2021 04 06 CC MinutesCITY COUNCIL MINUTES Page 1 of 18 APRIL 6, 2021
CITY COUNCIL
MINUTES
TUESDAY, APRIL 6, 2021
CALL TO ORDER
A regular meeting of the La Quinta City Council was called to order at 3:01
p.m. by Mayor Evans.
This meeting provided teleconferencing accessibility pursuant to Executive
Orders N-25-20, N-29-20, N-33-20, N-35-20, and N-60-20 executed by the
Governor of California, in response to the state of emergency relating to novel
coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) and enabling teleconferencing
accommodations by suspending or waiving specified provisions in the Ralph M.
Brown Act (Government Code § 54950 et seq.).
PRESENT: Councilmembers Fitzpatrick, Peña, Radi, Sanchez, Mayor Evans
ABSENT: None
STAFF PRESENT: City Manager McMillen, City Attorney Ihrke, City Clerk
Radeva, Deputy City Clerk Romane, Design and Development Director Castro;
Assistant to the City Manager Villalpando, Community Resources Director
Escobedo, Public Safety Manager Mendez, Public Works Director/City Engineer
McKinney, Acting Finance Director Martinez, Financial Services Analyst Hallick.
PUBLIC COMMENT ON MATTERS NOT ON THE AGENDA – None.
CONFIRMATION OF AGENDA
Mayor Pro Tem Radi requested to pull Consent Calendar Item No. 5 for a
separate vote and said he will recuse himself from discussion and vote on this
item due to a potential conflict of interest stemming from the possibility that
a long-term tenant in his rental property may have received financial support
from the Lift to Rise organization.
City Clerk Radeva said the motion for Consent Calendar Item No. 5 will be
amended as the Lift to Rise Regional Pledge for Housing and Opportunity will
be signed by the Mayor instead of the City Manager.
Council concurred.
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES Page 2 of 18 APRIL 6, 2021
CLOSED SESSION
1. THREAT TO PUBLIC SERVICES OR FACILITIES, PURSUANT TO
SUBDIVISION (a) OF GOVERNMENT CODE SECTION 54957.
CONSULTATION WITH: ALEXANDER JOHNSTON, SENIOR
EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT COORDINATOR; WILLIAM H. IHRKE,
CITY ATTORNEY (Review Continued Need and Response to
Proclaimed State and Local Emergencies Caused by COVID-19)
2. CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL – ANTICIPATED
LITIGATION; SIGNIFICANT EXPOSURE TO LITIGATION
PURSUANT TO PARAGRAPH (2) OR (3) OF SUBDIVISION (d) OF
GOVERNMENT CODE SECTION 54956.9 (NUMBER OF POTENTIAL
CASES: 1)
3. CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL—EXISTING LITIGATION
PURSUANT TO PARAGRAPH (1) OF SUBDIVISION (D) OF
SECTION 54956.9 OF THE GOVERNMENT CODE. NAME OF CASE:
CITY OF LA QUINTA, PETITIONER, V. LA QUINTA ARTS
FOUNDATION, RESPONDENT, USPTO TRADEMARK TRIAL AND
APPEAL BD., CANCELLATION CASE NO.: 92076446.
NAME OF CASE: LA QUINTA ARTS FOUNDATION, PLAINTIFF, V.
CITY OF LA QUINTA, DEFENDANT, US DIST. COURT, CENTRAL
DISTRICT OF CAL., CASE NO. 5:21-CV-515
4. CONFERENCE WITH REAL PROPERTY NEGOTIATORS PURSUANT
TO GOVERNMENT CODE SECTION 54956.8 FOR PROPERTY
LOCATED ON NORTH OF HIGHWAY 111, WEST OF WASHINGTON
STREET (APN 604-050-067)
CITY NEGOTIATOR: JON McMILLEN, CITY MANAGER
NEGOTIATING PARTY: MICHAEL SHOVLIN
UNDER NEGOTIATION: PRICE AND TERMS OF PAYMENT
5. CONFERENCE WITH LABOR NEGOTIATORS PURSUANT TO
GOVERNMENT CODE SECTION 54957.6; CITY DESIGNATED
REPRESENTATIVE: CHRIS ESCOBEDO, DIRECTOR OF
COMMUNITY RESOURCES; AND EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATION: LA
QUINTA CITY EMPLOYEES’ ASSOCIATION
COUNCIL RECESSED THE OPEN SESSION PORTION OF THE MEETING
AND MOVED INTO CLOSED SESSION AT 3:06 P.M.
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES Page 3 of 18 APRIL 6, 2021
MAYOR EVANS RECONVENED THE OPEN SESSION PORTION OF THE
CITY COUNCIL MEETING AT 4:26 P.M. WITH ALL MEMBERS PRESENT
AND ANNOUNCED THAT THE COUNCIL WILL RECESS TO CLOSED
SESSION AGAIN AT THE END OF THE OPEN MEETING TO CONCLUDE
THEIR DISCUSSION ON CLOSED SESSION ITEM NO. 5.
