RatingsCITY OF LA QUINTA
REQUEST FOR PROPOSAL EVALUATION
Professional Services:
PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING SERVICES
CALLE TAMPICO DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS
PROJECT NO. 2015-12C
Consultant: - h 0 dc K
Reviewer:
Date:
Score each category from I to its maximum assigned points (with I being the worst).
Project Understanding and Approach
20
Project Experience
26
Scope of Work
30
2
Schedule
10
Presentation
5
Format
5
Unique Qualities (Intangibles)
10
Total
100
Unique Qualities.,j1ptangibles):
y
;'/[./i A
(Explanation)
Comments:
TOTAL U
Reviewer's initials
CITY OF LA QUINTA
REQUEST FOR PROPOSAL EVALUATION
Professional Services:
PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING SERVICES
CALLE TAMPICO DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS
PROJECT NO. 2015-12C
Consultant: /4
Reviewer: 0
Date:/0-2-0--l-7
Score each category from I to its maximum assigned points (with I being the worst).
Project Understanding and Approach
20
Project Experience
20
Scope of Work
30
Schedule
10
Presentation
5
Format
5
Unique Qualities (Intangibles)
10
Total
100
Unique Qualities (Intan ibles):
� ,.! j TJ�
(Explanation)
I-rof br UVj d,
Comments: 6 h,
TOTAL
Reviewer's initials
CITY OF LA QUINTA
REQUEST FOR PROPOSAL EVALUATION
Professional Services:
PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING SERVICES
CALLE TAMPICO DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS
PROJECT NO. 2015-12C
Consultant:
Reviewer:
Date:
Score each category from I to its maximum assigned points (with 1 being the worst).
Project Understanding and Approach
20
Project Experience
20
Scope of Work
30
Schedule
10
Presentation
5
Format
5
Unique Qualities (Intangibles)
10
Total
100
Unique Qualities (Intangi les):
(Explanation) 15 M d ki
0'A
Comments:
TOTAL
Reviewer's initials
CITY OF LA QUINTA
REQUEST FOR PROPOSAL EVALUATION
Professional Services:
PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING SERVICES
CALLE TAMPICO DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS
PROJECT NO. 2015-12C
I ?) f)
Consultant: Anuaay",
Reviewer:
Date: /49/�Wr-r
Score each category from I to its maximum assigned points (with I being the worst).
Project Understanding and Approach
20
15-
Project Experience
20
1�
Scope of Work
30
Schedule
10
Presentation
5
Format
5
Unique Qualities (Intangibles)
10
Total
100
-lip
Unique Qualities (Intangibles):
(Explanation)
Comments:
TOTAL
Reviewer's initials -
CITY OF LA QUINTA
REQUEST FOR PROPOSAL EVALUATION
Professional Services:
PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING SERVICES
CALLE TAMPICO DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS
PROJECT NO. 2015-12C
Consul
Reviewer:-�5i,u
-Vttlal)6'�
Date: 101-3W t -7-
Score each category from 1 to its maximum assigned points (with I being the worst).
Project Understanding and Approach
20
Project Experience
20
Scope of Work
30
Schedule
10.
Presentation
5
Format
5
Unique Qualities (Intangibles)
10
Total
100
Unique Qualities (Intangibles):
(Explanation)
Comments -
TOTAL
Reviewer's initial
CITY OF LA QUINTA
REQUEST FOR PROPOSAL EVALUATION
Professional Services:
PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING SERVICES
CALLE TAMPICO DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENT5
PROJECT NO. 2015-12C
Consultant:
Reviewer: Date: 0-
u -
Score each category from 1 to its maximum assigned points (with I being the worst).
Project Understanding and Approach
20
19
Project Experience
20
Scope of Work
30
Schedule
10
Presentation
5
Format
5
Unique Qualities (Intangibles)
10
Total
100
Cl
Unique Qualities (Intangibles):
(Explanation)
Comments:
TOTAL
Reviewer's initials -
CITY OF LA QUINTA
REQUEST FOR PROPOSAL EVALUATION
Professional Services:
PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING SERVICES
CALLE TAMPICO DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS
PROJECT NO. 2015-12C
Consultant: ILA I (—haV-, I FXX L-A'
Reviewer: AJ -, A/ -
Date: /0 - c;l� —/ 2
Score each category from I to its maximum assigned points (with I being the worst).
Project Understanding and Approach
20
Project Experience
20
Scope of Work
30
C9 0
Schedule
10
Presentation
5
-5
Format
5
—5
Unique Qualities (Intangibles)
10
Total
100
Unique Qualities (Intangibles):
(Explanation) Ct>ccx�
Comments:
c
T�-cx"-,e- ,
Reviewer's initials
vrenoa,
C, %J
lop I —
44 e-,
e-),r-k-; rA
I L 1-�
�,j
P P ' 'Z-��TAL
CITY OF LA QUINTA
REQUEST FOR PROPOSAL EVALUATION
Professional Services:
PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING SERVICES
CALLE TAMPICO DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS
PROJECT NO. 2015-12C
Consultant: Acr
Reviewer: Date:
Score each category from I to its maximum assigned points (with I being the worst).
Project Understanding and Approach
20
Project Experience
20
Scope of Work
Schedule
Presentation
30
'20
10
5
Format
5
Unique Qualities (Intangibles)
10
Total
100
76
Unique Qualities (Intangibles):
L
(Explanation) �-nr cj ;S,)Ls - Al-�ukA 29 CQA1QL go
-7'r- 64 -AA e— SUry G <S
1 rz/ jo 26�214 Ile in 01 0,( :Ab le
c C—'/
,S1 � r- P Q&u /,Ss () e- -
k,C
TOTAL 76
Reviewer's initials
CITY OF LA QUINTA
REQUEST FOR PROPOSAL EVALUATION
Professional Services:
PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING SERVICES
CALLE TAMPICO DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS
PROJECT NO. 2015-12C
Consultant: 13 0 c�-,ek
Reviewer: tj - fj -
Date: /0 - d 6 —/�
Score each category from I to its maximum assigned points (with I being the worst).
Project Understanding and Approach
20
;�o
Project Experience
20
C;�Z)
Scope of Work
30
a-5
Schedule
10
Presentation
5
Format
5
Unique Qualities (Intangibles)
10
Total
100
Unique Qualities (Intangibles):
(Explanation) �e V. i -s,
nn-L 42�e AC-�r-xP - In
)Cr�A ('--CKA� 4:hi-< buor-k- u2:11
S+r. j t,121 y 41
0 D�� -\Q -nL!e w,4)
j
V� r�*- I V-IrA C, P vSt-),e-S in lci-kq� PAA-) /-t�A f:��e--us:ecl
C�wzo U rij -0- Y,-
1
<,C,,yVVe-- s6opw- On P
Comments: Sr �-\,PA t)\P �-\O,,-C, Ci,,1 Ur,v-,o, Avoln.)ererl
w,n
coork -
TOTAL
Reviewer's initials
rt)j