stucco sided with rock or gravel roof coverings. Building heights are generally 13' or 15' with 3 and 12 or 4 and 12 pitch gabled roofs being common in the area. Color schemes incorporate lighter earthtones, with a a few mustard -colored stucco units in the surrounding area. 4. Environmental Assessment: The project is categorically exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and a Notice of Exemption will be filed with the County Recorder. 5. Description of Request: The Applicant proposes a three -bedroom house with approximately 1279 sq.ft. of net usable living area. Two full bathrooms are provided on the floor plan. Bedroom #3 does not meet the required 10' x 10' clear interior dimension requirement, measuring 9.5' x 10.51. The garage has a 19' x 24' clear dimension providing an additional 4' depth to accommodate STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 2. laundry facilities. The garage area has pedestrian access from the front porch area to the dwelling via the front door/entry area. This floor plan was also submitted under Plot Plans Nos. 86-287 and 86-288 concurrent with this request. The site plan indicates an optional pool surrounded by a 6'-high, masonry wall located in the front yard. The siting of the unit provides the following setbacks: * Front Yard - 34 Feet * Side Yards - 5 Feet * Rear Yard - 10 Feet The exterior of the house will be oatmeal (medium brown) stucco. The height of the house is 12.5' and will have a twin gabled roof at the front elevation. The roof pitch is 2 and 12 and will be marigold brown tile. The trim for the house will be brown. STAFF COMMENTS The Applicant has received no single-family approvals, but the floor plan has been previously submitted under Desert Design and Development, which has had 9 prior approvals. Although the three houses will not be in the immediate vicinity of each other, archi- tectural variations should be provided to distinguish the units from each other in order to increase sales potential by providing prospec- tive buyers with a choice relative to the units' appearance. Regarding other considerations, the garage shall be widened 1' to allow for a 20' x 24' clear dimension as required. Access from the garage to the porch shall be covered, and bedroom #3 shall provide 10' x 10' clear interior dimensions. The elevations should show the chimney extension for the optional fireplace. Air-conditioning and swimming pool equipment may not be located in any required setback area. The proposed optional pool must be located as not to be within 5' of any property line, as required by ordinance. FINDINGS 1. The project will not have a significant adverse impact on the environment. 2. The request is consistent with the requirements of the R-1*++ Zone and goals and objectives of the La Quinta General Plan. STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 3. 3. The building design is compatible with the area development contingent upon the conditions of approval. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Based upon the above findings, the Community Development Department recommends approval of Plot Plan No. 86-289 in accordance with Exhibits A, B and C and subject to the attached conditions. PREPARED BY: Wallace Nesbit Planning Assistant WN:dmv Atchs: 1. Conditions 2. Exhibits A, B and C APPROVED BY: Lawrence L. Stevens, AICP Community Development Director E THIS APPROVAL IS SUBJECT TO THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS: 1. The development of the site shall be in conformance with the Exhibits A through C contained in the file for Plot Plan No. 86-289, unless otherwise amended by the following conditions. 2. The approved plot plan shall be used within two years of the approval date; otherwise, it shall become null and void and of no effect whatsoever. By "use" is meant the beginning of substantial construction, not including grading, contem- plated by this approval which is begun with the two-year period and is therefore diligently pursued to completion. 3. Water and sewage disposal facilities shall be installed in accordance with the requirements of the Riverside County Health Department. 4. Fire protection shall be provided in accordance with the standards of the Uniform Fire Code as adopted by the City of La Quinta. 5. Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the developer shall submit and have approved, a detailed landscape plan for the front yard showing the species, size, location and spacing of all planting materials, including a minimum of two (2), 15-gallon, street trees. The plan shall indicate the irriga- tion system and the location of the required three (3) outdoor water spigots. Prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, the Applicant shall install landscaping in accordance with the approved landscape plan. All trees and plants shall be maintained in viable condition for the life of the approved use. 6. The heating and cooling mechanical equipment shall be ground mounted, or screened entirely by the roof structure. 7. Refuse containers and bottled gas containers shall be concealed by fencing or landscaping. 8. The driveway shall be surfaced with concrete and have asphaltic concrete connecting pavement (a 2" x 4" header) to the existing street pavement. 9. The Applicant shall obtain clearances and/or permits from the following agencies prior to submitting these plans to the Building Department for plan check: * Riverside County Health Department * City Fire Marshal * Community Development Department, Planning Division * Desert Sands Unified School District V CONDITIONS (Cont'd) - PLOT PLAN NO. 86-289 10. The Applicant shall pay a school development fee as determined by the Desert Sands Unified School District in accordance with the school mitigation agreement as approved by the City Council and in effect at the time of issuance of a building permit. A letter from Desert Sands Unified School District stating that these fees have been paid shall be presented to the Community Development Department, Building Division, prior to issuance of a building permit. 11. The structure shall have a Class "A" roof covering. 12. The garage area shall be widened l' in order to allow for required 20' x 24' clear dimension. This change shall be noted on the plans for plan check submittal. 13. Covered breezeway shall be provided from the garage pedes- trian access to the front door of the unit, as required by City policies. 14. Any exterior mechanical equipment shall be located out of any setback areas required by ordinance. 15. Elevations shall show the chimney extension for the optional fireplace. This shall be shown on the plans submitted for plan checking. 16. Bedroom #3 shall be revised to provide 10' x 10' minimum clear dimensions. This shall be verified at time of plan check submittal. 17. The optional pool as proposed shall not be located within 5' of any property line, as required by Section 18.25 of the Municipal Land Use Ordinance. The surrounding wall shall match the color and siding material of the dwelling. 18. Roof pitch shall be increased to insure that the house con- forms to the general height and roof pitch characteristics of the surrounding area and current design trends being reviewed by the City. MEMORANDUM CITY OF LA OUINTA TO: The Honorable Chairman and Members of the City Council FROM: Community Development Department DATE: April 22, 1986 SUBJECT: PLOT PLAN NO. 86-290 LOCATION: East Side of Avenida Ramirez; 150' South of Calle Arroba APPLICANT: Joel Colombo, Architectural Creations REQUEST: Approval to Construct a Single -Family Dwelling Intended for Sale. BACKGROUND 1. General Plan: Medium Density Residential (4-8 Dwellings Per Acre). 2. Zoning: R-1*++ (One Family Dwellings, 17' Height Limit, 1200- Sq.Ft. Minimum Dwelling Size). 3. Existing Conditions: The project site is a vacant partially vegetated 50' x 100' interior lot in La Quinta's Cove area. The lot is currently surrounded by vacant lots to the side and rear. Of the 21 lots on the site vicinity block, only four lots are built upon. Three of the four houses incorporate conventional "California Ranch" style architecture with sloping gravel covered roofs and earthtone stucco sidings. The small house at the south- east corner of Avenida Ramirez and Calle Chillon is of an older "Desert Hut" style design incorporating a slightly sloping roof and rock siding. The Applicant is also proposing to build another house on the northerly adjacent lot. 4. Environmental Assessment: The project is categorically exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and a Notice of Exemption will be filed with the County Recorder. 5. Description of Request: The Applicant, who is a contractor, is requesting approval to construct five single-family houses intended for sale. This proposal is one of the plans submitted for consideration at this meeting. All five plans have identical floor plans and site plans with variations in architectural elevations. These plans call for approximately 1200 sq.ft. of a El STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 2. net usable floor area with three bed garage has a doorway which provides the main entrance into the house. D the house, no uniform roof overhangs house height is 12 feet. The flat r parapet to conceal roof -mounted mec ment. The Applicant is proposing a The house setbacks are as follows: rooms and two baths. The covered pedestrian access to ue to the unique design of or eaves are provided. The oof design includes a roof hanical or electrical equip - "Alamo" style architecture. Front Yard - 20 Feet Rear Yard - 21 Feet Side Yards - 5 Feet (Each The proposed colors for the house include an earthtone beige stucco siding with brown wood trim and orange mission tile roof- ing details. STAFF COMMENTS Considering that the project's vicinity block is primarily vacant with no adjacent surrounding development, it is difficult to determine the compatibility of the house in relationship to the neighborhood. However, the "Alamo" type architecture shown on the front elevation will introduce a unique architecture to the area. Due to the lack of development on the block, the house will be quite visible from all angles including the sides and rear. It is apparent that the Applicant intends to produce a standard, conventional, flat - roofed house with a false front to portray any architectural theme from "Desert Deco" and "Alamo" to "Country French" and "Ranch" designs. This is apparent in viewing the typical side and rear eleva- tion plans which indicates a bland cubiform design theme. To upgrade the architecture of the overall neighborhood, the elevation plans need to be revised to carry the "Alamo" design theme to the side and rear portions of the house. Therefore, prior to building permit plan check submittal, the Applicant shall present revised side and rear elevation plans, which extend the "Alamo" design architecture to the sides and rear elevations of the house, to the Planning Division for review and approval. The Applicant has indicated that he fully agrees to revise and upgrade the architecture at these portions of the house. The proposed roof design does not provide for full perimeter roof overhangs. However, with the plans modified, the mansard roof facade which will extend around the entire house will provide the minimum 18" roof eaves required. It should be noted, however, to require the full 1811, uniform perimeter roof eaves on this design would detract from the design theme of the house. STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 3. As indicated previously, the garage pedestrian door does not directly enter into the house. Rather, the access way to the main house entrance is fully covered to shade the pedestrian in route. The intent of the directly connecting pedestrian door into the garage is to protect the user from direct sun exposure in route. The plans indicate that mechanical equipment will be roof mounted. However, even with a surrounding roof parapet, equipment can be seen from higher elevations in the Cove. The Applicant has indicated that he intends to ground mount all electrical or mechanical equipment in the rear yard where there is ample room. To assure that this is done, the project shall be conditioned appropriately. The interior, clear garage measurements are 16' x 20.51. Pursuant to City standards, the garage plans shall be revised to provide a minimum of 20' x 20' interior clear dimensions. Overall, the project, as conditioned, is consistent with the City's R-1*++ Zone and will provide refreshing architectural variety to the Cove. FTwnTWn9 1. The project will not have a significant adverse impact on the environment. 