04-4021 (DSF)BUILDING & SAFETY DEPARTMENT
P.O. Box 1.504 (760),;777-7012
78-495 CALLE TAMPICO FAX (760) 777-7011
LA QUINTA, CALIFORNIA 92253 INSPECTION REQUESTS (760) '777-7153
BUILDING PERMIT
Application Number . . .
Property Address
APN:
Application description
Property Zoning . . . . .
Application valuation .
64 - GO GO 02.1
49130 EISENHOWER DR
658•--290-006-117 -000
DEMO - &INGLE FAMILY
LOW DENSITY RESIDENT
. 0
Date 5./10/04
e
MAY 10 2004
Owner Contractor I FINANGCucri.
MAZZELLA ANNE J EMERY LAND CLEARING & GRAD INC
4 E 64TH ST P.O. BOX 10'09
NEW YORK NY 10021 THERMAL CA 92274
(760) 391-5840
WCC: STATE FUND
WC: 116532.004 04/12/05
CSLB: 600283 11/30/05
CCC: C21
Other struct info . . . . NUMBER OF UNITS 1.00
_Permit . . . . DEMO PERMIT
Additional d_esc .
Permit Fee . . . 45.00 Plan Check Fee .00
Issue Date . . . . Valuation . . . . 0
Qty Unit Charge Per Extension
BASE FEE 45.00
Special Notes and Comments
DEMO OF SWIMMING POOL AND HOUSE TO BARE
GROUND, INCLUDING SEPTIC ABANDONEMENT.
Fee summary Charged Paid Credited Due
Permit Fee Total 45.'00 .00 .00 45.0.0
Plan Check Total .00 .00 .00 .00
Grand Total 45.00 .00 .00 45.00
P -O. BOX 1.504 � VOICE (760) 777-7012
Tur
78-493 CALLE TAMPICO FAX (760) 777-7011
LA QUINTA, CALIFORNIA 92253 INSPECTIONS (760) 777-7153
BUILDING & SAFETY DEPARTMENT
Application Number: '024-770-v Date' -5 01'.'
Applicant: Architect or ineer:
Applicant's Mailing Address: Architect o En ineer's Address:
Lic. No:
BUILDING PERMIT DECLARATIONS
LICENSED CONTRACTOR'S DECLARATION
I hereby affiim.under penalty of perjury'fhat I am lice�ed under provisions of Chapter 9 (commencing with Section 7000) of Division 3 of the Business and Professionals
Code, and my License is in full force and effect.
!0
I hereby affirm under penalty of perjury that I am.exempt :from the ContrsctoW State License Law for the following reason (Sec, 7031,.6. Bushess and Prolessions`Code: Any
city or county that requires a permit to construct, alter. Improve. demolish, or repair any structure, prior to its Issuance, also requires the applicant for the permit to file a signed
statement that.he or she Is licensed pursuant to the provisions of the Contractors` State License Law (Chapter 6 (commencing with Section 7000) of Division 3 of the Business
and Profeaslons Code) or that he or she is exempt thetefrom.and the basis for the alleged exemption. Any violation of Section 7031.5 by any applicant fora,psmdt subjects
the applicant to a civil penalty of not more than five hundred dollars ($500)J -
U, I, as owner of the property, or my employees with wages as their sole compensation, will do.the work, and. the structure Is not lnkwwW or offered for sale (Sec. 7044,
Business and Professions,Code: The Contractors' State License. Law does not apply to an owner of property who builds or improves thereon. and who: does the work
himself or herself or through his or her own employees. provided that the improvements are not untended or offered for sale. if. however, the building or improvement is
sold within one year of completion; the owner -builder will have the burden of proving that he or she did not build or improve for the purpose of sale.).
U 1, as owner oftheproperty, am exclusively contracting with licensed contractors to construct the project (Sec. 7044; Business and.Pnofessions Code: The Contractors'
State License Law does not apply to an owner of property who builds or -improves thereon, and who contracts for the projects with a contractor(s) licensed pursuant to
the Contractors' State License Law.).
U 1 am exempt,under See. B.& P.C. for this reason
Date � ,Owner .
WORKERS' COMPENSATION DECLARATION
I hereby affirm under penalty of perjury one of the following declarations:
_ I.he" and will maintain a_certificate of.consent to self4nsure for workers' compensation, as provided for by Section 3700 of the Labor Code, for the performance
of. the work for which this pernit'is issued.
%7 1 have and will maintain workers' compensationiiosurance. as required by Section 3700 of Labe Code, for the performance of the work for vrhkh this gem* is
tte last, - My workers' compensation insurance carrier polio rlymber are -
Carrier. .S T^7-07�'r/.✓� Policy Number G
_ I'cerfffy that, in the performance of the workfor which permit is°issued I not amployany person in any manner;so as to become subject to the workers'
compensation laws of California, and agree that if I cold s to tie workers' compensation provisions ot:Section 3700 of the Labor Code,1 shall
�j comply with those provisions:
n� J li" I U l enrr�. f may •
WARNING: FAILURE TO SECURE WORKERS' COMPENSATION COVERAGE IS UNLAWFUL, AND'6aALL SUBJECT AN EMPLOYER TO CRIMINAL PENALTIES AND
CIVIL FiNES UP TO' ONE HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS ($100,000), IN ADDITItNI TO THE COST OF COMPENSATION, DAMAGES ASPROVIDED FOR IN
SECTION 3706 OF THE LABOR CODE, INTEREST, AND ATTORNEY'S FEES.