REPORT ON ACTION(S) TAKEN IN CLOSED SESSION:
City Attorney Ihrke reported the following pursuant to Government Code
section 54950 et seq. (Brown Act):
CLOSED SESSION ITEM NO. 1
The Council continued its discussions regarding responses to the threat to the
City’s public services and facilities due to the declared state emergency caused
by COVID-19 and took the following vote:
MOTION – A motion was made and seconded by Councilmembers Radi/
Fitzpatrick to ratify the terminations of: (a) City Manager’s Executive Order
Nos. 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, and 8; (b) Amendment No. 2 to Executive Order No. 9; and
(c) Amendment No. 4 to Executive Order No. 10. Motion passed unanimously.
CLOSED SESSION ITEM NO. 2
MOTION – A motion was made and seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Radi/
Councilmember Sanchez to issue a Notice of Default to SilverRock
Development Company that will trigger its obligation to cure identified defaults
in the Schedule of Performance pursuant to the Purchase, Sale and
Development Agreement, as amended, between SilverRock Development
Company and the City. Motion passed unanimously.
CLOSED SESSION ITEM NO. 3 – no reportable action;
CLOSED SESSION ITEM NO. 4 – no reportable action; and
CLOSED SESSION ITEM NO. 5 – Council will re-enter closed session
to consider this item after the open portion of the meeting has
concluded.
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
Councilmember Fitzpatrick led the audience in the Pledge of Allegiance.
PUBLIC COMMENT ON MATTERS NOT ON THE AGENDA
PUBLIC SPEAKER VIA TELECONFERENCE ACCESSIBILITY:
Peter Meza, Associate Insurance Compliance Officer with the California
Department of Insurance (CDI) – provided information on the CDI
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES Page 4 of 18 APRIL 6, 2021
Consumer Education and Outreach Bureau which serves to educate
consumers through the development and distribution of insurance
informational guidelines; CDI’s functions are to protect consumers,
including overseeing insurer solvency, licensing agents and brokers,
conducting market conduct reviews, resolving consumer complaints,
and investigating and prosecuting insurance fraud; and California Low-
Cost Auto Insurance Program.
WRITTEN PUBLIC COMMENTS were provided by the following, which were
distributed to Council, made publicly available, and incorporated into the
agenda packet:
Floyd, Kim - regarding State of California organic waste reduction
actions.
ANNOUNCEMENTS, PRESENTATIONS AND WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS
1. PRESENTATION BY REGIONAL AFFORDABLE HOUSING PLANNER
TAYLOR LIBOLT VARNER WITH LIFT TO RISE REGARDING THE
WE WILL LIFT: REGIONAL PLEDGE FOR HOUSING AND
OPPORTUNITY
Lift to Rise President/CEO Heather Vaikona and Regional Affordable Housing
Planner Taylor Libolt Varner gave a brief presentation on the organization’s
services, priorities, collaborative efforts with other agencies and the WE WILL
LIFT: REGIONAL PLEDGE FOR HOUSING OPPORTUNITY program.
CONSENT CALENDAR
1. APPROVE MEETING MINUTES DATED FEBRUARY 16, 2021
2. APPROVE AGREEMENT FOR CONTRACT SERVICES WITH
COMPLETE PAPERLESS SOLUTIONS FOR LASERFICHE SOFTWARE
SUPPORT SERVICES AND PURCHASE OF THREE LASERFICHE
FULL-USER LICENSES
3. ACCEPT LA QUINTA LANDSCAPE RENOVATION IMPROVEMENTS
PROJECT NO. 2016-03E, LOCATED AT LA QUINTA RANCHO
OCOTILLO DEVELOPMENT, ON THE SOUTH SIDE OF FRED
WARING AND EAST SIDE OF ADAMS STREET
4. ADOPT RESOLUTION TO APPROVE THE CITY OF LA QUINTA
PROJECT LIST FOR FISCAL YEAR 2021/22 FOR SENATE BILL 1 -
ROAD REPAIR AND ACCOUNTABILITY ACT 2017 FUNDING
[RESOLUTION NO. 2021-009]
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES Page 5 of 18 APRIL 6, 2021
5. Pulled for a separate vote by Mayor Pro Tem Radi >>> ADOPT A
RESOLUTION IN SUPPORT OF THE WE WILL LIFT: REGIONAL
PLEDGE FOR HOUSING AND OPPORTUNITY
[RESOLUTION NO. 2021-010]
6. APPROVE DEMAND REGISTERS DATED MARCH 12, 19, AND 26,
2021
7. RECEIVE AND FILE REVENUE AND EXPENDITURE REPORT DATED
FEBRUARY 28, 2021
8. APPROVE PURCHASE OF A FORD F-450 4x4 DUMP TRUCK FOR
CITY MAINTENANCE AND OPERATIONS THROUGH SOURCEWELL
COOPERATING PURCHASING
MOTION – A motion was made and seconded by Councilmembers Peña/Radi
to approve Consent Calendar Item Nos. 1 – 4, and 6 - 8 as recommended,
with Item No. 4 adopting Resolution No. 2021-009. Motion passed
unanimously.