2. The request is consistent with the requirements of the R-1*++ Zone and goals and objectives of the La Quinta General Plan. 3. The building design is compatible with the area development contingent upon the conditions of approval. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Based upon the above findings, the Community Development Department recommends approval of Plot Plan No. 86-290 in accordance with Exhibits A, B and C and subject to the attached conditions. PREPARED BY: APPROVED BY: G � Lk/ 1 C � - Gary W. Price Lawrence L. Stevens, AICP Associate Planner Community Development Director WN:dmv Atchs: 1. Conditions 2. Exhibits A, B and C THIS APPROVAL IS SUBJECT TO THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS: 1. The development of the site shall be in conformance with the Exhibits A through C contained in the file for Plot Plan No. 86-290, unless otherwise amended by the following conditions. 2. The approved plot plan shall be used within two years of the approval date; otherwise, it shall become null and void and of no effect whatsoever. By "use" is meant the beginning of substantial construction, not including grading, contem- plated by this approval which is begun with the two-year period and is therefore diligently pursued to completion. 3. Water and sewage disposal facilities shall be installed in accordance with the requirements of the Riverside County Health Department. 4. Fire protection shall be provided in accordance with the standards of the Uniform Fire Code as adopted by the City of La Quinta. Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the developer shall submit and have approved, a detailed landscape plan for the front yard showing the species, size, location and spacing of all planting materials, including a minimum of two (2), 15-gallon, street trees. The plan shall indicate the irriga- tion system and the location of the required three (3) outdoor water spigots. Prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, the Applicant shall install landscaping in accordance with the approved landscape plan. All trees and plants shall be maintained in viable condition for the life of the approved use. 6. The roof -mounted mechanical and electrical equipment, as indicated on the plans, shall be ground mounted. All ground - mounted mechanical and electrical equipment shall be appropriately screened with approved methods of visual screening. Refuse containers and bottled gas containers shall be concealed by fencing or landscaping. 8. The driveway shall be surfaced with concrete and have asphaltic concrete connecting pavement (a 2" x 4" header) to the existing street pavement. 9. The Applicant shall obtain clearances and/or permits from the following agencies prior to submitting these plans to the Building Department for plan check: * Riverside County Health Department * City Fire Marshal * Community Development Department, Planning Division * Desert Sands Unified School District CONDITIONS (Cont'd) - PLOT PLAN NO. 86-290 10. The Applicant shall pay a school development fee as determined by the Desert Sands Unified School District in accordance with the school mitigation agreement as approved by the City Council and in effect at the time of issuance of a building permit. A letter from Desert Sands Unified School District stating that these fees have been paid shall be presented to the Community Development Department, Building Division, prior to issuance of a building permit. 11. The structure shall have a Class "A" roof covering. 12. The "Alamo" style architecture shall be extended along the side and rear portions of the house. Prior to building permit plan check submittal, the Applicant shall submit to Planning Division, for review and approval, specific side and rear elevations plans which carry the front architec- tural theme to all sides and rear of the house. 13. Interior garage dimensions shall be a minimum of 20' x 20' clear. 14. The Applicant shll submit to the Community Development Department for review and approval, a revised color scheme of the house. House colors shall be earthtone to match neighboring development. 0 MEMORANDUM CITY OF LA OUINTA TO: The Honorable Chairman and Members of the City Council FROM: Community Development Department DATE: April 22, 1986 SUBJECT: PLOT PLAN NO. 86-291 LOCATION: East Side of Avenida Ramirez; 100' South of Calle Arroba APPLICANT: Joel Colombo, Architectural Creations REQUEST: Approval to Construct a Single -Family Dwelling Intended for Sale. BACKGROUND 1. General Plan: Medium Density Residential (4-8 Dwellings Per Acre). 2. Zoning: R-1*++ (One Family Dwellings, 17' Height Limit, 1200- Sq.Ft. Minimum Dwelling Size). 3. Existing Conditions: The project site is a vacant partially vegetated 50' x 100' interior lot in La Quinta's Cove area. The lot is currently surrounded by vacant lots to the side and rear. Of the 21 lots on the site vicinity block, only four lots are built upon. Three of the four houses incorporate conventional "California Ranch" style architecture with sloping gravel covered roofs and earthtone stucco sidings. The small house at the south- east corner of Avenida Ramirez and Calle Chillon is of an older "Desert Hut" style design incorporating a slightly sloping roof and rock siding. The Applicant is also proposing to build another house on the southerly adjacent lot. 4. Environmental Assessment: The project is categorically exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and a Notice of Exemption will be filed with the County Recorder. 5. Description of Request: The Applicant, who is a contractor, is requesting approval to construct five single-family houses intended for sale. This proposal is one of the plans submitted for consideration at this meeting. All five plans have identical floor plans and site plans with variations in architectural elevations. These plans call for approximately 1200 sq.ft. of STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 2. net usable floor area with three bedrooms and two baths. The garage has a doorway which provides covered pedestrian access to the main entrance into the house. Due to the unique design of the house, no uniform roof overhangs or eaves are provided. The house height is 12 feet. The flat roof design includes a roof parapet to conceal roof -mounted mechanical or electrical equip- ment. The Applicant is proposing a "Desert Deco" style architecture. The house setbacks are as follows: * Front Yard - 20 Feet * Rear Yard - 21 Feet * Side Yards - 5 Feet (Each The proposed colors for the house include a bright pink stucco siding with orange wood trim and orange mission tile roofing details. STAFF COMMENTS Considering that the project's vicinity block is primarily vacant with no adjacent surrounding development, it is difficult to determine the compatibility of the house in relationship to the neighborhood. However, the "Desert Deco" type architecture shown on the front elevation will introduce a unique architecture to the area. The Applicant's adjacent development proposal (Plot Plan No. 86-290) incorporates a similar and compatible "Alamo" style architecture. The bright pink and orange colors proposed are definitely not compatible with neighborhood development. The Applicant should revise the color scheme of this house to earthtones and pastels which are compatible with neighborhood development. Due to the lack of development on the block, the house will be quite visible from all angles including the sides and rear. It is apparent that the Applicant intends to produce a standard, conventional, flat - roofed house with a false front to portray any architectural theme from "Desert Deco" and "Alamo" to "Country French" and "Ranch" designs. This is apparent in viewing the typical side and rear eleva- tion plans which indicates a bland cubiform design theme. To upgrade the architecture of the overall neighborhood, the elevation plans need to be revised to carry the "Desert Deco" design theme to the side and rear portions of the house. Therefore, prior to building permit plan check submittal, the Applicant shall present revised side and rear elevation plans, which extend the "Desert Deco" design architecture to sides and rear elevations of the house, to the Planning Division for review and approval. The Applicant has indicated that he fully agrees to revise and upgrade the architecture at these portions of the house. STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 3. The proposed roof design does not provide for full perimeter roof overhangs. However, with the plans modified, the mansard roof facade which will extend around the entire house will provide the minimum 18" roof eaves required. It should be noted, however, to require the full 1811, uniform perimeter roof eaves on this design would detract from the design theme of the house. As indicated previously, the garage pedestrian door does not directly enter into the house. Rather, the access way to the main house entrance is fully covered to shade the pedestrian in route. The intent of the directly connecting pedestrian door into the garage is to protect the user from direct sun exposure in route. The plans indicate that mechanical equipment will be roof mounted. However, even with a surrounding roof parapet, equipment can be seen from higher elevations in the Cove. The Applicant has indicated that he intends to ground mount all electrical or mechanical equipment in the rear yard where there is ample room. To assure that this is done, the project shall be conditioned appropriately. The interior, clear garage measurements are 16' x 20.51. Pursuant to City standards, the garage plans shall be revised to provide a minimum of 20' x 20' interior clear dimensions. Overall, the project, as conditioned, is consistent with the City's R-1*++ Zone and will provide refreshing architectural variety to the Cove. FINDINGS 1. The project will not have a significant adverse impact on the environment. 2. The request is consistent with the requirements of the R-1*++ Zone and goals and objectives of the La Quinta General Plan. 3. The building design is compatible with the area development contingent upon the conditions of approval. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Based upon the above findings, the Community Development Department recommends approval of Plot Plan No. 86-291 in accordance with Exhibits A, B and C and subject to the attached conditions. STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 4. PREPARED BY: Cjo— W'�r Gary W. Price Associate Planner GWP:dmv Atchs: 1. Conditions 2. Exhibits A, B and C APPROVED BY: Lawrence L. Stevens, AICP Community Development Director THIS APPROVAL IS SUBJECT TO THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS: 1. The development of the site shall be in conformance with the Exhibits A through C contained in the file for Plot Plan No. 86-291, unless otherwise amended by the following conditions. 