CONSTRUCTION LENDING AGENCY
I hereby affirm under penalty ofperj that there is a construction tion lending agency for ft performance of the work for which this permit to Issued,(Sec. 3097. CN. C.).
Lenders Name
Lenders Address
APPLICANT ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
IMPORTANT Application is hereby made to the Director of Building and Safety for a permit subject io the conditions and restrictions set forth"on alis application.
I. - Each person uponwhose behalf this application is made. each parson at.wtose request -and for whose benefit worts is performed under or pursuant to any permit
issued as a result of this application, the owner, and the applicant, each agrees to, and shall, defend. Indemnity, and hold harmless the City of Le CuiMa. Its
officers, agents and employees for any act or omission related to the work being performed under or following issuance of this perryk
2 wiArty Permit issued as a result of this application becomes nuti.and if work is not commenced within 160 days from date of issuance of such pemrit, or
cessation of work for 180 days will subject permit to cancellation.
I certifythat l have read this_appiicabon and state that the above infomretion bV1 with all city and county ordinances and state laws relating to building
oonsbuctio .and hereb�ylauthorize representatives of this countyto u toe ed forinspection purposes.
Data (7 ` Signature (Applicant or Agerd)•_
4/29/03
P.O. Box 1504
78-49'5 CALLE TAMPICO
LA QUINTA, CALIFORNIA 92253
Ms. Anne J. Mazzella
49-130 Eisenhower Drive
La Quinta, CA 92253
RE: 49-130 Eisenhower Drive Demolition
Dear Ms. Anne J. Mazzella,
BUILDING & SAFETY DEPARTMENT
(760).777-7012
FAX (760) 777-7011
The unoccupied single family dwelling structure is determined to be in an unsafe
condition. The rear patio is partially fallen and likely to fail or to become detached and
collapse in high winds or earthquake in the condition observed. The structure is in such a
condition as to constitute a public nuisance.
This letter serves as notification for the immediate asbestos removal and demolition of
the�single family dwelling due to unsafe conditions and site contamination. Please follow
the following demolition requirements;
• Submit an asbestos survey and demolition permit application to the Building
Department
Provide evidence of South Coast Air Quality Management District
Notification (AQMD)
Obtain Building Department demolition permit
Submit asbestos removal documentation prior to Building Department final
inspection.
Please contact me at (760) 777-7027 for any questions and/or assistance. Thank you.
Sincerely,
4anie/P.ra E r.
Building Inspector II
La Quinta Golf Estates
Community Association
Architectural Committee
P.O. Box 553
La Quinta, CA 92253
(760) 564-0136
April 20, 2004
Mr. David Howard
Cherokee Homes
73-180 Highway 11l
Palm Desert, CA 92260
Dear Mr. Howard:
The Architectural Committee for the La Quinta Golf Estates Community Association has
reviewed your letter dazed April 19, 2004 outlining the,plans to demolish the structure,
west property block wall, driveway, patios, and pool located at 49-130 Eisenhower Drive.
This letter is to advise -you that we have approved them
Please rememberthat the approval is for these plans only and if you make changes to
your plans they will have to be resubmitted for approval.
Yours truly, '
'e D. Woods
Architectural Committee
!16/2004 FRI 11.08 FAI 12-122232040 clm properties inc
•ta
""Mu�aEffiNOR
AN, MIM 114COVOID PWI. MS ttEM AM UMZU
CJI 'RW'= 'HOW SELOW, bUtL TAC STAT61 WMt3M
Anne Y. MamBa
4, Fast 64th Street
New York, NY 10021
A.p.N M-290-006.0
V03/005
DOG N 2000--466598
11/MW90 98':00A Fee.B,.00
PVW i of Z Cnc t TAN Paid
Recorded in Official Records
Catintty of Riverside
Cary L. Ors*
Assessor, County Clark i Raaerder
1111111 Jill
1111
W- I so1CA1M=,1wmIowI&W—
TWO Order No. 20591634
Ztemw,or Loan No. IW1464WA
GRANT DEED
Imo; UMMMONI3D OLAMOR(g) D �)
D0CU AJKY TRANSPBRTAX is S 330.00 Crry TAX
0 cvmPuw of &a value ofpfoPerty coaveyed, or
p Wnfu don fnli value lass value of Hens of emunbmnces rcmoiuing at titae ofule,
0 UmncaapOMcd atca: Cityof 1Qlt3uta
� caw
FOR A VALUABLE CONM]U A710N bmvby wJmewl d F=4 0
Wife as Joint Tooam; ' mceipt of which '(lsac(y and Iarita U'Cuady Huabaad
Y GLOUiiS) t0 A= L Matz & A Married woman; as Her Sots gad separa0e Property;
*6 following _dc6mibed progeny, is the County of RIYBRSIDB. Stats of Calif
or,a:
Lot 114 and 117 OfTraat Map Book 37/9fr96_La.Qalnta Golf.gatases Ng.,
98 in BMW mop recorded m Book 37, Pages 46.97 . and
the CfRce Oftbo Ct»mty'llecorder of Riverside.Cmmiy.
Dated: October:27, 2000
State of4l Vftim X.11—
Of
11
SS.
on ! ' � before am, a
petsonau'y icrtown to'me (Or pied to are On the basis of ry
evidcace) to bo the pason(t}'whose >sama(a) rales aubscaibcd to the
wmdu kmmmet mod acbwMedgcd ov me that beJidwMky mcuted
the iblm�suthotiaed tapadiy(iea}, and that by hial w
E5����Ensftwnmnt
mw the payem(s� or.the mdwupon
a(i) ecttd. ax¢vvted the tnsftw»
�r0 0 v,j�./
_ !' •t.
l� .i i.11�,�*,
et
i
e
1<alaq�iDtilwRain blraw
dads
��itldt�!