CONSENT CALENDAR ITEM NO. 5
MAYOR PRO TEM RADI RECUSED HIMSELF FROM DISCUSSION AND
VOTE ON CONSENT CALENDAR ITEM NO. 5 DUE TO A POTENTIAL
CONFLICT OF INTEREST STEMMING FROM THE POSSIBILITY THAT A
LONG-TERM TENANT RENTING THE COUNCILMEMBER’S RENTAL REAL
PROPERTY MAY HAVE RECEIVED RENTAL SUBSIDY FROM THE STATE
THROUGH THE LIFT TO RISE ORGANIZATION
MOTION – A motion was made and seconded by Councilmembers Peña/
Fitzpatrick to approve Consent Calendar Item No. 5 as recommended,
adopting Resolution No. 2021-010. Motion passed: yes 4, noes 0, abstain 1
(Radi)
BUSINESS SESSION
1. INTRODUCE FOR FIRST READING AN ORDINANCE AMENDING
CHAPTER 3.25 OF LA QUINTA MUNICIPAL CODE BY ADDING
SECTION 3.25.055 RELATED TO NON-ISSUANCE OF NEW SHORT-
TERM VACATION RENTAL PERMITS AND SECTION 3.25.065
RELATED TO GROUNDS FOR DENIAL OF SHORT-TERM VACATION
RENTAL (STVR) PERMITS [ORDINANCE NO. 591]
Design and Development Director Castro presented the staff report, which is
on file in the Clerk’s Office.
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES Page 6 of 18 APRIL 6, 2021
WRITTEN PUBLIC COMMENTS received prior to the adjournment of the
meeting at 9:20 p.m., are listed on Attachment 1 in alphabetical order, and
have been distributed to Council, made publicly available and incorporated into
the agenda packet. City Clerk Radeva displayed the list of 503 authors of
written public comments received up until 4:00 p.m. when the open session
of the meeting was called to order.
PUBLIC SPEAKERS VIA TELECONFERENCE ACCESSIBILITY listed in the order
in which they spoke:
1. Jeff Wen – purchased a second home in La Quinta; supports STVRs.
2. Marlene Fradis (La Quinta Cove) – supports the moratorium.
3. Robert Blotzer – has a second home at PGA West; supports STVRs.
4. Don Shofftall (La Quinta) – supports a stay on STVRs in all residential
neighborhoods including HOAs.
5. Kevin Wong (Los Angeles) – purchased a second home in La Quinta;
supports lifting the moratorium on new STVR permits.
6. Arlene Gotshalk (La Quinta) – supports a stay on new STVR permits.
7. David Kohan – purchased a home in the Cove with expectation to rent
as a STVR; requests lifting the moratorium on new STVR permits.
8. Eric Lavigne (Minneapolis, MN) – purchased a second home in PGA West
with belief that the moratorium was temporary; requests lifting the
moratorium on new STVR permits.
9. Alan Woodruff (La Quinta Cove) – full time resident; opposes STVRs.
10. Jelena Tamm (La Quinta/Newport Beach) – representing VRON-LQ;
opposes a stay on new STVRs anywhere in the City.
11. Araceli Gutierrez (La Quinta Cove)– supports a ban on STVRs.
12. Graham Lucas – purchased a second home in PGA West just when the
temporary moratorium took effect; requests lifting the moratorium.
13. Olivier Chaine (La Quinta) – President of VRON-LQ; supports STVRs.
14. Eddy Estrada (La Quinta) – video comments played; supports STVRs.
15. Cynthia Appolito (La Quinta – Desert Club Estates) – supports new
permits for STVR homeshares.
16. Anna Duitruck – supports STVRs; urged neighbors and STVR owners to
work together.
17. Kimberley Estrada (La Quinta) – video comments played; supports
STVRs; and encouraged residents and STVR owners to work together.
City Manager McMillen clarified that City Staff has never provided information
to residents, potential buyers or any persons regarding speculations on the
future status of the moratorium. Staff provided only facts on the status and
provisions of the moratorium in place at the time.
Council discussed the purpose of zoning limitations; using a home as a
business is a privilege, not a right; problem with STVRs is over-saturation; the
goal being restoration of neighborhoods; density restrictions being a future
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES Page 7 of 18 APRIL 6, 2021
option; periodic review of the stay such as re-evaluation every 3 or 6 months;
gathering more data as changes take effect; current compromise was difficult
to reach but allows the STVR program to continue; importance of vibrant
tourism, and developing communities designed for STVRs; applying for a bed
and breakfast license is still an option for homeowners; whether to operate a
STVR is a property right and whether once taken by government, it may never
be given back; hostility of neighbors to neighbors solving nothing; STVR
property owners’ responsibilities; avoidance of over-regulation; the effects of
COVID-19 restrictions on perception of the program in 2020; giving new
ordinances, fees, and regulations a chance to succeed before enacting a stay;
intention to lift the moratorium once the state of emergency order was lifted;
need for TOT revenue to keep the City beautiful; and punishment for bad
operators only, not new owners waiting for the temporary moratorium to be
lifted.
City Attorney Ihrke explained Section 3.25.055 of the proposed Ordinance
regarding exemptions for certain homeowners’ associations (HOAs).