2. The approved plot plan shall be used within two years of the approval date; otherwise, it shall become null and void and of no effect whatsoever. By "use" is meant the beginning of substantial construction, not including grading, contem- plated by this approval which is begun with the two-year period and is therefore diligently pursued to completion. 3. Water and sewage disposal facilities shall be installed in accordance with the requirements of the Riverside County Health Department. Fire protection shall be provided in accordance with the standards of the Uniform Fire Code as adopted by the City of La Quinta. Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the developer shall submit and have approved, a detailed landscape plan for the front yard showing the species, size, location and spacing of all planting materials, including a minimum of two (2), 15-gallon, street trees. The plan shall indicate the irriga- tion system and the location of the required three (3) outdoor water spigots. Prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, the Applicant shall install landscaping in accordance with the approved landscape plan. All trees and plants shall be maintained in viable condition for the life of the approved use. 6. The roof -mounted mechanical and electrical equipment, as indicated on the plans, shall be ground mounted. All ground - mounted mechanical and electrical equipment shall be appropriately screened with approved methods of visual screening. Refuse containers and bottled gas containers shall be concealed by fencing or landscaping. 8. The driveway shall be surfaced with concrete and have asphaltic concrete connecting pavement (a 2" x 4" header) to the existing street pavement. 9. The Applicant shall obtain clearances and/or permits from the following agencies prior to submitting these plans to the Building Department for plan check: * Riverside County Health Department * City Fire Marshal * Community Development Department, Planning Division * Desert Sands Unified School District CONDITIONS (Cont'd) - PLOT PLAN NO. 86-291 10. The Applicant shall pay a school development fee as determined by the Desert Sands Unified School District in accordance with the school mitigation agreement as approved by the City Council and in effect at the time of issuance of a building permit. A letter from Desert Sands Unified School District stating that these fees have been paid shall be presented to the Community Development Department, Building Division, prior to issuance of a building permit. 11. The structure shall have a Class "A" roof covering. 12. The "Desert Deco" style architecture shall be extended along the side and rear portions of the house. Prior to building permit plan check submittal, the Applicant shall submit to Planning Division, for review and approval, specific side and rear elevations plans which carry the front architec- tural theme to all sides and rear of the house. 13. Interior garage dimensions shall be a minimum of 20' x 20' clear. 14. The Applicant shll submit to the Community Development Department for review and approval, a revised color scheme of the house. House colors shall be earthtone to match neighboring development. MEMORANDUM CITY OF LA OUINTA `fJ TO: The Honorable Chairman and Members of the City Council FROM: Community Development Department DATE: April 22, 1986 SUBJECT: PLOT PLAN NO. 86-292 LOCATION: East Side of Avenida Villa; 200' South of Calle Monterey APPLICANT: Joel Colombo, Architectural Creations REQUEST: Approval to Construct a Single -Family Dwelling Intended for Sale. BACKGROUND 1. General Plan: Medium Density Residential (4-8 Dwellings Per Acre). 2. Zoning: R-1*++ (One Family Dwellings, 17' Height Limit, 1200- Sq.Ft. Minimum Dwelling Size). 3. Existing Conditions: The site is a typical 50' x 100' interior lot within La Quintals Cove area. The neighborhood is typical for Cove development with vacant lots and scattered housing. Of the 23 lots in the project vicinity block, 18 lots are vacant and five lots are built upon. The built portions of the block consist of a variety of architecture; two houses having sloping tile roofs and white stucco sidings, two with sloping rock roofs and beige stucco sidings having a "Modular" type architecture, and one flat roofed "Desert" type house with a combination of rock, stucco, and wood siding. 4. Environmental Assessment: The project is categorically exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and a Notice of Exemption will be filed with the County Recorder. 5. Description of Request: The Applicant, who is a contractor, is requesting approval to construct five single-family houses intended for sale. This proposal is one of the plans submitted for consideration at this meeting. All five plans have identical floor plans and site plans with variations in architectural elevations. These plans call for approximately 1200 sq.ft, of STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 2. net usable floor area with three bedrooms and two baths. The garage has a doorway which provides covered pedestrian access to the main entrance into the house. Due to the unique design of the house, no uniform roof overhangs or eaves are provided. The house height is 12 feet. The flat roof design includes a roof parapet to conceal roof -mounted mechanical or electrical equip- ment. The Applicant is proposing a "Moroccan" style architecture. The house setbacks are as follows: * Front Yard - 20 Feet * Rear Yard - 21 Feet * Side Yards - 5 Feet (Each The proposed colors for the house include a beige stucco siding with orange wood trim and orange mission tile roofing details. STAFF COMMENTS Considering that the project's vicinity block is primarily vacant with no adjacent surrounding development, it is difficult to determine the compatibility of the house in relationship to the neighborhood. However, the "Moroccan" type architecture shown on the front elevation will introduce a unique architecture to the area. Due to the lack of development on the block, the house will be quite visible from all angles including the sides and rear. It is apparent that the Applicant intends to produce a standard, conventional, flat - roofed house with a false front to portray any architectural theme from "Desert Deco" and "Alamo" to "Country French" and "Ranch" designs. This is apparent in viewing the typical side and rear eleva- tion plans which indicates a bland cubiform design theme. To upgrade the architecture of the overall neighborhood, the elevation plans need to be revised to carry the "Morrocan" design theme to the side and rear portions of the house. Therefore, prior to building permit plan check submittal, the Applicant shall present revised side and rear elevation plans, which extend the "Morrocan" design architecture to sides and rear elevations of the house, to the Planning Division for review and approval. The Applicant has indicated that he fully agrees to revise and upgrade the architecture at these portions of the house„ STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 3. The proposed roof design does not provide for full perimeter roof overhangs. However, with the plans modified, the mansard roof facade which will extend around the entire house will provide the minimum 18" roof eaves required. It should be noted, however, to require the full 1811, uniform perimeter roof eaves on this design would detract from the design theme of the house. As indicated previously, the garage pedestrian door does not directly enter into the house. Rather, the access way to the main house entrance is fully covered to shade the pedestrian in route. The intent of the directly connecting pedestrian door into the garage is to protect the user from direct sun exposure in route. The plans indicate that mechanical equipment will be roof mounted. However, even with a surrounding roof parapet, equipment can be seen from higher elevations in the Cove. The Applicant has indicated that he intends to ground mount all electrical or mechanical equipment in the rear yard where there is ample room. To assure that this is done, the project shall be conditioned appropriately. The interior, clear garage measurements are 16' x 20.5'. Pursuant to City standards, the garage plans shall be revised to provide a minimum of 20' x 20' interior clear dimensions. Overall, the project, as conditioned, is consistent with the City's R-1*++ Zone and will provide refreshing architectural variety to the Cove. FINDINGS 1. The project will not have a significant adverse impact on the environment. 2. The request is consistent with the requirements of the R-1*++ Zone and goals and objectives of the La Quinta General Plan. 3. The building design is compatible with the area development contingent upon the conditions of approval. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Based upon the above findings, the Community Development Department recommends approval of Plot Plan No. 86-292 in accordance with Exhibits A, B and C and subject to the attached conditions. STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 4. PREPARED BY: APPROVED BY: Gary W. Price Lawrence L. Stevens, AICP Associate Planner Community Development Director WN:dmv Atchs: 1. Conditions 2. Exhibits A, B and C THIS APPROVAL IS SUBJECT TO THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS: 1. The development of the site shall be in conformance with the Exhibits A through C contained in the file for Plot Plan No. 86-292, unless otherwise amended by the following conditions. 2. The approved plot plan shall be used within two years of the approval date; otherwise, it shall become null and void and of no effect whatsoever. By "use" is meant the beginning of substantial construction, not including grading, contem- plated by this approval which is begun with the two-year period and is therefore diligently pursued to completion. 3. Water and sewage disposal facilities shall be installed in accordance with the requirements of the Riverside County Health Department. 4. Fire protection shall be provided in accordance with the standards of the Uniform Fire Code as adopted by the City of La Quinta. 5. Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the developer shall submit and have approved, a detailed landscape plan for the front yard showing the species, size, location and spacing of all planting materials, including a minimum of two (2), 15-gallon, street trees. The plan shall indicate the irriga- tion system and the location of the required three (3) outdoor water spigots. Prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, the Applicant shall install landscaping in accordance with the approved landscape plan. All trees and plants shall be maintained in viable condition for the life of the approved use. 6. The roof -mounted mechanical and electrical equipment, as indicated on the plans, shall be ground mounted. All ground - mounted mechanical and electrical equipment shall be appropriately screened with approved methods of visual screening. 7. Refuse containers and bottled gas containers shall be concealed by fencing or landscaping. 8. The driveway shall be surfaced with concrete and have asphaltic concrete connecting pavement (a 2" x 4" header) to the existing street pavement. 9. The Applicant shall obtain clearances and/or permits from the following agencies prior to submitting these plans to the Building Department for plan check: * Riverside County Health Department * City Fire Marshal * Community Development Department, Planning Division * Desert Sands Unified School District CONDITIONS (Cont'd) - PLOT PLAN NO. 86-292 10. The Applicant shall pay a school development fee as determined by the Desert Sands Unified School District in accordance with the school mitigation agreement as approved by the City Council and in effect at the time of issuance of a building permit. A letter from Desert Sands Unified School District stating that these fees have been paid shall be presented to the Community Development Department, Building Division, prior to issuance of a building permit. 