Mu—sm for tsfficid MALewma)
TAX STAT09;N'TSt AS D� A$OVE
X04/16/ ff0 FRI-,,.11:08 FAX 12122232040 c1m propetfi:8'49c'
Louis Mazzella & Anne I Mazzella - -
April 1612004
Cherokee Homes
73-180 Highway 111
Palm'Desert, CA 92260
Attn:,,Don How W
'Re. Demolition of Eisenhower Dr. House
Dear Mr. Howard:
This is a latta of authorization for your Company Cherokee Home to perform the
demolition of the above-mentioned house.
Yourfum b to demolish the house and cart It away, and then to grade and scod
the lot after completion.
If them is anything else that you may need please fool five to call me at either the
California or the Florida numbers, d=k you,
Very Truly YOUM
Aare E LOU MaM41i
@002/005
APR -15-04 09:53 AM CHEROKEE HOMES
7603410946
Cety of La Qu
inta
Developers PM -10 Approval Form
P.01
Prior to the issuance of a Demolition permit for the project llsled below, Public Worb
APPro>al must be obtained. Please return this form to the Building and Suety bepartment
only 4ftrapproval.
Project Address: — (3 ��rt �'l b uxe
Applicant,Nameftone#: i
Scope Of Work:
To [hpit dust at this jobsite 1 will:
Maintain Adequate Watering at. All Times.
Prevent Trackout
Tarp All Vehicles Removing Debris from Site
�,a - ft—Vork in high Wind Conditions
SVS Ftrip
oalc To BE dvmP1�m) 1of x'-10 L(i'mluaec C��s
--
go.
0
Publie Works
Is Hereby granted:
•4ry1
:G
I
14
tt.
SOUTH COAST AIR QUALITY MANAGEMENT DISTRICT
NOTIFICATION OF DEMOLITION .OR ASBESTOS REMOVAL
(NAIL FORM AND FEE TO SCACMD. ASBESTOS NOTIFICATIONS. FILE # 59841. LOS ANGELES CA 90074.9641
T P
At�NB'USE ONLY ski 61r . RCENED3 TMARK s t i BFERED1r b1EmFlcAnoN
COMPLETED BY COMPANY EMERY LANDCLFA, RING PHONE 76Ml-5840
LORI EMERY V.P. AND GRADING, INC.
DATE 51" CHECK # 1283 FEE $ 118.41, PROJECT #
NOTIFICATION TYPE
ORIGM REVOw DATB Rmm Ong (hWghq CANcaLAnoN
PROJECT TYPE
DEaa.moN Ogma Darolrrran. RENOVATM (lanov* EMERGENCY REMOVAL RANm RENO (ammo
SITE INFORMATION
SITE NAME
SITE ADDRESS 49=130 EISENHOWER DRIVE CROSS STREET COACHELLA DRIVE
CITY LA QUINTA STATE CALIF. ZIP .92263 COUNTY RIVERSIDE
DESCRIBE WORK AND LOCATION DEMOLISH HOUSE LA QUINTA COUNTRY CLUB
BUILDING SIZE (SQ FT) 1800 NUMBER OF FLOORS 1 BUILDING AGE ffARS) 20 NUMBER OF DWELLING UNITS 1
BLDG PRIOR/ PRESENT USE
cm wmm HOsfAL IwDwTm 00m Owe Plmcam SMM SNP UMVrAU E
SITE OWNER MS. ANNE J. MAZZELLA ADDRESS 49-130 EISENHOWER DRIVE:
CITY LA QUINTA STATE CA ZIP 92253 CONTACT MR. DON HOWARD PHONE 7OV341-0920
REQUIRED BUILDING
INFORMATION
ASBESTOS YES NO I
PRESENT?
ASBESTOS YES NO
SURVEY? '
ASBESTOS YES NO
REMOVE`D7
BUILDING TO BE YES NO
DEMOLISHED?
PROJECT DATES
START l 1
END, WORK SHI ng, nlgtM
ASBESTOS AMOUNT TO BE
LOVED (n square foo
FRIABLE
CLASS I
CLASS II
TOTAL AMOUNT (add MW)
ASBESTOS REMOVAL FROM
SURFACES PIPES COMPONENTS
AMOUNT OF EACH TYPE OF
ASBESTOS (m square"
ACOUSTIC CEILING
LINOLEUM
INSULATION-
FIREPROOFING
DUCTING
STUCCO �
MASTIC
FLOOR TILES (VAT)
DRYWALL
PIASTER
TRANSITE
ROOFING
OTHER
CONTRACTOR INFORMATION
CSLB LICENSE# 600283 OSHA REG# AQMD ID # 100435
NAME EMERY LANDCLEARING AND GRADING, INC. ADDRESS P.O. BOX 1009
CITY THERMAL STATE CA ZIP 92274 SITE SUPVR JAMES C. EMERY PHONE 760x/749493
WASTE TRANSPORTER #1
LANDFILL
ADDRESS
ADDRESS
CITY
STATE
FZI
CITY
STATE
ZIP
* Asbestos surveys are required oft to Demolition and Renovation
..