Council discussed adding language to the proposed ordinance to address
various HOA situations, or to bifurcate the matter and address it at the next
meeting; reconsidering new permits for homeshares, and primary residence
STVRs; the benefit of quarterly reviews of the program versus semi-annual
reviews versus upon-request reviews; inability of homeowners under a
Development Agreement that permits STVRs, to subsequently vote to ban
STVRs until the term of the Agreement expires; many objecting to STVRs
called for new tourist commercial (TC) developments to accommodate STVR
operators, which is a compromise Council supports, but is concerned about
NIMBYism when new TC developments are proposed; the desire for all
residents and visitors to return to being positive ambassadors for La Quinta;
acknowledgement that the proposed ordinance can be amended at any time
by three Councilmembers’ votes, so not necessarily a permanent stay on new
permits; expressed respect for both sides of the matter; and reminder that
the proposed ordinance has no effect on existing permits if they abide by all
the rules, nor will it affect any workers servicing those properties.
Council directed the City Attorney to prepare an ordinance for Council
consideration, detailing how certain HOAs can be exempted from the non-
issuance of new STVR permit ordinance.
MOTION – A motion was made and seconded by Councilmembers Fitzpatrick/
Radi to take up Ordinance No. 591 by title and number only and waive further
reading. Motion passed: ayes 4, noes 1 (Sanchez)
City Clerk Radeva read the following title of Ordinance No. 591 into the record:
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES Page 8 of 18 APRIL 6, 2021
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LA QUINTA,
CALIFORNIA, AMENDING CHAPTER 3.25 OF THE LA QUINTA MUNICIPAL
CODE BY ADDING SECTION 3.25.055 RELATED TO NON-ISSUANCE OF
NEW SHORT-TERM VACATION RENTAL PERMITS AND SECTION
3.25.065 RELATED TO GROUNDS FOR DENIAL OF SHORT-TERM
VACATION RENTAL PERMITS
MOTION – A motion was made and seconded by Councilmembers Fitzpatrick/
Radi to introduce at first reading Ordinance No. 591 with the commencement
date of May 20, 2021 inserted in Section 3.25.055 and other minor typo and
sequencing corrections. Motion passed: ayes 4, noes 1 (Sanchez)
MAYOR EVANS CALLED FOR A BRIEF RECESS AT 7:35 P.M.
MAYOR EVANS RECONVENED THE COUNCIL MEETING AT 7:58 P.M.
WITH ALL MEMBERS PRESENT
STUDY SESSION – None
PUBLIC HEARINGS
1. ADOPT RESOLUTION TO AMEND THE CITY’S SHORT-TERM
VACATION RENTAL PROGRAM PERMIT FEES [RESOLUTION 2021-011]
City Clerk Radeva introduced City Consultant Terry Madsen, President and
CEO with ClearSource Financial Consulting who via ZOOM, presented the staff
report, which is on file in the Clerk’s Office.
MAYOR EVANS DECLARED THE PUBLIC HEARING OPEN AT 8:06 P.M.
PUBLIC SPEAKERS: None
MAYOR EVANS DECLARED THE PUBLIC HEARING CLOSED AT 8:06 P.M.
MOTION – A motion was made and seconded by Councilmembers Radi/
Fitzpatrick to adopt Resolution No. 2021-011 as recommended:
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LA QUINTA,
CALIFORNIA, AMENDING THE CITY’S SHORT-TERM VACATION
RENTAL PROGRAM PERMIT FEES
Motion passed unanimously.
DEPARTMENTAL REPORTS
All reports are on file in the City Clerk’s Office. Council pulled the following
for discussion and to provide direction to Staff:
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES Page 9 of 18 APRIL 6, 2021
3. CITY CLERK – CITY BOARDS, COMMISSIONS, AND OUTSIDE
AGENCIES COMMITTEE’S ANNUAL RECRUITMENT
City Clerk Radeva presented the department report which is on file in the
Clerk’s Office.
Council reached a consensus to directed staff to schedule a special meeting in
June 2021 to conduct the interviews in the Council Chambers at City Hall.
5. DESIGN AND DEVELOPMENT – HIGHWAY 111 FORM BASED CODE
AND DESIGN CIP PROJECT 2019-05 UPDATE
Council directed Staff to accelerate the Highway 111 rear corridor commercial
signage now that the CV Link project has broken ground.
MAYOR’S AND COUNCIL MEMBERS’ ITEMS
Councilmembers expressed thanks for residents’ written communications and
assured those writers that every email is read.
Mayor Evans gave an update on the CV Link project underway and the recent
grand opening celebration; commended Staff on the event featuring the
Easter Bunny; reported on the virtual event honoring the Pillars of the
Community Jeff Smith, Victory Grund, and Allen Woodruff; announced the
tentative date of April 24, 2021, evening, for the virtual presentation of the
Senior Inspiration Awards on NBC Palm Springs; noted that Middle and High
School students are back in the classrooms; reported that the City has
presented Certificates to all Assistant Principals in La Quinta in support of
National Assistant Principal Awareness Week; and noted the return of Art on
Main Street events and the Farmers’ Market.