11. The structure shall have a Class "A" roof covering. 12. The "Morrocan" style architecture shall be extended along the side and rear portions of the house. Prior to building permit plan check submittal, the Applicant shall submit to the Planning Division, for review and approval, specific side and rear elevations plans which carry the front architec- tural theme to all sides and rear of the house. 13. Interior garage dimensions shall be a minimum of 20' x 20' clear. ® 0 MEMORANDUM CITY OF LA QUINTA TO: The Honorable Chairman and Members of the City Council FROM: Community Development Department DATE: April 22, 1986 SUBJECT: PLOT PLAN NO. 86-293 LOCATION: West Side of Avenida Juarez; 150' South of Calle Colima APPLICANT: Joel Colombo, Architectural Creations REQUEST: Approval to Construct a Single -Family Dwelling Intended for Sale. BACKGROUND 1. General Plan: Medium Density Residential (4-8 Dwellings Per Acre). 2. Zoning: R-1*++ (One Family Dwellings, 17' Height Limit, 12,00- Sq.Ft. Minimum Dwelling Size). 3. Existing Conditions: The project site is a typical 50' x 100' interior lot in La Quinta's Cove area. The neighborhood consists of a variety of architecture with seven of the 22 lots built: upon. The lot directly south and adjacent to the site has a "California Ranch" architecture with a white, rock -covered, sloping roof and white stucco siding with brown trim. The three other houses on the Avenid Juarez side of the block have similar designs. On the Avenida Madero side of the block, one house incorporates a "Conventional Tract" design with a sloping, brown composition shingle roof and yellow stucco siding and two houses incorporate a "Modern Spanish" design with sloping barrel tile roofs and beige stucco sidings. Directly to the north of the site, the Applicant is proposing another house for development. 4. Environmental Assessment: The project is categorically exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and a Notice of Exemption will be filed with the County Recorder. 5. Description of Request: The Applicant, who is a contractor, is requesting approval to construct five single-family houses intended for sale. This proposal is one of the plans submitted 0 STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 2. for consideration at this meeting. All five plans have identical floor plans and site plans with variations in architectural elevations. These plans call for approximately 1200 sq.ft. of net usable floor area with three bedrooms and two baths. The garage has a doorway which provides covered pedestrian access to the main entrance into the house. The house height is 12 feet. The house incorporates a sloping, mansard style roof design with an approximate 4 and 12 pitch along the slopes. The roof eaves extend out 18". This house has a "Ranch" style architectural design. The house setbacks are as follows: * Front Yard - 20 Feet * Rear Yard - 21 Feet * Side Yards - 5 Feet (Each) The proposed colors for the house include a beige stucco siding with brown wood trim and brown, flat roof tile. STAFF COMMENTS The "Ranch" style house design is the most compatible house design of the Applicant's five house proposals in the Cove. According to the Applicant, both the "Ranch" and "Country French" houses will have a roof style that extends around the side and rear elevations, unlike the other "Alamo", "Desert Deco", and "Morrocan" design proposals (Plot Plans Nos. 86-290, 86-292). The proposal is compatible with existing neighboring development and is expected to upgrade the architecture on the block. Since the plans do not indicate specific side and rear elevations for the project, the Applicant should submit these plans for review and approval to the Planning Division prior to submittal of plans to the Building Division for plan check. To assure appropriate overall design, these plans shall specify a continuation of the attractive mansard roof and siding details to the side and rear elevations of the house. According to the Applicant, the roof designs for the "Ranch" and "Country French" houses will require roof truss construction which will eliminate the false front problem which is associated with the "Alamo", "Desert Deco", and "Morrocan" style houses. As indicated in the Applicant's previous Staff Reports, the Applicant has indicated that he agrees to revise all side and rear elevation plans to substantially upgrade the architecture at these portions of the house. As indicated previously, the garage pedestrian door does not directly enter into the house. Rather, the access way to the main house entrance is fully covered to shade the pedestrian en route. The intent of the directly connecting pedestrian door requirement is to protect the user from direct sun exposure en route. STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 3. Although the plans indicate that major mechanical and electrical equipment will be roof mounted, the Applicant has indicated that it will be ground mounted in the rear yard. The interior clear garage measurements are 16' x 20.5'. Pursuant to City standards, the garage plans shall be revised to provide a minimum of 20' x 20' interior clear dimensions. Overall, the project, as conditioned, is consistent with the City's R-1*++ Zone and will provide architectural variety to the neighbor- hood. FINDINGS 1. The project will not have a significant adverse impact on the environment. 2. The request is consistent with the requirements of the R-1*++ Zone and goals and objectives of the La Quinta General Plan. 3. The building design is compatible with the area development. contingent upon the conditions of approval. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Based upon the above findings, the Community Development Department recommends approval of Plot Plan No. 86-293 in accordance with Exhibits A, B and C and subject to the attached conditions. PREPARED BY: Gary W. Price Associate Planner MUMMA Atchs: 1. Conditions 2. Exhibits A, B and C APPROVED BY � 0- —L, Lawrence L. Stevens, AICP Community Development Director I''i��3 11 THIS APPROVAL IS SUBJECT TO THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS: 1. The development of the site shall be in conformance with. the Exhibits A through C contained in the file for Plot Plan. No. 86-293, unless otherwise amended by the following conditions. The approved plot plan shall be used within two years of the approval date; otherwise, it shall become null and void and of no effect whatsoever. By "use" is meant the beginning of substantial construction, not including grading, contem- plated by this approval which is begun with the two-year period and is therefore diligently pursued to completion. 3. Water and sewage disposal facilities shall be installed in accordance with the requirements of the Riverside County Health Department. 4. Fire protection shall be provided in accordance with the standards of the Uniform Fire Code as adopted by the City of La Quinta. Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the developer shall submit and have approved, a detailed landscape plan for the front yard showing the species, size, location and spacing of all planting materials, including a minimum of two (2), 15-gallon, street trees. The plan shall indicate the irriga- tion system and the location of the required three (3) outdoor water spigots. Prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, the Applicant shall install landscaping in accordance with the approved landscape plan. All trees and plants shall be maintained in viable condition for the life of the approved use. The roof -mounted mechanical and electrical equipment, as indicated on the plans, shall be ground mounted. All ground - mounted mechanical and electrical equipment shall be appropriately screened with approved methods of visual screening. 7. Refuse containers and bottled gas containers shall be concealed by fencing or landscaping. 8. The driveway shall be surfaced with concrete and have asphaltic concrete connecting pavement (a 2" x 4" header) to the existing street pavement. 9. The Applicant shall obtain clearances and/or permits from the following agencies prior to submitting these plans to the Building Department for plan check: * Riverside County Health Department * City Fire Marshal * Community Development Department, Planning Division * Desert Sands Unified School District CONDITIONS (Cont'd) - PLOT PLAN NO. 86-293 10. The Applicant shall pay a school development fee as determined by the Desert Sands Unified School District in accordance with the school mitigation agreement as approved by the City Council and in effect at the time of issuance of a building permit. A letter from Desert Sands Unified School District stating that these fees have been paid shall be presented to the Community Development Department, Building Division, prior to issuance of a building permit. 11. The structure shall have a Class "A" roof covering. 12. The "Ranch" style architecture, including roof design and siding features, shall be extended along the side and rear portions of the house. Prior to building permit plan check submittal, the Applicant shall submit to the Planning Division, for review and approval, specific side and rear elevations plans which carry the front architec- tural theme to all sides and rear of the house. 13. Interior garage dimensions shall be a minimum of 20' x 20' clear. MEMORANDUM CITY OF LA OUINTA 4 k - TO: The Honorable Chairman and Members of the City Council FROM: Community Development Department DATE: April 22, 1986 SUBJECT: PLOT PLAN NO. 86-294 LOCATION: West Side of Avenida Juarez; 100' South of Calle Colima APPLICANT: Joel Colombo, Architectural Creations REQUEST: Approval to Construct a Single -Family Dwelling Intended for Sale. BACKGROUND 1. General Plan: Medium Density Residential (4-8 Dwellings Per Acre). 2. Zoning: R-1*++ (One Family Dwellings, 17' Height Limit, 1200- Sq.Ft. Minimum Dwelling Size). 3. Existing Conditions: The project site is a typical 50' x 100' interior lot in La Quintals Cove area. The neighborhood consists of a variety of architecture with seven of the 22 lots built on. The lot directly south and adjacent to the site has a "California Ranch" architecture with a white, rock -covered, sloping roof and white stucco siding with brown trim. The three other houses on the Avenid Juarez side of the block have similar designs. On the Avenida Madero side of the block, one house incorporates a "Conventional Tract" design with a sloping, brown composition shingle roof and yellow stucco siding and two houses incorporate a "Modern Spanish" design with sloping barrel tile roofs and beige stucco sidings. Directly to the south of the site, the Applicant is proposing another house for development. 4. Environmental Assessment: The project is categorically exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and a Notice of Exemption will be filed with the County Recorder. 