SCAQMD NOPHCATION OF DEDOLATION OR ASBESTOS REMOVAL
PUL FORM AND FEE TO SCAOMD, ASBESTOS NOTIFICATIONS, FILE # 59641, LOS ANGELES CA 9W745841
WASTE TRANSPORTER #2
WASTE'STORAGE SITE
ADDRESS
ADDRESS
CITY STATE ZIP
CITY STATE ZIP
CONTROLS: DESCRIBE WORK PRACTICES AND CONTROLS TO BE USED AT THE RENOVATION AND: DEMOLITION SITE. Pmcedure # 1, 2, 3, 4, S cr Odw...
For asbestos rarramis circle the coreft alum of Rude 1403 procedures used Procedure.4 and 5 submit plans fcr Atm Prior approval
ASBESTOS DETECTION Pte: CIRCLE THE PROCEDURES AND ANALYTICAL METHODS USED TO DETERMINE ASBESTOS IN THE BUILDING:
Srrm, Bulk Sarrmlma hlsper dm. PLM, PCM, TEM, Assrmed as Asbeslos-PALM, Describe Oftw-
FOR ONC LITION$.GIVE THE COMPANY NAME AND DATES OF THE ASBESTOS REMOVAL BRICKLEY EWRONMENTAL I d
FOR OROERED DEMOLITION SEND ACOPY OF THE ORDER AND GIVE THE AGENCY NAME & PHONE # CITY OF LA QUINTA 7OWM-7027
AUTHORIZING PERSON: MR. DANIEL P. CRAWFORD JR. TITLE BUILDING INSPECTOR I
DATE OF ORDER: 4128104 DATE ORDERED TO BEGIN: Sl6(04
FOR ENStGENCY ASBESTOS"REMOVAL GIVE THE NAME MID S40W NUMBER OF THE PERSON DECW211GIAUTHORIZING THE EMERGENCY; DATE AND HOUR OF
EMERGWY AND DESCRIBE THE SUDDEN, UNELECTED EVENT: PROCEDURE fly RiK2U.EY DIVIRONMENTAL
EXPLAIN NOW THE. EVENT' WOULD CAUSE UNSAFE CONDITIONS, EWPM ENT DAMAGE OR,UNREASONABLF FINANCIAL BURDEN:'
PATIO PARTIALLY FALLEN - UNSAFE CONDITIONS
CONTINGENCY PLAN: DESCRIBE ACTIONS TO BE.FOLLOWED JF UNEXPECTED ASBESTOS IS FOUND DURING DEMOLITION OR ASBESTOS MATERIAL BECOME
DISTURBED,, CRUMBLED, PULVERIZED, OR REDUCED TO POWDER
STOP PROJECT,iHAVE cenrim ASBESTOS OVAL toNTRAO'TOR REMOVE AND DISPOSE OF.
TRAINING CERTIFICATION: I cm* l 0 an k diMW trairred'tn the pmmelorm of reglMm AQMD Rude 1403 and NESH AP vAlf be on sited ft the removal and
evWmm #ret the mg ed trai ft hes been a000rr byft pwm w61 befor irlspention during ra n busirs.
abble rre� hou.
Corrip" Name EMERY Pdrdrm, oromwhpoW Sigm- tune Tittle of omer4walor Dale6
UANDCLEARING AND .LORI EMERY
GRADING, INC. VICE PRESIDENT
INFORMATION CERTIFICATION: I oertitjrthat the stxxrearAm Mm is oomect u d I have orudased a stMdnneMs_
CwWM Name EMERY Print m ofamerkpwator of Time of aenerkperator Da
LANDCLEARING AND LORI EMERY C ER r h
GRADING, INC. V J V
GR3
am,not be accepted wftm tie re*w tee (AQMD a 301). Admics'mmvals oQm flan 100 sqn s feet are exempt from mon and fees.
Please make choft payable to-"SCAQMD'. Fees we perm, not mbxk bte, and vary wmr ft to #w project sim Fees are as fdlow.
DEMOIITION.OR ASBESTOS REMOVAL PROCEDURE 4 OR 5 PLAN $ 33121
FROM 100 TO 1,000 SQUARE FEET $ 29.52 SPECIAL HANDLING FEE $28.17
FROM 1,001 TO 5,000 SQUARE FEET $ 90.24 REVISION OF NOTIFICATION $11.94
FROM 5,0011010,WD SQUAD FEET $211.22 RETURNED CHECK CHARGE $`29.28
MORE THAN 10,000 SQUARE FEET $33121 CANCELLATION OF NOTF=TION $ 0.0
DEMOLITION OF LESS THAN 100 SQ'FT $ 29.52 ASBESTOS REMOVAL AT omm $ 29.52
'MNL FORM AND FEE TO, SCACANX ASBESTOS NOTIFICATIONS, FILE # 55641, LOS ANGELES CA 900746641 Page 2 of 2
TELEPHONE: M 398.= FAX (909) 398,'1342 Form REV 20030827
FORMS, INSTRUCTIONS,.ANDTHE.RULE 1403 CAN BE OBTAINED FROMAQMD:WEBSITEAT HTTP://WWW.AQN4D.GOV
ePAnUn I- • .a 71RM C f f Ja o Mkm rtionw%A Dor PA 047RC A1A7 10M% Q0R'X M
z
(D
�Me LotjdCLOkrin�
�(5pI1��1q�2?4
IS
------------------ -
--------------------
FROM : BR I 6<LEY B#J I RONMEtvTAL FAY N0. : 909 3s31 3433 May. 04 2004 03: 36FM P_
4
Environmental Remediation Contractor
FAX COVER SHEET
DATE: May 3, 2004 TIME: 2:08 PM
TO: SOUTH COAST A. Q. M. D. PHONE: 909.398-3 9
ATTN: MOHAN NAGAVEDE FAX: 909-396-3342
FROM. KERI HEIL
RE: PROCEDURE 5 ;NOTIFICATION
MOHAN:
ATTACHED IS A PROCEDURE 5 NOTIFICATION FOR YOUR REVIEW. WE WOULD LIKE TO START
THE WORK SOMETIME THIS WEEK PENDING YOUR APPROVAL.