REPORTS AND INFORMATIONAL ITEMS
La Quinta’s representative for 2021, Mayor Evans reported on her participation
in the following organization’s meeting:
COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DISTRICT JOINT POLICY
COMMITTEE
La Quinta’s representative for 2021, Councilmember Peña reported on his
participation in the following organization’s meeting:
IID ENERGY CONSUMERS’ ADVISORY COMMITTEE
La Quinta’s representative for 2021, Mayor Pro Tem Radi reported on his
participation in the following organization’s meeting:
CVAG TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES Page 10 of 18 APRIL 6, 2021
COUNCIL RECESSED THE OPEN SESSION PORTION OF THE MEETING
AND MOVED BACK INTO CLOSED SESSION AT 8:34 P.M.
MAYOR EVANS RECONVENED THE OPEN SESSION PORTION OF THE
CITY COUNCIL MEETING AT 9:19 P.M. WITH ALL MEMBERS PRESENT
REPORT ON ACTION(S) TAKEN IN CLOSED SESSION:
City Attorney Ihrke reported the following pursuant to Government Code
section 54950 et seq. (Brown Act):
CLOSED SESSION ITEM NO. 5 – no reportable action.
ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business, a motion was made and seconded by
Councilmembers Radi/Peña to adjourn at 9:20 p.m. Motion passed
unanimously.
Respectfully submitted,
MONIKA RADEVA, City Clerk
City of La Quinta, California
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES Page 11 of 18 APRIL 6, 2021
ATTACHMENT 1 to
CITY COUNCIL MEETING
MINUTES
TUESDAY, APRIL 6, 2021
WRITTEN PUBLIC COMMENTS were received from the following prior to the
adjournment of the meeting at 9:20 p.m., including those received during the
live meeting, and have been distributed to Council, made publicly available,
and incorporated into the agenda packet. Writers are grouped by their
position (support or opposition), and in alphabetical order.
BUSINESS SESSION ITEM NO. 1
INTRODUCE FOR FIRST READING AN ORDINANCE AMENDING
CHAPTER 3.25 OF LA QUINTA MUNICIPAL CODE BY ADDING SECTION
3.25.055 RELATED TO NON-ISSUANCE OF NEW SHORT-TERM
VACATION RENTAL (STVR) PERMITS AND SECTION 3.25.065 RELATED
TO GROUNDS FOR DENIAL OF SHORT-TERM VACATION RENTAL
PERMITS [ORDINANCE NO. 591]
Correspondence requesting that Council include HOAs in the proposed
ordinance placing a stay on new STVR permits (form letter no. 1):
1. Alwood, Gary and Chriss
2. Anderson, Roger and Sue
3. Baak, Tom and Sandy
4. Bangert, Steven
5. Bergman, Mark
6. Beshara, Jodi
7. Bloesser, Rex and Polly
8. Bottom, Steve and Susan
9. Bowen, Stephen and Joan
10. Brown, Beth
11. Brown, Martin and Karen
12. Buckman, Tony
13. Bushong, Susan and Bruce
14. Capobianco, Peter
15. Carlisle, Darrell and O’Toole,
Patricia
16. Carse, Leo
17. Cebron, Carol and Harry
18. Chandler, Cal and Kathy
19. Christopher, Eva and Doug
20. Clark, Brian and Bergeron, Shirley
21. Clay, Sharon and Kent
22. Collins, Brian and Suzanne
23. Condon, Cathy
24. Considine, John
25. Corr, Kelly
26. Corr, Laurie
27. Cunnington, Ed and Karayn
28. Davis, Charles and Laurie
29. Dean, Richard
30. Donaldson, Toni and Shane,
Lawrence
31. Dwyer, John
32. Estern, Emmet
33. Foley, John and Janet
34. Gallagher, James and Janet
35. Goldman, Harvey
36. Graves, Dean
37. Gregory, Larry
38. Gruber, John and Diane
39. Hackel, Joan
40. Hamilton, John
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES Page 12 of 18 APRIL 6, 2021
41. Heeter, Robert and Carol
42. Herman, Michael and Nancy
43. Hillebrand, Jeff
44. Hraban, Edith
45. Huntley, Andrew and Susan
46. Ihlenfeld, Cynthia
47. Intemann, Gertrude
48. Jahnke, David
49. Jaramillo, Salvador
50. Johnson, Ron and Becky
51. Kahn, Suzanne and Kevin
52. Kaiser, Jeffrey
53. Kalman, Joe
54. Kleiner, Donald and Charlene
55. Klink, Bruce
56. Korbey, Alexis
57. Lambert, Jim and Barbara
58. Lazich, Loydene
59. Leo, Robert and Rebecca
60. Leven, Norman
61. Lint, James and Michelle
62. Lloyd, Walt