5. Description of Request: The Applicant, who is a contractor, is requesting approval to construct five single-family houses intended for sale. This proposal is one of the plans submitted STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 2. for consideration at this meeting. All five plans have identical floor plans and site plans with variations in architectural elevations. These plans call for approximately 1200 sq.ft. of net usable floor area with three bedrooms and two baths. The garage has a doorway which provides covered pedestrian access to the main entrance into the house. The house height is 15 feet. The house incorporates a sloping, mansard style roof design. with variable roof lines. The roof eaves extend out 18". This house has a "Country French" style architectural design. The house setbacks are as follows: * Front Yard - 20 Feet * Rear Yard - 21 Feet * Side Yards - 5 Feet (Each) The proposed colors for the house include a beige stucco siding with brown wood trim and brown, flat roof tile. STAFF COMMENTS The "Country French" style house design is compatible with existing neighborhood development. According to the Applicant, both the "Ranch" and "Country French" houses will have a roof style that extends around to the side and rear elevations, unlike the other "Alamo", "Desert Deco", and "Morrocan" design proposals (Plot Plans Nos. 86-290, 86-292). The proposal is compatible with existing neighborhood development and is expected to upgrade the architecture on the block. The Applicant's other adjacent proposed house, to the north of the project site, has a "Ranch" style design which is compatible with this proposed house. Since the plans do not indicate specific side and rear elevations for the project, the Applicant should submit these plans for review and approval to the Planning Division prior to submittal of plans to the Building Division for plan check. To assure appropriate overall design, these plans shall specify a continuation of the attractive mansard roof and siding details to the side and rear elevations of the house. According to the Applicant, the roof designs for the "Ranch" and "Country French" houses will require roof truss construction which will eliminate the false front porblem which is associated with the "Alamo", "Desert Deco", and "Morrocan" style houses. As indicated in the Applicant's previous Staff Reports, the Applicant has indicated that he agrees to revise all side and rear elevation plans to substantially upgrade the architecture at these portions of the house. The garage pedestrian door does not directly enter into the house. Rather, the access way to the main house entrance is fully covered to shade the pedestrian en route. The intent of the directly connecting pedestrian door requirement is to protect the user from direct sun exposure en route. STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 3. As indicated previously, the garage pedestrian door does not directly enter into the house. Rather, the access way to the main house entrance is fully covered to shade the pedestrian en route. The intent of the directly connecting pedestrian door requirement is to protect the user from direct sun exposure en route. Although the plans indicate that major mechanical and electrical equipment will be roof mounted, the Applicant has indicated that it will be ground mounted in the rear yard. The interior clear garage measurements are 16' x 20.5'. Pursuant to City standards, the garage plans shall be revised to provide a minimum of 20' x 20' interior clear dimensions. FINDINGS 1. The project will not have a significant adverse impact on the environment. 2. The request is consistent with the requirements of the R-1*++ Zone and goals and objectives of the La Quinta General Plan. 3. The building design is compatible with the area development contingent upon the conditions of approval. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Based upon the above findings, the Community Development Department recommends approval of Plot Plan No. 86-294 in accordance with Exhibits A, B and C and subject to the attached conditions. PREPARED BY: Gary W. Price Associate Planner WN:dmv Atchs: 1. Conditions 2. Exhibits A, B and C APPROVED BY: /-"" 6< , Lawrence L. Stevens, AICP Community Development Director THIS APPROVAL IS SUBJECT TO THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS: 1. The development of the site shall be in conformance with the Exhibits A through C contained in the file for Plot Plan No. 86-294, unless otherwise amended by the following conditions. 2. The approved plot plan shall be used within two years of the approval date; otherwise, it shall become null and void and of no effect whatsoever. By "use" is meant the beginning of substantial construction, not including grading, contem- plated by this approval which is begun with the two-year period and is therefore diligently pursued to completion. 3. Water and sewage disposal facilities shall be installed in accordance with the requirements of the Riverside County Health Department. 4. Fire protection shall be provided in accordance with the standards of the Uniform Fire Code as adopted by the City of La Quinta. 5. Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the developer shall submit and have approved, a detailed landscape plan for the front yard showing the species, size, location and spacing of all planting materials, including a minimum of two (2), 15-gallon, street trees. The plan shall indicate the irriga- tion system and the location of the required three (3) outdoor water spigots. Prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, the Applicant shall install landscaping in accordance with the approved landscape plan. All trees and plants shall be maintained in viable condition for the life of the approved use. 6. The roof -mounted mechanical and electrical equipment, as indicated on the plans, shall be ground mounted. All ground - mounted mechanical and electrical equipment shall be appropriately screened with approved methods of visual screening. 7. Refuse containers and bottled gas containers shall be concealed by fencing or landscaping. The driveway shall be surfaced with concrete and have asphaltic concrete connecting pavement (a 2" x 4" header) to the existing street pavement. The Applicant shall obtain clearances and/or permits from the following agencies prior to submitting these plans to the Building Department for plan check: * Riverside County Health Department * City Fire Marshal * Community Development Department, Planning Division * Desert Sands Unified School District l CONDITIONS (Cont'd) - PLOT PLAN NO. 86-294 10. The Applicant shall pay a school development fee as determined by the Desert Sands Unified School District in accordance with the school mitigation agreement as approved by the City Council and in effect at the time of issuance of a building permit. A letter from Desert Sands Unified School District stating that these fees have been paid shall be presented to the Community Development Department, Building Division, prior to issuance of a building permit. 11. The structure shall have a Class "A" roof covering. 12. The "Country French" style architecture, including roof design and siding features, shall be extended along the, side and rear portions of the house. Prior to building permit plan check submittal, the Applicant shall submit to the Planning Division, for review and approval, specific side and rear elevations plans which carry the front architec- tural theme to all sides and rear of the house. 13. Interior garage dimensions shall be a minimum of 20' x 20' clear. M I N U T E S PLANNING COMMISSION - CITY OF LA QUINT. A Regular Meeting Held at the La Quinta City Hall, 78-105 Calle Estado, La Quinta, California March 25, 1986 1. CALL TO ORDER 7:00 p.m. A. Chairman Thornburgh called the Planning Commission meeting to order at 7:00 p.m.; he called upon Commissioner De Gasperin to lead the flag salute. 2. ROLL CALL A. Chairman Thornburgh requested the Roll Call; the Secretary called the Roll: Present: Commissioners Brandt, De Gasperin, Moran, Walling, and Chairman Thornburgh Also present were Community Development Director Lawrence L. Stevens and Secretary Donna M. Velotta. 3. HEARINGS 4. CONSENT CALENDAR A. Commissioner De Gasperin made a motion, seconded by Chairman Thornburgh to approve Plot Plans Nos. 86-273, 86-276, and 86-277. Unanimously Adopted. B. Commissioner Brandt made a motion, seconded by Chairman Thornburgh to approve the minutes from the regular meeting of March 11, 1986, as submitted. Unanimously Adopted. 5. BUSINESS Chairman Thornburgh introduced the item of business as follows: A. 1986 General Plan Review - Cycle I. He called for the Staff Report. 1. Community Development Director Lawrence L. Stevens reiterated that this was a new procedure stating that approximately six or eight weeks ago, we adopted a proce- dure to coordinate the review of General Plan Amendments by setting up a three -cycle -a -year system. That was to assure compliance with the government code provision which limits general plan amendments to a maximum of four times a year. In essence, we set up three general plan MINUTES - PLANNING COMMISSION March 25, 1986 Page 2. application deadlines of December 15, April 15 and August 15, with essentially a four -month review. Part of the review that we provided for was that upon submittal of applications, the Planning Commission and City Council would review the applications on a preliminary, non - hearing basis to make sure that the scope of what we were considering was appropriate, since a particular applicant could only ask to amend his particular piece of property. This would maintain a General Plan approach rather than looking at our General Plan as a colored zoning map. In addition, the purpose of the review was to also give the Commission the opportunity to identify other changes not related to applications that might be appropriate for consideration of amendment to the General Plan. There- fore, the purpose of this preliminary review is to establish a scope for each of the applications received and then to determine if there are other areas that should be considered for amendment beyond those raised by the applications. Director Stevens advised that this year only, Cycle I is done outside of the normal review period since we did not set up the schedule until February, we are using a modi- fied review for the first cycle this year. And, as you can see, one of the reasons we set up a coordinated review for General Plan amendments is that we now have three such applications and if we assessed them independently, we would have used up three of our four amendment :reviews. So, there is a good reason for setting up this type of review schedule. Director Stevens then referred the Commission to the memo provided them regarding the three applications received which gives a general background of each and asks the Commission to determine the scope they feel should be considered for each. He then briefly explained each of the applications. General Plan Amendment No. 86-009 is an application from the Western Corporation. This affects 30 or so acres within the Duna La Quinta Specific Plan area and what the Applicant is requesting is that we amend the text of the Community Development Element to create a new land use category entitled "Very High Density Residential" which would permit 16 to 24 units per acre. At the present time, the maximum density we would allow would be 16 units per acre in our "High Density Residential" category. Then the Applicant is asking, in addition, that should you create a "Very High Density Residential" category that a particular 30-acre parcel be so designated for the purpose of a allowing a 688-unit apartment project. They intend MINUTES - PLANNING COMMISSION March 25, 1986 Page 3. to process the zone change and the plot plan associated with that, as well as a specific plan amendment to the Duna La Quinta Specific Plan simultaneously with the General Plan amendment application. Director Stevens informed the Commission that looking at the factors, there are two factors to consider in evaluating this request. The first factor is the text change to "Very High Density Residential" and I think it should be understood that we are going to have to define