ONCE APPROVED, BRICKLEY ENVIRONMENTAL WILL SUBMIT THE PROCEDURE 5 ALONG WITH
THE SCAQMD NOTIFICAT ION FORM AND APPLICABLE FEES.
IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS OR NEED ANYTHING, FURTHER PRIOR TO ISSUING AN
APPROVAL #, PLEASE CONTACT IAN GORDON OR MYSELF.
THANK YOU.
VHEIL
ECT ADMINISTRATOR
IF YOU HAVE DIFFICULTYREADING ANY OF THE FOLLOWING PAGES,
OR HAVE ANY QUESTIONS REGARDING THIS TRANSMISSION,
PLEASE CALL OUR OFFICE AS SOONAS POSSIBLE.
Number of pages including cover sheer 4
857 W. Reece Street. San 9emardho, CA 92411., Uc. No. 610414 CAL/OSHA No, 49
909,888.2010 .800.530-3366 FAX 909.361-3433
ENVIRONMENTAL FAX N0: :;909.381.3433 May. 04 2034 03:36PM P3
09:5e 9Ql9g806628 PAGE,03
General Environmental,
.3o, MW
somCowAir Ckwov �
AM., Mr., Mahan UNROVodu
2,1905f.. Copley Ddw
DIanWd emr, CA:97765
fs Pr+duh 54t
VOCIInt PmPerly
County of Ahmi"
49130 E smheywsr Drive
Lm tom, CA MO
Dear Mr. Nago wu-
VIS . to► h lMbnnpdon in compowm wkh ftb
14(1X01)(B)M. V" Mquest Your WOW. OoMmerb and .subsecpant approvml
so ft pry may canmi ". Piaase na'I )UR %Wballlc so khat VA an tm
tftftd ttpht away.
Should yaa hM SOY qumft s. A1sW & $Kd hssbft ft e ct ins.
4.
J � JohPaon.
GettllW AsbW
GEMS SwVkms
Consultant. 92.0698
UOZ0 Arraw,Rcute, Suite 105, ftmho Cucsrnonpa, CA. 917.
(100) 886-2589 0 Obx (W9)980-6628
ENUIRONMSJTAL FAX NO. :909 3E1 3433 May. 04 "2004 03:35PM P4
12147 9999806029 PAS 02
General Environmental ;
Manavaement sir vie ma ,
PV=EDUR 5 APPLICATHM & I ORMATMN
LCICATION: 5F -- i1Ml�C�li�iEGi
CQUtt W QP R1nU DE
am i. MVS"
LA QUWA, C:A am
't . biStanr of std: The subject Slee is a single V" home IOCRW. In the La
Quints 4Y olub d rent The aippr a sge of the home is 30
Yeem• The have is vacantfor dernoMon pulp • Somefte befteen ft
dMO OOwpanbs v=DW !It@ dwMM atbco:a Month "o,WW 0* tUrte the
dwnoMjon ortwty showed up, a Polon or pefmons unknOPPown Improperly f�DA1oV0d
�t►' eR• fit. of roofing tlIe and aev+nnsly darti'wged to path cover resuftlng
InirOpprco(e Esq. fL of e�ebean c orfthWq JIMstee
to be red about the
Z. - ; n apri a9, 2Ernilr � Occur at the stru�e wft
esbalt rod by h t apk ' at &iddey merdsl, The inspection MM is veers
verbally p Ph�OgraPhicaNy mportd fe GENA SeW4" (800 attaahed
Rho�opnrphe). I'M ebtrature wn toured to bb It t6t
at the marof fthouse. The ft for tie exr� br the prpo overttang
A In a Oave in. Approx ° ha been rs�MMAd
ep.1t of rooming % t coat oldatrved to be
Win! around the khmeduft area. lira ff t 19 known to be asbestae
�nialNng f rm a bulk sample SUN" analysie Provided by Soott morrkron and
As®ociS�es (see Vii,
3.
fton the cone petip ane Sewn is ePP=. 400
ma�flrtp fGIL Around the chlrnne and eve erbt
Of W, maw which Is notd ,110 MO wM be 75 lira�etr R
cmiundion with ft r Ing ieft debdL Contamkmftd wsebe +eili be
double tiransparwit'g ni poly and pmpe* wim pm' aArtd
'v&be steed wfih f+Yd Wfan Eom number,
ICOKI batob[I ooMainer. Ia6Yh gtfd transferrer! to a 84ided
4• ►ef-d I[Ubrlcthe work ie'to be pef ffrad by
ftickley
ConshuGtibn Ce., lnc. dba Brle�cfsy Ertvinur+mentatt, located at 957 gt,,
8®n Bamerdtno� ret 0.24Y 1. Thee: #81O414. Qxftd lbr t w
rarttracr i$ Ian t�orrlsort. Phone 3 01$ fbx: #S"1-,433. The worn
11010 Arrow Routs, SufNe 105, Rancho Cucamonga, CA. 9,1730
(800) 886-2589 • FOX (909) 980-5828
ENVIRONMENTAL FAX NO. :909 361 3433 May. 04 2004 03:37Ft9 P5
89: ee 9899@85826 FAEE 0:
TM Work WIII be pfd a8 fOftm:
1. Stene 0060o8 119136 and Pftftd algae around the j b
Sm.