63. Martin, Paul
64. Mattos, Mike and Kris
65. McAslan, Keith
66. Messeri, Dean and Linda
67. Millar, Rick and Elaine
68. Montavon, Barbara
69. Mortimer, Cathy Ann
70. Mortimer, Tom and Cathy
71. Nelson, Matthew
72. Newton, Sandra
73. Noble, Robert and Rocio
74. Nolte, Carol
75. Olsen, Risa
76. Olson, Mark and Marde
77. Oneil, Chantel
78. Ortiz, Betty
79. Park, Diana and David
80. Patel, Balmukund
81. Pelletier, Bill and Karen
82. Pipoly, GM (George)
83. Pracht, Terry and Patricia
84. Rashkin, Michael
85. Raymond, Paul
86. Reich, Richard and Lynn
87. Rendino, Dan
88. Revy, Karin Andrea
89. Sahagian, James and Jane
90. Savery, Barbara
91. Schubert, Roy and Terry
92. Silveira, Jim and Karen
93. Sites, William
94. Smith, Rod
95. Spitzer, Paul
96. Spridgeon, Ken
97. Stark, Anne and Jim
98. Steele, Gary and Karen
99. Steward, Ken and Cathy
100. Sultan, Anthony
101. Thomas, Tom
102. Tippett, Thomas
103. Tung, Andre
104. Ungar, Peter
105. Wall, David and Jennifer
106. Welty, John and Sharon
107. White, David and Catherine
108. White, Jessica
109. White, Shawn and Rebecca
110. Williams, John
111. Wilson, Colleen and Achs, Ken
112. Young, Robert
113. Zenz, Steve and Joanne
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES Page 13 of 18 APRIL 6, 2021
Correspondence requesting that Council include PGA West in the proposed
ordinance placing a stay on new STVR permits (form letter no. 2):
114. Alioto, Angelo
115. Armstrong, Gary and Mira
116. Askin, Dick
117. Baak, Toma and Sandy
118. Baker, Michelle and Dee
119. Blackmore, Nancy
120. Boysen, Paul
121. Britt, William
122. Brown, Beth
123. Butler, Bill and Terri
124. Carpenter, Bob
125. Civello, Nicholas and Julie
126. Crampton, Perrine
127. Davis, Charles and Laurie
128. Dingerson, Brett
129. Dolenga, R. Gary and Phyllis
130. Echelberger, Linda and Larry
131. Enebak, Tip and Diane
132. Falore, David
133. Floersheim, Rob and Betty
134. Fox, Cliff
135. Fulmer, Scott and Chris
136. Goldfinch, Greg
137. Goldman, Harvey
138. Grenier, Kylie
139. Gruber, John and Diane
140. Gutowicz, Alice
141. Gutowicz, Matthew
142. Hagerman, Allen
143. Hamilton, Jim and Janet
144. Herpcik, Richard
145. Hinman, Michael and Heather
146. Hodgetts, Joanne and Craig
147. Hraban, Edith
148. Johnson, Phyllis
149. Jones, Linda
150. Justis, Larry
151. Kellam, Ron and Lane
152. Kenndey, Jeanine and Jack,
James
153. Kirley, Joe and Sally
154. Knight, Tom and Jahanna
155. Korbey, Alexis and Wolf, Margaret
156. Kraemer, Linda
157. Laperuto, Anthony
158. Lloyd, Walt
159. Long, Jeffrey
160. Lynch, Jim and Nancy
161. Lyon, Thomas
162. MacRae, James and Vaughan, Sheri
163. Martin, Carol
164. McBay, Robert and Shelly
165. McCowan, Mary Jo and Robert
166. McGray, Mike
167. Michalowski, Peter
168. Millar, Marcia
169. Millar, Rick and Elaine
170. Moberg, Randy and Mitzi
171. Montavon, Barbara and Gary
172. Montgomery, Terry
173. Morse, Alan
174. Mortimer, Cathy Ann
175. Mueller, Chloe and Lance
176. Nagel, Joni
177. Niemi, Gary and Bonnie
178. Nimis, Connie
179. Nimis, Donald
180. Noble, Robert and Rocio
181. Nolte, Ronald
182. O’Connell, Jean
183. Parkin, Mark and Lorraine
184. Patel, Balmukund
185. Ploetz, Mary and Savageau, Joe
186. Raymond, Paul
187. Reich, Lynn and Richard
188. Rndino, Dan
189. Rock, Leslie
190. Romano, David
191. Rosen, Scott
192. Ryan, Timothy and Victoria
193. Scheela, Janie and Walt
194. Scherry, John and Tracey
195. Schuler, Arthur and Gayle
196. Silverman, Charles
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES Page 14 of 18 APRIL 6, 2021
197. Smith, Rod
198. Sommer, Cheryl
199. Spraker, Terry and Linda
200. Struther, George and Monica
201. Theron, Elizabeth
202. Theron, Pieter
203. Tseng, T C
204. Van Bavel, Cathy
205. Vislocky, Greg and Pam
206. Weberling, Jerry and Janet
207. White, David and Catherine
208. Williams, Margaret