it and we probably will have some policies associated with that. He thought that merely the initiation of a text change gives us an adequate range to raise those poli- cies as part of the review. Therefore, should the Commission and Council approve this request, we will have a text describing what "Very High Density Residential" means and probably a number of policies telling us about how and when we will use it. However, if the Commission has some particular interest in areas of concern, you may raise those now and we will make sure they are addressed in the preparation of our report and the evaluation of possible policies under that text. The second issue is whether or not the land area under consid- eration should be larger than the land area for which the Applicant has applied - the 30-acre parcel. Director Stevens stated that he feels there may be reason to look at a larger area than the 30-acre parcel. It may make some sense, but he felt you could look at this project as a transition from commercial on Tampico to Very High Density to High Density so, in this case, we are not recommending that you consider anything other than the Applicant's land area. Director Stevens addressed the second application as General Plan Amendment No. 86-010 from Drew Wright and Associates. It is a 40-acre parcel at the northeast corner of Washington and Sagebrush. As noted in the Staff Report, in addition to the land use amendment which would be from "Low Density Residential" (2-4 units per acre) to "Medium Density Residential" (4-8 units per acre). There are associated requests relative to a change of zone to a new zoning district to be developed that would make provision for some components of the development. In addition, there is a tentative tract map and a change of zone. Again, it would be our inten- tion to process these relatively simultaneously. In evaluating General Plan issues, we think there are several. The first one we discussed is surrounding land use and it is Staff's judgment that it would really be a "spot zoning" issue if we talked merely about the 40-acre parcel, as it would be an island of Medium Density MINUTES - PLANNING COMMISSION March 25, 1986 Page 4. surrounded by Low Density. Therefore, Staff feels it would be appropriate to expand the area of consideration to include the existing Sagebrush area tract coming all the way down and actually pick up the small parcel on the southeast corner of Avenue 50 and Washington down to the channel. It would create a more logical land use pattern should you choose to approve this request. Other General Plan related issues include the suggestion to consider whether or not you wish to have a policy included in the Infrastructure Element of the General Plan regarding private versus public streets. Currently, the Applicant is proposing that all local streets within the subdivision be dedicated as public streets. And, as of the present time, the City has not established any policy in this regard. Staff is concerned that long-term maintenance requirements on the City for public streets means that it should be an issue for us and we should consider estab- lishing a uniform policy in the General Plan for these types of projects and consider having a policy requiring these streets to be private. Staff believes that this would be an appropriate issue to consider with this pro- ject since this is the first such application that we have received. We also have some problems with this application relative to the Washington Street Specific Plan, although we make no recommendation nor think it appropriate to amend that plan or for the Commission to initiate such an amendment. We think that the issue can be dealt with in conditions of approval for the project. It is our understanding that, based on some recent dis- cussions with the Applicant, that this application may be withdrawn in favor of a development that would be in compliance with the General Plan Density of 4 units per acre. If that is the case, obviously we would not to proceed with any of the other issues at this time. The last application is General Plan Amendment No. 86-011 from M. B. Johnson Properties for property at the north- east corner of Washington and Avenue 48 which is the site of the "Isla Mediterranea" project. The Applicant is requesting a change from "High Density Residential" to "Mixed -Use Commercial". This property is bordered by the "Mixed -Use Commercial" both on the north and the east and has major streets on the opposite sides. In terms of the land area, Staff does not think it of any use to look at a larger land area than for what the Applicant has applied. We do think however, based on discussions with the Applicant related to the Highway Ill Bypass issue, that this may be the time to go ahead and consider the MINUTES - PLANNING COMMISSION March 25, 1986 Page 5. upgrading of Adams Street from a Secondary to a Major street and resolve that bypass issue. Director Stevens reiterated that the policy in the plan says that we will conduct a further study to determine whether Adams or Dune Palms between Avenue 48 and Highway 111 should be widened to accommodate this bypass. In summary, Director Stevens advised the Commission that Staff's recommendation with regard to this 1986 General Plan Review - Cycle I is as follows: a. GPA 86-009: * Consider amending the text of the Community Development Element to include a Very High Density Residential (16-24 units per acre) land use category including pertinent supportive policies. * Consider amending the Land Use Plan for the land area as requested by the Applicant. b. GPA 86-010: * Consider amending the Land Use Plan for the land area as requested by the Applicant and for the land area south of the Applicant's to and including the southeast corner of Washington Street and Avenue 50. * Consider amending the Infrastructure Element to establish a policy concerning public or private streets in new single-family subdivisions. c. GPA 86-011: * Consider amending the Land Use Plan for the land area as requested by the Applicant. * Consider amending the Circulation Plan and associated policies concerning the roadway classi- fication for Adams Street and the Highway Ill Bypass. Director Stevens advised the Commission that one of the things he did try to point out in the report that this is really a scoping type of session to make sure that we are dealing with the right scope of the General Plan issues. It is not really intended to be a pro or con discussion MINUTES - PLANNING COMMISSION March 25, 1986 Page 6. of the projects and Staff, very carefully, in the Staff Report tried not to indicate positions on any of the applications. He noted that Staff is also recommending that the Commission not initiate any amendment to the General Plan beyond those associated with these appli- cations so that we can get them through the process. This concluded Staff's report. There was a brief discussion among the Planning Commission concerning policies for the Very High Density Residential category, the Highway 111 Bypass and the expanded land area related to the Wright Associates application. It was the consensus of the Planning Commission to concur with the recommendations from Staff. Commissioner Moran stated in the "Very High Density" designa- tion, she would like to see the percentage spelled out with regard to the open space/recreational area on a case -by -case basis. She would also like to see a buffer between the "Mixed -Use Commercial" and single-family zoned areas. There being no further discussion, Chairman Thornburgh called for a motion. 2. Commissioner De Gasperin made a motion, seconded by Commissioner Walling, to agree with the Staff recommenda- tion as to each of the three General Plan Amendments, with the understanding that if any of the three Applicants withdraws their request, the Community Development Department not proceed to continue to consider that withdrawn application. Unanimously Adopted. ADJOURNMENT There being no further items of agenda to come before the Planning Commission, Commissioner Brandt made a motion, seconded by Commissioner Walling to adjourn to the next regular meeting of the Planning Commission to be held April 8, 1986, at 7:00 p.m., in the La Quinta City Hall, 78-105 Calle Estado, La Quinta, CA. The regular meeting of the Planning Commission of the City of La Quinta, CA was adjourned at 7:37 p.m., March 25, 1986, in the La Quinta City Hall, 78-105 Calle Estado, La Quinta, California. M I N U T E S PLANNING COMMISSION - CITY OF LA QUINT; A Regular Meeting Held at the La Quints City Hall, 78-105 Calle Estado, La Quinta, California. April 8, 1986 1. CALL TO ORDER 7:00 p.m. 4 n� A. Associate Planner Gary W. Price called the Planning Commission meeting to order at 7:00 p.m. 2. ROLL CALL A. Associate Planner Price called the roll. Present: Associate Planner Gary W. Price. Absent: Commissioners Brandt, De Gasperin, Moran, Walling, and Chairman Thornburgh 3. HEARINGS 4. CONSENT CALENDAR 5. BUSINESS 6. ADJOURNMENT There being no quorum present, Associate Planner Price adjourned this meeting to an adjourned meeting on April 14, 1986, at 12:00 noon, in La Quinta City Hall, 78-105 Calle Estado, La Quinta, CA. The regular meeting of the Planning Commission of the City of La Quinta, California, was adjourned at 7:10 p.m., April 8, 1986, at La Quinta City Hall, 78-105 Calle Estado, La Quinta, CA. ITEM NO. 4. DATE /A6 PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING RE: GASPERIN MDRkNr • + r ,r DISCUSSION: L..�. � � sue. • ' !� � ' 'sue:/ � ROLL CALL VOTE: COMMISSIONERS: UNANIMOUSLY ADOPTED: AYE NO YES ABSTAIN NO ABSENT PRESENT' TO: FROM: DATE: SUBJECT: LOCATION: APPLICANT: REQUEST: BACKGROUND MEMORANDUM CITY OF LA OUINTA 5. A The Honorable Chairman and Members of the Planning Commission Community Development Department April 22, 1986 PLOT PLAN NO. 86-295 Northeast Corner of Avenida Bermudas and Calle Estado Dan Edgar Approval to Construct a 3052 Sq.Ft. Bank Building 1. General Plan: a. Land Use Plan: Village Commercial (See Attachment No. 1). b. Circulation Plan: Avenida Bermudas, Secondary Arterial, 88-foot right-of-way. 2. Zoning: C-P-S, Scenic Highway Commercial (See Attachment No. 2). 3. Existing Conditions: The 9100 sq.ft. site is located in the Village at La Quinta area of the City. The adjacent lots are developed as follows: North - retail commercial building; East - office building; South - office building and nursery; and West - gas station and post office. Regarding public roadways, Avenida Bermudas is paved with curb only to a half -width of 30 feet. Calle Estado is paved with curb only to its full 50-foot, half -width. These existing curbs, which were constructed as a part of the original subdivision, are not consistent with current standards. The 20-foot-wide, public alley along the site's north boundary is paved to full width. Water, electric and phone service exist at the site. A natural gas main is located in the alley, but terminates approximately 100 feet east of the site; there is sufficient capacity to extend this main. Sewage disposal will be by a private on -site septic system. The property is located within the 100-year flood plain and is subject to flooding to a depth of three feet. STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 2. 4. Environmental Assessment: The project is categorically exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and a Notice of Exemption will be filed with the County Recorder. 