Z. Workers vial MNlar'tYM011uU body ppm cgs "'W proW
re PMW "ufpment, boots andppbvaa:
3. W piwit rmod ae .air =- am In pre wet axWeon at an
WW raughout the worit area. All materials vNN be pr*4N* prlor t D
placing he labeled "I polyethylanf baps for proper dlapopal.
4. Double bq or double wrap with "m polyehyiene.
PMWIY I&W with 9WWWW number and transfer ib.laoioabla disposal
5, Wft mT and HERA vacuum all surfaces within the work or",
G.E.M.Swig conduct final inspection *w vteibis 90cumuta bm of roon%
felt *669 OW the abateRm t has been mnpbbd.
T. Ono* the armis tow aPhis werl visuW slum not, w=prarlpbe au end
s ulaoss In 00 WNW eros; MMM alt endleeefg embole and
WN bang m.
014110OUL SITE: An" Land Reolameticn
1201 W. GbW tone
/tmm, CA,91702
b Jasriph Johnson, Celitomia Ce ditd Asbeifte Cona 4mik 131-0996, hartre
Propbred the Pr+oaedure b work plin forapphvNal by the 800 Coast Air Quaky
Pnagernent �n���im�Proedumat forth In: ft plan, beaaoaiani
rooth debris should be mnowd in iffi enftty.
•
31010 Arnow Roue, Sults 105, Moneho CUCsmOnga, CA. 91730
(800) 886-2589 0 Fax (909) 880.-6$28
Riversidc, ('A 4251',
( 909) 624- Mr+s
SCOTi' MORR1SO N & ASS(1CIA 1 FS
ASBESTOS SURVEY REPORT (Addendum)
Completed On
April 22, 2004
PLM0416#1501 add
ClientCherokee Homes
73-180 Hwy: 111
Palm Desert, CA 92260
Project 49130 Eisenhower Drive
La Quints, CA
(single-femily home with attached gerage)
.1ISis rkrtu Palm Drive, Ste. 03-407
C:ethedrat (ley. . CA 027.14
t'ht»a2,►•7743
On April 20, 2004 additional bulk sampling was conducted at the above project address Bulk samples
were taken of the exterior stucco only at the request of the client named above. A total of (03) bulk
samples were submitted to Caroline Environmental, Inc. located at: 107 New Edition Court in Cary NC
(NVLAP Code 101768-0 and Cel Environ. Lab. Cert 02493) to estimate the percentage of asbestos by
volume and determine the type(s) present by using the 1,000 point -counting method.
Carolina Environmental. Inc. determines percentages and type of asbestos by using EPA approved
method BDOVM4-82-020, Interim Method for the Determinetton of Asbestos in Bulk Samples. Bulk
samples°were analyzed by using 1,000 total voirits or a field matrix using a polarized light microscope
Tt•e California Code of Regulations (CCR 1529) requires bulk sampling be conducted according to the
A HE R.A. protocol provistons of 40 CFR Part 763.86. The A.H. E.R.A. protocol recommends three (3) or
more frlable surfacing samples from a homogeneous area be collected and analyzed before any building
material is determined to be non -asbestos containing. Scott Morrison & Associates conducts asbestos
inspection surveys following the A.H.E. R.A. inspection orotocol.
ASBESTOS INSPECTION BY: Scott Morrison, DOSH 092-0248
BULK SAMPLES ANALYZED BY: Carolina Environmental, Inc, NVLAP 0101768.0
The results,on the following page(s) Indicate that asbestos,(greater than 1.0%) was detected in 00 or the
03 samples analyzed.
(1)
P.O. Box 5;;:Q
Rivmidt, CA 42517
(904) 62-0- lfo,s
IRLfV1041601801add
ti(,c x.1..1. NIOR ISON & ASSO CIA 11"
11855 Date -Palm Drive. Ste 01507
Cathed_ rat City. CA 994
t �a��t3�1.�743
Sample #CH-16a0d - Type o. material:exterior stucco/ tan -grey
Location: N. -central exterior well. by A/C fan
Area:throughout exterior wills
Friable' no Result:#: 0.1 % Chrysotile asbestos (1 pt. 11000 total)
Sarnple #CH-17add
Type of material:exterior stucco/ tan -grey
Location:E,-central exterior wall (patio area)
Ares. -throughout exterior walls
Friabie:no
Results. 0.2% Chrysotile asbestos (2 pt 11000 total)
Sample #CH•18add
type of material:extenor stucco/ tarngrey
Location:W -central- exterior well, by HVAC closet
Ares:throughout exterior walls
Friable.no
ResuNs: 0.1% Chrysotile asbestos 0 pt.11000 total;
Note: All asbestos containing building material(s) containing greeter than 10% asbestos by volume or
weight. must be removed by a state certifi90 asbestos abatement contrector prior to any demolition or
renovation of ilia property
Inspector
Scott C. Morrison
Certified Asoestos Consultant
DOSH#92-0248
(2-)
w -V -W Oi':lW From-CARLihA.EW110l144"A6
CAF1X ► EWY%,tree.
