2020 AB52 Tracking SheetCity of La Quinta Travertine Development – AB 52 Consultation 2020
Contact List Received from NAHC on
03/03/20
Date
Letter
Sent to
contact
Comments/Concerns
Agua Caliente Band of Cahuilla Indians
Jeff Grubbe, Chairperson
5401 Dinah Shore Drive
Palm Springs, CA, 92264
(760) 699-6800
3/5/20
2017 Notes:
Response received 9-20-17
Contacted Katie Croft 9-22-17 – no response back
Cultural Report sent to Katie Croft 10-4-17
Consultation mtg requested by tribe 11/6/17; City
contacted tribe for mtg 11/15/17 &11/28/17
Emailed tribe 12-14-17 for mtg request
Mtg scheduled for Tuesday 12-19-17, no mtg held that day
Mtg rescheduled and held 1-4-18
Letter rcvd 1/12/18 asking for more info for tribe to
complete their review
Sent requested info to tribe 1-30-18
Letter rcvd 3/15/18 with requests
Response sent back 3/19/18 accepting requests
3/5/20 2020 Notes:
No response received within the 30 day timeframe.
Applicant requested to discuss 3/15/18 letter with Pattie
Garcia
Conducted meetings on July 21, 30 and August 13, 2020
with applicant and Pattie Garcia to discuss project
and mitigation necessary
Meeting on 9/3/20, next mtg scheduled for 9/17/2020,
Pattie accepted mtg invitation
Meeting for 9/17/20 was postponed due to scheduling
conflict for Pattie and absence of TMDCI rep, next
mtg scheduled for 9/22/2020
Conducted meeting on 9/22/2020—Pattie was unable to
attend but still met with TMDCI
Conducted mtg on 9/28/2020 where suggestions for
mitigation were given, ACBCI and TMDCI
understood project and were satisfied with
consultation process
Letter from ACBCI issued on 9/28/20 with mitigation
Augustine Band of Cahuilla Mission Indians
Amanda Vance, Chairperson
P.O. Box 846
Coachella, CA 92236
(760) 398-4722
3/5/20
2017 and 2020 Notes:
No response received.
Cabazon Band of Mission Indians
Doug Welmas, Chairperson
84-245 Indio Springs Parkway
Indio, CA 92203
(760) 342-2593
3/5/20
2020 Notes:
No response received.
Contact List Received from NAHC on
03/03/20
Date
Letter
Sent to
contact
Comments/Concerns
Cahuilla Band of Indians
Daniel Salgado, Chairperson
52701 U.S. Highway 371
Anza, CA 92539
(951) 763-5549
chairman@cahuilla.net
3/5/20
2017 and 2020 Notes:
No response received.
Campo Band of Mission Indians
Ralph Goff, Chairperson
36190 Church Road, Suite 1
Campo, CA 91906
(619) 478-9046
rgoff@campo.nsn.gov
3/5/20
2017 and 2020 Notes:
No response received.
Ewiiaapaayp Tribal Office
Robert Pinto, Chairperson
Michael Garcia, Vice Chairperson
4054 Willows Road
Alpine, CA 91901
(619) 445-6315
3/5/20
2017 and 2020 Notes:
No response received.
Jamul Indian Village
Erica Pinto, Chairperson
Lisa Cumper, Tribal Historic Preservation
Officer
P.O. Box 612
Jamul, CA 91935
(619) 669-4785
3/5/20
2017 and 2020 Notes:
No response received.
La Posta Band of Mission Indians
Gwendolyn Parada, Chairperson
Javaughn Miller, Tribal Adminstrator
8 Crestwood Road
Boulevard, CA 91905
(619) 478-2113
LP13boots@aol.com
3/5/20
2017 and 2020 Notes:
No response received.
Los Coyotes Band of Cahuilla and Cupeno
Indians
Shane Chapparosa, Chairperson
P.O. Box 189
Warner Springs, CA 92086-0189
(760) 782-0711
chapparosa@msn.com
3/5/20
2017 and 2020 Notes:
No response received.
Manzanita Band of Kumeyaay Nation
Angela Elliott Santos, Chairperson
P.O. Box 1302
Boulevard, CA 91905
(619) 766-4930
3/5/20
2017 and 2020 Notes:
No response received.
Contact List Received from NAHC on
03/03/20
Date
Letter
Sent to
contact
Comments/Concerns
Mesa Grande Band of mission Indians
Michael Linton, Chairperson
P.O. Box 270
Santa Ysabel, CA 92070
760-782-3818
3/5/20
2017 and 2020 Notes:
No response received.
Morongo Band of Mission
Indians
Robert Martin, Chairperson
12700 Pumarra Rroad
Banning, CA, 92220
Phone: (951) 849 - 8807
Fax: (951) 922-8146
dtorres@morongo-nsn.gov
3/5/20 2020 Notes:
No response received.
Quechan Tribe of the Fort Yuma
Reservation
Jill McCormick, Historic
Preservation Officer
P.O. Box 1899
Yuma, AZ, 85366
Phone: (760) 572 - 2423
historicpreservation@quechantribe.com
3/5/20 2020 Notes:
No response received.
Ramona Band of Cahuilla Mission Indians
Joseph Hamilton, Chairperson
P.O. Box 391670
Anza, CA 92539
(951) 763-4105
admin@ramonatribe.com
3/5/20
2017 and 2020 Notes:
No response received.
San Pasqual Band of Diegueno Mission
Indians
Allen E. Lawson, Chairperson
P.O. Box 365
Valley Center, CA 92082
(760) 749-3200
allenl@sanpasqualtribe.org
3/5/20
2017 and 2020 Notes:
No response received.