5. Description of Request: The Applicant, who is a general contractor, is requesting approval to construct a 3052 sq.ft. building for a bank. The building is single story with approxi- mately 2160 sq.ft. of net usable area. Three teller windows are proposed. The main entrance will face towards Avenida Bermudas, with a second entrance on the north side adjoining the parking area and alley. The Applicant proposes Modern Spanish style architecture similar to the Milne Building located at the north side of the La Quinta Park. A "shed" roof style is proposed. The height of the building varies from 10 feet at the front or west side, to 25 feet at the rear or east side of the building. The shed roof will be covered with clay red flashed Mission tile, and the exterior walls will have light brown (San Simeon) stucco. Regarding the site design, the building is set back a minimum of 10-1/2 feet from the face of curb on Calle Estado, 39-1/2 feet from the Avenida Bermudas right-of-way, 22 feet from the alley right-of-way, and 0-foot setback from the east property line. Nine parking spaces are proposed on -site. The 3 spaces nearest Calle Estado will be accessed from Avenida Bermudas, with the remaining spaces accessed from the public alley. The driveway between the alley and the front parking area is 14 feet wide and one-way northbound. 6. Comments From Other Agencies a. City Engineer (1) The Applicant shall dedicate all necessary public street and utility easements. (2) The Applicant shall construct street improvements for half -width Avenida Bermudas, half -width Calle Estado, and the abutting alley to the requirements of the City Engineer and the La Quinta Municipal Code. (3) The Applicant shall prepare and submit street improve- ment plans. Improvements shall be to City Standards. (4) A grading plan shall be prepared by a Registered Civil Engineer and submitted to the City for review and approval. STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 3. (5) A preliminary geological and soils engineering investi- gation shall be submitted to the City in conjunction with the required grading plan. (6) Drainage disposal facilities shall be provided as required by the City Engineer. (7) Utilities shall be installed to City Standards. (8) Curb return radius shall be per City Standards with standard corner cutback dedication. Site plan to be modified accordingly. (9) Dedicate sidewalk easement along Calle Estado. (10) Curb and gutter to be constructed on Avenida Bermudas, curb only for Calle Estado starting at east ECR. Side- walks on both streets to City Standards. (11) wheel stops shall be installed in spaces adjacent to narrow sidewalks on north side of building. (12) Applicant shall pay all processing, plan checking and inspection fees. (13) Applicant acknowledges that City considering a City-wide Landscape and Lighting District and agrees to be included in the District. Any assessments will be done on a benefit basis. b. City Fire Marshal (1) Provide or show there exists a water system capable of delivering 2000 GPM fire flow for a 2-hour duration at 20 psi residual operating pressure. (2) Fire flow of 1000 GPM for a 2-hour duration at 20 psi residual operating pressure must be available before any combustible material is placed on the job site. (3) The required fire flow shall be available from a Super hydrant (6" x 4" x 2-1/1" x 2-1/2"), located not less than 25' nor more than 165' from any portion of the building as measured along approved vehicular travel - ways. (4) The required fire flow shall be available from any two adjacent on -site and off -site Super fire hydrants in the system located as specified in Item 3 above. STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 4. (5) Installation of an automatic fire protection system may lessen fire flow requirements. If hydrant lies more than 165' from any portion of the building, Applicant shall install an automatic fire protection system or upgrade current water system to meet the 165' requirement. (6) Install portable fire extinguishers as per NFPA Pamphlet #10. (7) Applicant shall be responsible to provide or show there exists conditions set forth by the Fire Department. (8) Final conditions to be addressed at Building Division plan check. C. Building Division - No Comment. d. La Quinta Chamber of Commerce - No Comment. e. Southern California Gas Company - No Comment. f. Comments were requested, but not received from Coachella Valley Water District, Imperial Irrigation District, General Telephone Company, and Riverside County Sheriff's Office. STAFF COMMENTS AND ANALYSIS Consistency with the General Plan and Zoning The proposed use is consistent with the General Plan Land Use designa- tion of Village Commercial. The use is also permitted by the C-P-S (Scenic Highway Commercial) Zone with plot plan approval. Site Plan Considerations Building Setbacks: The C-P-S Zone does not require building setbacks. However, because the edge of right-of-way along Calle Estado is at the curbline, the County and the City has required a minimum 10-foot set- back to provide adequate area for a sidewalk and landscaping. The building's minimum 10-1/2-foot setback from Calle Estado is consistent with this past policy. Parking and Circulation The Municipal Land Use Ordinance requires nine parking spaces for this office building having approximately 2160 net square feet, excluding public halls and the main lobby area. However, in this case, the standard seems inadequate, particularly as it appears that there will be 5-10 employees at the facility. Relatively few customer spaces would be left meaning that either employees or customers would have to 0 STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 5. regularly rely upon on -street parking or would overflow into adjacent developments. Regarding the design of the spaces, the end stalls in the front parking area must be widened from 9 feet to 11 feet, as required by Section 18.12 of the Municipal Land Use Ordinance. In order to comply with this standard, either the sidewalk adjacent to the building or the landscaping adjacent to Bermudas will have to be reduced; the site plan in this area is already "tight". As shown, the remainder of the spaces are in compliance with the ordinance's requirement of a minimum depth of 18 feet, minimum widths of 11 feet for end stalls and 9 feet for interior stalls, minimum setback of 3 feet from property lines and 5 feet from street right-of-ways. The 3-foot setback of the spaces along the north side of the site should be sufficient to ensure that parked vehicles do not extend into the alley. The 5-foot setback from street right-of-ways is required in order to provide landscaping between the parking area and the public street; the plan complies with this requirement. Access to the parking areas will be from the public alley and a driveway on Avenida Bermudas, in addition to a 14-foot-wide, on -site connecting driveway from the front parking area to the alley. The parking access and circulation is poorly designed and creates a number of unacceptable conflicts. These result from: * The offset alignment of the Bermudas driveway with existing Avenida Montezuma. * The close proximity of the Bermudas and alley driveways. The movement between two separate parking areas on a relatively small site. For example, vehicles backing out of any of the spaces in the front parking area would block ingress to it while maneuvering thereby creating a stacking problem within the Bermudas (and possibly Montezuma) right-of-way. Right turns out of the Bermudas driveway could conflict with left turns into or out of the alley driveway. There will be conflicts in the one-way, on -site connecting driveway. All of these can be corrected by an improved design while still allowing reasonable development of the site. However, it does appear that the entire project would need to be redesigned to remedy these conflicts. Nevertheless, the Bermudas-Estado-Montezuma intersection is an important part of the Village and effort should be made to avoid major conflicts of the sort that would result from this plan if it was approved. Site Grading The City currently requires that the floor level be a minimum of 3 feet above the highest point of the adjacent public roadways, in accordance with the requirements of FEMA for floor protection. STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 6. Although not shown explicitly on the site plan, the Applicant has stated that it is his intention to also raise the parking area 3 feet to avoid stairs at the building entrances. This site consideration will have a substantial effect on the overall appearance of this proposed development. Additional considerations which will be reviewed include maintaining intersection visibility (plantings and walls are limited to 42-inches from street level in the corner areas) the design and location of retaining walls, and the compatibility of the proposed pad level with respect to adjacent existing buildings. Building Design The building has a Modern Spanish style of architecture. The front faces out onto the west parking area and Avenida Bermudas, with a secondary entrance on the north side at the alley. The top of the roof line at the east wall of the building is 22 feet, with the architectural features extending up an additional 3 feet. As a point of comparison, the adjacent office building is 25-feet high at the roof peak on the second story. Staff has a number of concerns relative to the proposed building design, including: Should additional architectural features or embellishments be added to the side and rear building elevations, as has been required during previous Planning Commission review of single-family houses proposed for corner lots? Of particular concern is the side adjacent to Calle Estado and the rear of the building, which will also be visible from Calle Estado. Should the height of the building, which is 22-25 feet along the Calle Estado frontage, be reduced? Is the general style of architecture consistent or compatible with existing and anticipated development within the Village at La Quinta area? * Are the proposed materials and colors consistent or compatible with the existing and future development of the area? CONCLUSIONS 1. The proposed office use is consistent with the La Quinta General Plan designation of General Commercial. 2. The proposed site is in compliance with the requirements of the C-P-S Zone. STAFF REPORT - PLANNING COMMISSION April 22, 1986 Page 7. 3. The existing utilities are adequate or can be upgraded to provide for the needs of the office building. 4. Provided that the alley is improved, existing public roadways will adequately provide for off -site traffic circulation. 5. The existing site and parking design would result in major circu- lation problems warranting redesign of the project. 6. The Spanish style architecture and proposed building materials may be compatible with existing and future development in the area. 7. Approval of the project will not result in any significant environmental impacts. STAFF RECOMMENDATION The Community Development Department recommends that Plot Plan No. 86-295 be tabled and that the Applicant be directed to prepare revised plans which consider the following: * Elimination of driveway access (other than the alley) to Bermudas * Redesign of the on -site parking and circulation * Reevaluation of the building design The attached conditions of approval have been prepared in the event that the Commission intends to approve the project substantially as submitted. PREPARED BY: Sandra L. Bonner Principal Planner SLB:LLS:dmv Atch: 1. Conditions of Approval 2. Exhibits A, B and C APPROVED BY: 10 �_ lzt4L //Lawrence L. Stevens, AICP Community Development Director Ll • • • • • • • • ••••• • • • • • •'1'•'•••••••'I'••• •••••••'••I••' ••. . . •• ••• NO. 1 General Plan El CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL April 22, 1986 FIRST NATIONAL BANK OF LA QUINTA DAN EDGAR General 1. The development of the site and building shall comply with approved Exhibits A, B and C, as contained in the Community Development Department's file for Plot Plan No. 86-295 and the following conditions, which conditions shall take precedence in the event of any conflict with the provisions of the site and building plans. 