WNION15dllp, asac rANcare11
PW0,00IE11Ns Fa:(Y1te14tiiow
-41* 14!1 T-tiO F QV14 P- 1t
LA 130RATO RY REPORT
68618108 BULK AN LYSIS
Client* soott Morrison & Assoelstaa CEI Lid COtle;
A04.2876
31855 Date Palm Or. Suite 3.507 Received-
04-2'-04
Cathedral City, CA 92234 Anay0d
04-2244
Reported.
04-22.04
Analyst,.AnneAAslmtlarQ
project: PLM0416#1501 ad+d
X
JJ0MWgWvITY 088CHIPTION
CL1sN7 10 LAS
t,AS ID
AIME OS
s;N.16add A2541.96 L'iill�RloR STUCCO P_LASIiB
CHRY Q.1 X
Heterogeneous, len. Grey, Non-fibrous, loosely 130Un0
,:HRY 0.1110 ®IND 499% CELL <1 Yt
0,.l % Chry = (1 Chry POInt 11000 Total PAINT s1 %
points) x'100
CH- 17add A254199 FTERIo STUCCO PLASTER
CHRY 0.7%
Hste Wr.cous, 'Tan, Gray; Nos.l orous. Loosely !sound
CHRY 0.2% 01HP 000% CEL: 'et Y.
0.2 % CFry = (2 Chry Pant 110,00 TO•.el PAINT 'Cl %
points) K 100
CH--18add A254200 EX*satOa sTUcco PLASTER
CHRY 0.1
Heterogeneous. Fan: Grey, Nam -fibrous, Loosely BOuna
CFIRY 0.1% !$IND 11110.9% CELL Kt %
0 1 " Ch • 11 ChryPOIn111000 Tota! PAINT ,t1 %
N
IS olm"s) x ' 00 ---- ..
Page i
CLIMNAIN CU EODY /+Cv- ,4 ff�o C�)
W,& ql ?I- - - -f 4s f�2-
From SoM Merriam & AswisOn Ta: Cordials Kawkeumeaft% bc.
TI.O. BOIL 55329 107 New Edilim court
NdvbfWt, CA 925I 7 Cory, WC' 27511
{76%323-7743 t919} 481-1413
NVL"Co&WON D CAFIAP*240
co
ft. CHMIC. Cl-ittoko Arv&vs PWWR Tnkbg VIA
&*kw it
Job Igo.Wtt�flG-130 PZI
Sam*# Mohffw & nmatftm Oftr tnfwmafi on
Ion
-1 74a qD
CK -Itjb4trw s4utw
h -
TkoLh
I
I
W�q v p EP p
Nr
Cp
. . ..... ---- --
POIL io Yates tea No
Olt
Relingoi B7: DnvfriML-- Olt Z, V30P41RWr*IW
MaWF*z ire SceK Mordom & Asockftsv 31856 Date Pxft Dr..S.k-- OX-587. Catbedrol City, CA 92234.476" 323-7743
1oi-Zi•01 Oi:69an fres-CARQLNA ENVIRUMMtd A6 *•o,,.+.
T.he jollovA nq dthnitions apply W the it"revistlons used M the A3BE87.06 SULK
^MALYSIS REPORT:
CHRY
s Chyaotse
CELL a Cellulose
Dta3A o Debris
AMOS
s Amo:xte
F515PL a Fibrous Oless
9iND a Sinder
GAOC
0 Groc dials
ORt3N a organim
SiLI v SNCAW
TRLM
v Tromoilte
SY NT = syntnebt s
GRAY a Gravel
ANTM
• r1r+tAophy lits
WOLL a Wollastonite
MAST = Mastic
ACTH
a Act'nottte
CERWt. Cosmic wool
PLAS s Piaster
N D
= Vose DetecteC
NTRF m a Non•Asbeetiform
PFRL a Perlite
NAIVTIi s Non-Aabestltorm
Tr aUte
FWDR =Rubber
AMtiaphy;lite
--
CLIENT: Scott Morrison & Assoaat!s
PaeojeeT: PLM041601801add.
U
CS, t.A6 ccoh= A04-2876
gte,edscople Mlemecopy and poler:zed light microscopy couple4 with disoemion stairing to to.analyti�aI tecIII a f, used
rot sample identification. The percentage of each C*mponart is visually estimetec by volume. These results partair only
to the swrples analyzed. The eernctes were analyzed as submitted by the client !no iney not be ropresentolbr0 of the larger
inslSrial In question. Ur+lses notified in wrlting to return samples,. Caroline Environmental. Me, WIU disord a,l DVIX semple9
attar 30 days .
Mot lied it a fiber
Many viny' 000rriies tiave bee-1menufaaureq usinl7 rester themro 1 r , ap "NOne 0e 4cted" D read p on vinyl floor He
site below the de'actlon limit of poisry7.sd light rRlt roscoG!Y nere(ore, rov:dei a more ooncwswe
does M1 necessarily exclude the presence of p9bestoe. Transmissl0r. electron microscopy p
Torr" of engysxs'for vinyl flv4r tt-es.
tis .osrMied by the sig sue 1os'0:80096105 jhat in b <lina ImaterieIs.�,irld. is The acctealted es tmetllod s EPA 1$06 / M 82r! 020 for
Proprarr, (NVLAP) for
the analysts of asbestos in buCding Taierlate. P+fO W, as 4eicrlbed in ERA 16041 R -9J r 1' 6 hwe tleen lrcorpOratsd
where appcksale Tne detact':on limit forths method is 0,1 % (trooe ,mount), Carolina Env ronrnental, Ines NVLAP
accreditation number K fJ101789.0. This repartIS not to be 6sed to Clair" product endorsement frit NVLAP Or 6ny agency
of tate U S Governrne-it. This report. end its con*gts are on,,yvalid when reproduced in tuft. Dust and soft analyses fof
asbestos using PCM ilia not covered tfndsr NVLAP aWeditatioh.