Santa Rosa Band of Mission Indians
Steven Estrada, Chairperson
P.O. Box 39182
Anza, CA 92539
(951) 659-2700
3/5/20
2017 and 2020 Notes:
No response received.
Soboba Band of Luiseno Indians
Scott Cozart, Chairperson
P. O. Box 487
San Jacinto, CA, 92583
Phone: (951) 654 - 2765
Fax: (951) 654-4198
jontiveros@soboba-nsn.gov
3/5/20 2020 Notes:
No response received.
Contact List Received from NAHC on
03/03/20
Date
Letter
Sent to
contact
Comments/Concerns
Sycuan Band of the Kumeyaay Nation
Cody J. Martinez, Chairperson
1 Kwaaypaay Court
El Cajon, CA 92019
(619) 445-2613
ssilva@sycuan-nsn.gov
3/5/20
2017 and 2020 Notes:
No response received.
Torres-Martinez Desert Cahuilla Indians
Mary Resvaloso, Chairperson
P.O. Box 1160
Thermal, CA 92274
(760) 397-0300
tmchair@torresmartinez.org
3/5/20
2017 Notes:
No response received. Will send cultural study to new tribal
chairperson.
Contacted tribal chairperson 10/15/17, 10/20/17
Contacted Cultural Resources coordinator with the tribe
11/8/17, 11/28/17 via email and phone
Emailed cultural study
Updated contact from 2017: Thomas Tortez,
Chairperson
3/5/20
2020 Notes:
No response received within 30-day response timeframe.
8/11/2020 Michael Mirelez, Cultural Resource Coordinator
for TMDCI called regarding AB52 and SB18 consultation
for projects in La Quinta
8/11/2020 called him back and informed him of Travertine
and emailed a follow up on 8/12/2020.
8/18/2020 Emailed him link to download cultural studies
and NOP—Michael responded 8-18-2020
Meeting held 9/3/2020, next meeting scheduled 9/17/20,
Michael accepted mtg invitation
9/15/2020 Email Michael regarding 9/17 meeting asking if
he had any questions about the project and resent
Travertine project info materials-No response received
Meeting for 9/17/20 was postponed due to scheduling
conflict for ACBCI rep and absence of Michael, next mtg
scheduled for 9/22/2020
9/17/20 Emailed Michael and left phone message regarding
the meetings
Conducted meeting on 9/22/2020—ACBCI was unable to
attend but still met with Michael—applicant
explained project, monitoring protocol was
discussed
Conducted mtg on 9/28/2020 ACBCI and TMDCI were in
attendance—suggestions for mitigation were
given, ACBCI and TMDCI understood project and
were satisfied with consultation process
Email sent 10/05/2020 to follow up on when letter would
be issued with mitigation requirements
Email sent 10/16/2020 to follow up on when letter would
be issued with mitigation requirements—10/17/2020
email was returned as undeliverable
10/19/2020 called Michael and left phone message
regarding letter with mitigation requirements and
conclusion of consultation
Contact List Received from NAHC on
03/03/20
Date
Letter
Sent to
contact
Comments/Concerns
Twenty-Nine Palms Band of Mission Indians
Darrell Mike, Chairperson
46-200 Harrison Place
Coachella, CA 92236
760-863-2444
3/5/20
2017 Notes:
Letter rcvd 9-18-17 requesting cultural study.
Met with reps from tribe on October 3, 2017.
Gave them cultural study. They are reviewing and will get
comments back to us. Contacted them to follow up on
their review 11/15/17
Emailed 12-14-17 to follow up on comments
2020 Notes:
No response received.
Viejas Band of Kumeyaay Indians
John Christman, Chairperson
1 Viejas Grade Road
Alpine, CA 91901
(619) 445-3810
3/5/20
2017 Notes:
Letter received 9-5-2017
No consultation needed unless new discoveries happen.
2020 Notes:
No response received.
Summary
Most tribes did not respond to consultation letters.
Consultation with ACBCI and TMDCI (2020):
• June 2020—Applicant requested to meet with Pattie Garcia of ACBCI to discuss the letter they issued
3/15/2018. Applicant wanted to present project and negotiate mitigation measures. Meetings were
conducted on July 21, 30 and August 13, 2020 with applicant and Pattie.
o July 21 mtg introduced project and reviewed where sensitive sites are
o July 30 mtg-discussed rockslide district at Martinez Slide, villages located near there, trails map
needs to show APE—may need to send Pattie trails map, ACBCI could help with interpretive
exhibits
o Aug 13 mtg—discussion on geology of area, describe geomorphology to find depth of hard rock
and determine potential resources, Pattie needs map of lots with archeological sites and cut and
fill map
• Meeting on 9/3/20, next mtg scheduled for 9/17/2020
o Michael from TMCDI joined
o Cut and fill map was shown
o Geology shows boulders not bedrock, monitoring would need to be done there
o Pattie requested the map showing geology, cut and fill with archeo sites
• Meeting on 9/17/20 was postponed due to scheduling conflict for ACBCI rep and absence of TMDCI rep,
next mtg scheduled for 9/22/2020
• Meeting on 9/22/2020 was held with TMDCI rep only as ACBCI rep was unavailable.
o Michael from TMDCI explained their monitoring requirements
Monitor cut and fill areas
o Follow up meeting scheduled for 9/28/2020.
• Meeting on 9/28/2020 was held with TMDCI and ACBCI reps.
o Geology map was shown with cut/fill and archeo sites.
o Tribes gave recommendations to applicant
o All parties were amenable to recommendations
o Tribes stated they would provide letters listing recommendations to incorporate into EIR