209. Wilson, Rich
210. Yukich, Jim and Janet
211. Zehnder, Werner and Susan
Correspondence requesting that Council include HOAs and/or PGA West in
the proposed ordinance placing a stay on new STVR permits:
212. Ambrosio, Joanna
213. Armstrong, Mira and Gary
214. Bakall, Ergun & Cheryl
215. Bassi, Marte
216. Beams, Ronald and Corla
217. Beron, Bette
218. Corr, Kelly
219. Dotto, Roy
220. Gottleib, Janice
221. Hall, Thomas
222. Harmina, George and Geraldine
223. Headrick, Maggie and Tom
224. Hoffner, John
225. Hullinger, Jeff
226. Isaacs, Bryan
227. Lambert, Jim and Barbara
228. Lloyd, Walt and Jan
229. Logan, John
230. Lund, Richard and Marcia
231. Marcus, Mark
232. Martin, Jim and Betty Ann
233. Maughan, Kris and Wes
234. Merchant, Kenneth
235. Mills, Richard
236. Mitchell, Lisa and Ed
237. Montgomery, Terry
238. Mortimer, Cathy Ann
239. Perez, TKC
240. PGA West Fairways Association
241. PGA West Master Association
242. Schmitz, Mark and Diana
243. Segal, Marvin and Stefanie
244. Shapiro, Jody, Chester and
Annette
245. Singh, Amarjit
246. Stover, Larry
247. Tompkins, James
248. VanDeventer, Frank and Julie
249. Wanshura, Kathryn and James
250. Williams, Margaret
251. Woods, Kenny
252. Young, Grace
Correspondence in general opposition to STVRs and/or in support of
either extending the moratorium or a permanent ban on STVRs:
253. Akeakle
254. Alderson, Connie
255. Armendarez, Edward
256. Beavers, Meagan
257. Bogin, Rick
258. Borders, Bill
259. Browning, Toby
260. Case, Michael
261. Cornick, Therese
262. Coulter, Kathy
263. Courting, Mercedes
264. Courting, Robert
265. Cutchin, Marcia
266. Duncan, Stephanie
267. Facchin, Lucy and John
268. Faherty, Joe
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES Page 15 of 18 APRIL 6, 2021
269. Fradis, Marlene
270. Franco, Dianne
271. Garcia, Eileen
272. Garibay, Maria
273. Garibay, Soleded
274. Gilreath, Edward and
Consuella
275. Glasier, Pamela
276. Gleason, David
277. Gotshalk, Arlene
278. Gottberg, Kathy and Thom
279. Greenberg, Roger and Diane
280. Gunn, Diane
281. Hartung, Kathy
282. Heineman, Cheryl
283. Hoffman, Judy
284. Holmgren, Jeanne
285. Hylton, Edie and Dan
286. Kaiser, Ron and Alison
287. Karlen, Vince
288. Kelly, Paddy
289. Kneeter, Gretchen
290. Langhans, Terri
291. Langson, Sandy
292. Makino, Catherine
293. Martin, John
294. Mattos, Mike and Kris
295. McGuire, Rod
296. McQuiggan, Timothy
297. Mikulenka, Christopher
298. Miles, Kevin
299. Minichiello, Roberta and Tom
300. Neid, Judith
301. Nelson, Derek and Sharia
302. Nugent, Robin and Bob
303. Overley, Katherine
304. Poynter, Bruce
305. Purcell, Desiree
306. Quill, Paul
307. Robson, Lucinda
308. Schwartz, Bruce and Judith
309. Smith, Jeff
310. Stevenson, Roger
311. Stoddard, Elizabeth
312. Storbo, Dick and Janis
313. Thompson, Craig
314. Thompson, Marie
315. Vano, Laura
316. Vaughn, Susan
317. Vega, Lourdes
318. Vince, Vicki
319. Watson, Jim and Rochelle
320. Williams, Linda and Philip
321. Wolff, Kay
322. Yaple, James
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES Page 16 of 18 APRIL 6, 2021
Correspondence in general support of STVRs and/or in support of lifting
the moratorium:
1. AirBnB (Patel, Toral)
2. Aleman, Lisa
3. Alpi, Carol
4. Appolito, Cynthia and
Anthony
5. Arpe, Julie
6. Arsanto, Joey
7. Atkins, Garrett
8. Barletta, John
9. Barton, Ryan
10. Baxa, Amy
11. Bayley, Matthew
12. Behrens, Donna
13. Bell, Audrey
14. Bendokas, Tim and Heidi
15. Bennett, Chris
16. Bernick, DeBora
17. Beuermann, Caroline
18. Biller, Angela
19. Bilsborough, Deanne and Joe
20. Blanchard, Molly
21. Bloch, Carol
22. Bloch, Kim
23. Block, Ric
24. Boggs, Hale
25. Bojarski, Ellen
26. Bojarski, John
27. Bonilla, Elena
28. Boyd, Sheryl
29. Boyle, Gary
30. Bradley, Paige
31. Brar, Mindy and Tony
32. Brazas, Anthony
33. Broad, Bobbi Jo
34. Brudevold, Kjell
35. Buce, Robert