'ANALYST
REVIRWED BY
Tlo�beo Oor, PhA. � ,,
Laboratory Dirftl& End of Report
(� �% LAW OFFICES OF
GARY ALDO DAPELO * ` ooD, •` ILDMAw, HEowEss & WALLEY
TROY M. GOOD
ROBERT W. OYESS,JR.*
(RETIRED)
MARSHA GABLE
5000 CAMPUS DRIVE
PAUL C..HEGNESS *
WggrpOgT BEACH, (`AT T711(1 BNTA. 02860-2181
PAUL W. WILDMAN
HEIDI -STILB LEWIS
TIMOTHY C. PICKART
(949) 955-1100 CITY Y OF LA 01 11NITA
(1924-1983)
NIKKI A. PRESLEY
,
MICHAEL P. RIDLEY
OF COUNSEL
JOHN A. STILLMAN
(�
OCTCJT
LOUIS A. CAPPADONA
THOMAS E. WALLEY *
1 REC,IJ
DOUGLAS M. VICKERY
STEPHEN B. OTTO
*A PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION
pA ' fifiyy
FAX (949) 833-0633
October 8, 2003
Tom Hartung
Building and Safety Director
CITY OF LA QUINTA
PO Box 1504
La Quinta, CA 92253
Re: Mazzella vs. O'Gradv
4.9130 Eisenhower Drive, La Qunita, CA
Dear Mr. Hartung:
Thank you for responding so quickly with your Declaration. I have finalized
your Declaration and enclose it for your review and signature. I also enclose a self-
addressed, stamped envelope for return mailing and for your convenience.
Should you have any questions in this regard, please do not hesitate to contact
me.
Very truly yours,
GOOD, WILDMAN, HEGNESS & W.
By: ,/ AZV7Y O
THOMAS E. WALLEY, ESQ.
TEW al
Enclosure
cc: Lou Mazzella. (w/ enclosure)
Hartung, Tom (re. Mazzella v OGrady).ltr
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
THOMAS E. WALLEY, ESQ., State Bar No. 46115
GOOD, WILDMAN, HEGNESS & WALLEY
5000 Campus Drive
Newport Beach, CA 92660
Phone: (949) 955-1100
Fax: (949) 833-0633
Attorneys for Plaintiff,
ANNE J. MAZZELLA
SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA IN THE COUNTY OF
RIVERSIDE—INDIO BRANCH
ANNE J. MAZZELLA,
Plaintiff,
V.
FRANK O'GRADY, LORITA O'GRADY; DYSON &
DYSON OF CALIFORNIA, INC.; BOB A. LA VENIA
dba CASA DE LA VENIA; and Does 1 through 5
and 7 through 15, inclusive
Defendants.
FRANK O'GRADY and LORITA O'GRADY
Cross -Complainants,
V.
BOB A. LA VENIA dba CASA DE LA VENIA;
DYSON & DYSON OF CALIFORNIA, INC.; and
ROES 1 through 20, inclusive,
Cross -Defendants.
BOB A. LA VENIA dba CASA DE LA VENIA,
Cross -Complainants,
V.
DYSON & DYSON OF CALIFORNIA, INC.; FRANK
O'GRADY and LORITA O'GRADY; and MOES 1
through 10, inclusive,
Cross -Defendants.
CASE NO. INCO31034
The Honorable Robert G. Taylor
Dept. 2G
DECLARATION OF TOM
HARTUNG, BUILDING AND
SAFETY DIRECTOR OF THE
CITY OF LA QUINTA
Complaint Filed: 8/29/02
Hearing Date:
Dept: 2G
I, TOM HARTUNG, declare as follows:
-1-
DECLARATION OF TOM HARTUNG
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
J N'
12
3 m
m
� 13
W
O °o
�
�z�W -z. 14
W a n a
0 15
q is
a24— 16
O) a m
o a 17
o.
9 z 18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
1. I am the Building and Safety Directorforthe City of La Quinta. I am competent
to testify and if called upon, would testify to the truth and accuracy of the following facts.
2. The real property which is the subject of the within lawsuit is located in the
County of Riverside, State of California, identified as: Lot 114 and 117 of Tract Map
Book 37/96-98 La Quinta Golf Estates No. 1 as per map recorded in Book 37, Pages
96, 97, and 98 in the Office of the County Recorder of Riverside County, and is
commonly known as 49-130 Eisenhower Drive, La Quinta, California (hereinafter the
"Property").
3. On or about March 27, 20011 was contacted by Lou Mazzella, Sr. I visited the
Property on that same day.
4. 1 observed that concrete in the garage was upheaving in some areas. I also
observed minor cracking in the tile at several locations in the house on the Property.
5. 1 recommended to Lou Mazzella, Sr. that he contact a soils engineer to
determine the cause of the upheaval in the garage.
I declare under penalty ,of perjury that the foregoing .is true and correct.
Executed in La Qunita, California.
Dated: October / s, 2003
TOM HARTUNG, Buildi and Safety Director
of the City of La Qunita
-2-
DECLARATION OF TOM HARTUNG