2. This approval is construction of a building for use as a bank. Any change in the occupancy different from the approved use shall require prior City approval to ensure compliance with the parking standards and any other requirements of adopted City plans and ordinances in effect at the time of occupancy change. 3. Plot Plan No. 26-295 shall comply with the standards and require- ments of the La Quinta Land Use Ordinance unless otherwise modified by the following conditions. 4. This approval shall be used within two (2) years after final proceedings before the La Quinta Community Development Director; otherwise, it shall become null and void and of no effect whatso- ever. The term "use" shall mean the beginning of substantial construction of permanent buildings (not including grading) authorized by this permit, which construction shall thereafter be pursued diligently to completion. 5. Prior to the issuance of a building permit for construction of any use contemplated by this approval, the Applicant first shall obtain permits and/or clearances from the following public agencies: * City Engineer * City Fire Marshal * City Community Development Department, Planning Division * Riverside County Environmental Health Department Evidence of said permit or clearance from the above agencies shall be presented to the Building Division at the time of application for a building permit for the use contemplated herewith. Building Design 6. The building shall be constructed in accordance with the approved Exhibits B and C contained within the Community Development Department's file for Plot Plan No. 86-295. 7. The type and colors of the exterior building materials shall be in accordance with the approved Exhibit C and materials sample board. ir, CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL April 22, 2986 Page 2. FIRST NATIONAL BANK OF LA QUINTA All roof -mounted equipment shall be screened from view on all sides by the roof structure. Site Design (Grading Parking Circulation Streets) 9. The Applicant/Developer shall comply with the following require- ments of the City Engineer: a. The Applicant shall dedicate all necessary public street and utility easements as required by the City Engineer. b. That the Applicant shall construct street improvements for 1/2-width Avenida Bermudas, 1/2-width Calle Estado, and abutting alley to the requirements of the City Engineer and the La Quinta Municipal Code (LQMC). C. That the Applicant shall have prepared street and alley improvement plans that are prepared by a Registered Civil Engineer. Street and alley improvements, including traffic signs and markings, and raised median islands (if required by the City General Plan) shall conform to City Standards as determined by the City Engineer and adopted by the LQMC. (3" AC over 4" Class 2 Base minimum for residential streets.) Street design shall take into account the subgrade soil strength, the anticipated traffic loading, and street design life. d. The Applicant shall have prepared a grading plan that is prepared by a Registered Civil Engineer, who will be required to supervise the grading and drainage improvement construc- tion; and certify that the constructed conditions at the rough grade stage are as per the approved plans and grading permit. This is required prior to issuance of building permits. Certification at the final grade stage and verifi- cation of pad elevations is also required prior to final approval of grading construction. e. A thorough preliminary engineering geological and soils engineering investigation shall be done and the report submitted for review along with the grading plan. The reports recommendations shall be incorporated into the grading plan design prior to grading plan approval. The soils engineer and/or the engineering geologist must certify to the adequacy of the grading plan. f. Drainage disposal facilities shall be provided as required by the City Engineer. CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL - FIRST NATIONAL BANK OF LA QUINTA April 22, 1986 Page 3. g. All utilities will be installed and trenches compacted to City Standards prior to construction of any streets. The soils engineer shall provide the necessary compaction test reports for review by the City Engineer. h. The Applicant shall pay the required processing, plan checking and inspection fees as are current at the time the work is being accomplished by City personnel or subcontractors for the Planning, Building, or Engineering Divisions. i. The Applicant acknowledges that the City is considering a City -Wide Landscape and Lighting District and . agrees to be included in the district. Any assessments will be done on a benefit basis as required by law. j. Curb return radius at Avenida Bermudas/Calle Estado shall be in accordance with City Standards with the standard corner cutback dedication. The site plan shall be modified by the City Engineer to ensure adequacy for traffic safety and compatibility with existing street improvements along Avenida Bermudas. k. A sidewalk easement shall be dedicated along Calle Estado. 1. Curb and gutter shall be constructed along Avenida Bermudas, curb only along Calle Estado starting at the east ECR. 10. Parking shall be provided in accordance with the approved Exhibit A and the requirements of Section 18.12 of the Municipal Land Use ordinance: a. End stalls in the westerly parking area shall be increased to a minimum width of 11 feet. b. Wheel stops shall be installed in the north parking area to prevent vehicles overhanging the pedestrian walkway. C. Landscaping and striping of the parking area shall be in accordance with Section 18.12. 11. The on -site driveway connecting the alley and the west parking area shall be designated as "One -Way" northbound by signage and pavement markings in accordance with the requirements of the City Engineer. 12. Parking shall be restricted, through signage or other means (as approved by the City Engineer) to only those designated parking spaces shown on Exhibit A. Necessary signage shall be installed prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy. None of the El CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL - FIRST NATIONAL BANK OF LA QUINTA April 22, 1986 Page 4. required parking spaces shall be designated as reserved for any exclusive use, except for the handicapped space. 13. The grade of the parking areas shall remain substantially as they exist and they shall not be raised to the 3-foot FEMA level required for the building pad. Public Services and Utilities 14. Fire protection shall be required in accordance with the City of La Quinta codes and ordinances in effect at the time of building permit issuance: a. Provide or show there exists a water system capable of delivering 2000 GPM fire flow for a 2-hour duration at 20 psi residual operating pressure. b. A fire flow of 1000 GPM for a 2-hour duration at 20 psi residual operating pressure must be available before any combustible material is placed on the job site. C. The required fire flow shall be available from a Super fire hydrant, (6" x 4" x 2-1/2" x 2-1/211), located not less than 25 feet or more than 165 feet from any portion of the building as measured along approved vehicular travelways. d. A combination of on -site and off -site Super fire hydrants, (6" x 4" x 2-1/2" x 2-1/211), will be required located not less than 25 feet or more than 165 feet from any portion of the building as measured along approved vehicular travelways. The required fire flow shall be available from any 2 adjacent hydrant(s) in the system. e. Install portable fire extinguishers as per NFPA, Pamphlet #10. f. Other: Installation of an automatic fire protection system may lessen fire flow requirements. If hydrant lies more than 165' from any portion of the building, Applicant shall install an automatic fire protection system or upgrade current water system to meet 165' requirement. g. Applicant/developer shall be responsible to provide or show there exists conditions set forth by the Fire Department. h. Final conditions will be addressed when building plans are reviewed in Building and Safety. CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL - FIRST NATIONAL BANK OF LA QUINTA April 22, 1986 Page 5. 15. Water service shall be provided in accordance with the require- ments of the City of La Quinta and the Coachella Valley Water District. 16. Sewage disposal shall be provided by an on -site septic system installed in accordance with the standards and requirements of the City of La Quinta and the Riverside County Health Department. The system shall be designed so as to facilitate future hookup to community sewer lines. 17. All on -site utilities shall be installed underground. Miscellaneous 18. Prior to the issuance of building permits, the Applicant shall submit to the Community Development Department, Planning Division, for review and approval, a plan (or plans) showing the following: a. Landscaping, including plant types, sizes, spacing and locations. b. Landscape irrigation system. c. Location and design detail of any proposed walls. d. Location and design of sidewalks and walkways on -site and adjacent to Calle Estado and Avenida Bermudas. e. Exterior lighting plan. f. Location and design of walled enclosure for trash bin. The approved landscaping and improvements shall be installed prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy. The landscaping shall be maintained in a healthy and viable condition for the life of the project. 19. Desert or native plant species and drought resistant planting materials shall be incorporated into the landscaping plans for the site. 20. A trash enclosure shall be provided as follows: a. The enclosure shall be located as shown on approved Exhibit A. b. The size and dimensions of the enclosure shall be in accordance with the standards of Palm Desert Disposal Company. The walls and gates shall be 6-feet high. 'Il, CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL - FIRST NATIONAL BANK OF LA QUINTA April 22, 1986 Page 6. c. The enclosure shall be constructed of slumpstone or of concrete block with finish to match the building. The gates shall be constructed of materials to completely screen the interior of the enclosure, excepting that wood materials or slats woven into chainlink type fencing are not permitted. The floor shall be concrete with raised curb adjacent to the walls. d. A minimum 5-foot-wide, concrete apron extending the entire length of the front of the enclosure shall be installed. 21. Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the Applicant shall submit a sign plan showing the location, type, size, colors and type of illumination (if any) of all proposed identification and directional signs. Identification signs shall be limited to building name or directory type signs. All on -site traffic directional or informational signs shall be installed in accordance with the approved plan prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy. 22. Temporary construction or trades signs may be installed on -site as a part of this plot plan approval. The sign plans shall be reviewed and approved by the Planning Division, and the Applicant shall obtain a building permit for installation of the sign in accordance with the requirements of the Building Division. 23. Prior to the issuance of building permits, the Applicant shall comply with the city's adopted requirements regarding infra- structure fees for Public Facilities and Buildings. 24. Prior to the issuance of building permits, the Applicant shall apply for a Parcel Merger.