36. Burke, Evvan
37. Chaine, Olivier rep VRON-LQ
38. Clark (no last name)
39. Colby, Chuck
40. Collier, Neal
41. Cooper, Cari
42. Crane, CJ
43. Dal Poggetto, John
44. De Antonio, Ray
45. De Winter, Nadia
46. Delpit, Katherine
47. Diamond, Vanetta
48. Dixon, Barbara
49. Dobrowolski, Lenard
50. Donahoe, Denise
51. Dubin, Nancy
52. DuFour, William
53. Dunn, Nancy
54. Dyck, Carla
55. Emerson, David
56. Erez, Nimrod
57. Estopinal, Andrew
58. Estrada, Eddy
59. Estrada, Kimberly
60. Evans, Ashley
61. Fach, Michael
62. Fairchild, Jason
63. Feng, Jade
64. Florentin, Ilia
65. Flynn, Meredith
66. Frost, Greg
67. Gackic, Ensar
68. Garcia, Rene
69. Garcia, Sherie and Alex
70. Gelberd, Sarah
71. Gibson, Gillian
72. Giliam III, Everett John
73. Golin, Cynthia
74. Granger, Olympia
75. Gravina, Robert
76. Gray, Layne
77. Griffith, Daniel
78. Griffith, Stephanie
79. Grotsky, Kelly
80. Guerra, Megan
81. Hackner, Lisa
82. Halwani, Eve and John
83. Hashimi, Mike
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES Page 17 of 18 APRIL 6, 2021
84. Hastie, John
85. Hayes, Deonn
86. Hayes, Donald
87. Heyler, Randy and Kelly
88. Hill, Linda
89. Hoban, Bruce
90. Holby, Eric and Tammy
91. Holcenberg, Brad
92. Houk, James
93. Ignatowski, Patty
94. Ingram, Dennis and Roberta
95. Johnson, Oran
96. Johnson-Azoulay, Cheryl
97. Jones, Gary
98. Kakuk, Marita
99. Kakuk, Peter
100. Kaplan, Avi Lee
101. Kaufman, Alison
102. Keating, Melanie
103. Kennedy, Brian
104. Klaiman, Amy and David
105. Kohan, David
106. Kollesoff, Paul,
107. Konkle, Nick
108. Kossowicz, Tegan, Seig and Sam
109. Kula, Marichi
110. Lamb, Brent
111. Lauro, Fabio
112. LaVoie, Michael
113. Leibelt, Dustin
114. Leibelt, Wendy
115. Leydekkers, Jolie
116. Lu, Hongmei
117. Lucas, Laura
118. Lucas, Laura and Graham
119. Lucas, Matthew
120. Lunan, Wayne and Wildman,
Debra
121. Lux Box Vacation Rentals
122. Lynch, Sarah
123. M (just initial given), Denise
124. Machock, Julie and Dan
125. Malet, Debbi
126. Manning, Jasmin
127. Manukyan, Serj
128. Mark and Ethel (no last name)
129. Marrical, Jen
130. Marsh, Stuart
131. Mawhiney, James
132. Mawhiney, Sherronna
133. McCarroll, Eileen
134. McCartney, Stephanie
135. McWhorter, Wes and Wendy
136. Melniker, Richard
137. Mitzev, Vasko
138. Montgomery, Douglas
139. Moon, Susan
140. Moore, Tanya
141. MULTIPLE COVE RESIDENTS
142. Myrmo, Morgan
143. Nahas, Sam
144. Nelson, Imelda and Kayne
145. Nguyen, Ton
146. Niederhauser, Steven
147. Nuzzo, Juliet
148. O’Callaghan, Cara
149. Oliva, Alexa
150. Orman, Susan
151. Palmer, Luanne and Gerald
152. Palumbo, Jeff and Diane
153. Parnell, Karen
154. Pauls, Dwight
155. Peca, Matt
156. Pheifer, Lance and Terry
157. Pitzen, Sharla
158. Podjavorsek, Heidi
159. Polisky, Blake
160. Porter, Jennifer
161. Preher, Julian
162. Reed, Diane
163. Repp, Jimmy, Mary and Robert
164. Rhodes, Jesse
165. Riding, Lisa
166. Rosiak, Agnes
167. Rosiak, Michael
168. Sassounian, Boghos and Ani
169. Sauls, Karoline
170. Schwartz, Lawrence
171. Schwartzbord, Sarah
172. Serjmanuk
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES Page 18 of 18 APRIL 6, 2021
173. Shapiro, Matthew
174. Sharrer, Dave
175. Singer, Adam
176. Smith, Justin
177. Smith, Susie
178. Sosa, Xavier
179. Sowle, Jason
180. Sprague, Melanie
181. Sprague, Melanie and Jeff
182. Stauber, Matthew
183. Suard, Stever
184. Suppelsa, Suzanne
185. Sweeney, Michael
186. Taddy, Sonia, Sandino and
Manuel
187. Tamm, Jelena rep VRON-LQ
188. Taylor, William
189. Testa, Joseph
190. Thompson, Warren and Cami
191. Torrey, Dave
192. Tschacher, Steven
193. Warda, David and Donna
194. Weber, Rob and Kathy
195. Weiss, Nicole and Marc
196. Welin, Jonathan
197. Wen, Jeff
198. Wengreniuk, Gordon
199. Wiedder, Michael
200. Wierema, Dirk
201. Wierema, Karen
202. Wilkie, Linda
203. Wilson, Amy
204. Wilson, Fred
205. Wong, Kevin
206. Young, Jim
end.