Loading...
COC 1999-018Ci La Y Uinta Community Mveloprnent Department 78=495: Ca1leTampico - P O Box. 1504 La Quinta :California 92253 (760) 777-7125 - fak (760) 777-1233 Application for Certificate ofApppropriateness I. General Information Andrea Mock for Applicant KSL Desert Resorts, Inc. dba La Quinta Resort & Club Address 49 499 Eisenhower Drive, La Quinta, CA Owners KSL Desert Resorts, Inc. Address .:OFFICE USE ONLY Case No.GAD� Date Recvd. Feer RelatedApps.: Logged in by: Phone 760-7.77-4855 92253 Phone 760-777-4855. 49 499 Eisenhower Drive, La Quinta, CA 92253 This application is for work on a: (I Historic Resource Assessor's Parcel Number ()`Historic Landmark ( ) Historic District General Location At La Quinta Resort & Club; Adjacent to the Main Lobby building at the west end of the main driveway. Acreage n/a Existing Zoning TC Legal Description (give exact legal description as recorded in the Office of the County Recorder - it may be attached). La Quints Resort & Club'- 49 499 Eisenhower Drive, La Quinta, CA 92253 Purpose of this Request (type of work to be done) To obtain approval to' move the existing f ront foyer doors to the restaurant (installed in 1988), northward appx. 12ft.and reuse the existing doors at the new location. Replace the door opening with a window.to match the existing window in the north wall of the Bar. To build_an unattached plastered column and wood trellis outside the front doors and realign the.walkway from the front Lobby to the proposed new door location. A23:\Certificate of Appropriateness -1- II. - Project Background 1. Expanded description of the project (including architectural and historical characteristics important to the project). The bldg. is part of a historic district, but as noted in the Mellon Report, has been previously renovated and changed. The foyer area.is wood frame and plaster construction. We intend to`keep the physical characteristics as they are, but wish to move the doors to create a better visual attraction for the 2. Common of project, if any 3. Relationship to a larger project or series of projects, if applicable. Describe how this project relates to other activities, phases and developments planned, or.now underway. This is part of the interior remodel of the restaurant-_ and bar_ 'New furniture, fixtures and equipment, and a realignment of the bar are planned. 4. List and describe any other related permits and other public approvals required for this -project, including those -required by the City, Regional, State, and Federal agencies. (Indicate approval status, agency name, and type of permit required. May be attached.) ' City of La Quinta - Building Permit 5. What original deed restriction(s), if any, concerning the type of improvements and class of uses permitted were placed on the property involved? (You may attach copy of original printed restrictions in answer to this question after properly underscoring those features governing the type of improvements and class of uses permitted thereby). None are known. 6. When did present owner acquire the property? 12/31/93. 7. When did propertyobtain historical resource, landmark, or district status? 1996. A23:\Certificate of Appropriateness -2- A 8. . What other level(s) of historical status does this property have: (X) Local O State O National Register M. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION TO BE SUBMITTED WITH THIS APPLICATION X '(1) Site plan in appropriate scale - 25 copies X (2) Photographs, old and recent X (3) Elevations - 25 copies X (4) Floor plans - 25 copies (5) Other Signature of Applicant Date . 8/11 / 00 Authority for'this application is hereby given: Date Date IMPORTANT: Any false or misleading information shall be grounds for denying this application. Signatures and addresses of all owners as shown in the Office of the County Recorder must be included. NOTE: Please FOLD all maps down to 8-1/2" x 11" (accordion style excepting presentation material). A23:\Certificate of Appropriateness -3- P.O. Box 1504 78-495 CALLE TAMPICO LA QUINTA, CALIFORNIA 92253 September 22, 2000 Ms. Andrea Merril -Mock La Quinta Resort Resort & Club Post Office Box 69 La Quinta, Calif. 92253 FILE (760) 777-7000 (TDD) (760) 777-12.27 SUBJECT: Certificate of Appropriateness 2000-006 (Azur Restaurant) Dear Ms. Mock, The .Historic Preservation Commission at its meeting of September 21, 2000, recommended approval of your request to the City Council to remodel the entry area to the restaurant area west of the hotel lobby area. The City Council will. consider your request at its meeting of October 3, 2000, at 3:00 p.m. in the council chambers. Please attend.to answer any questions that arise. Should you have any questions, please call me at (76.0) 777 -7064. - Very truly yours, JERRY HERMAN COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR STAN B. SAWA Principal Planner c: Christi di lorio, Planning Manager pAstan\Itr coa 2000-006.wpd I .ev t 4 COUYCIL/RDA MEETING DATE: October 3, 2000 Appr:)vai of a Certificate of Appropriateness to Revise the Entry Area of the Restaurant to the West of the Hotel Lobby Entry Area Located at 49-499 Eisenhower Drive, Within the La Quinta Resort and Club. Applicant: KSL Desert Resorts, Inc. 9 AGENDA CATEGORY: BUSINESS SESSION: CONSENT CALENDAR: /d STUDY SESSION: PUBLIC HEARING: RECOMMENDATION: Approve Certificate of Appropriateness 2000-006, subject to findings. FISCAL IMPLICATIONS: None. CHARTER CITY IMPLICATIONS: None. BACKGROUND AND OVERVIEW: The restaurant is in a building which is a part of the original La Quinta Hotel constructed in 1926-27. While the City has designated the hotel and its grounds as a local historic development, the original character -defining architectural features of this portion of the hotel have been irreparably altered. Therefore, it does not contribute on its architectural merit. However, it is important that the proposed design be ccmpatible with the overall character of its historic architectural features. The origintal buildings have set the tone for development of the entire City and therefore, review of modifications are of importance. The La Quinta Charter and Municipal Code requires that revisions or additions to designated historic structures obtain approval from the City Council. This requires review and recommendation from the Historic Preservation Commission. P:\STALJ\coa 2000-006 cc rpt.wpd Proposed Revisions: The restaurant is located to the west of the hotel registration area, in front of the plaza and valet area.- The previous Montanas restaurant is closed and being remodeled into a seafood restaurant called Azur. The applicant is proposing to modify the entry area to the restaurant to improve its visibility to guests (Attachment 1). The proposal is to move the existing double arched wood doors which were installed in 1988 approximately 12 feet to the north, away from the interior corner of the "L" shaped' building. In front of the new door location, a freestanding wood trellis supported by eight smooth plastered columns, similar in design to the one over the lobby entry without the tile roofing will be constructed. The terra cotta tile walkways in front of the restaurant and between the lobby entry and fountain will be reconstructed to correspond with the new entry. Material colors and finishes will match that used in the existing building and walks, except that small blue tile accents will be added to the rectangular terra cotta tile walkway beneath the new trellis. A new false window will be provided to the left of the new door location. With the revision to the walkways, most of the adjacent landscaping will be replanted. Plants retained include the large Ficus near the south wall of the restaurant, the Palm tree at the east end near the lobby entry, and bougainvillea against the west wall of the restaurant. The color theme of the new landscaping includes plants that are primarily "blue" or "white". Discussion: Pursuant to the La Quinta Charter and Municipal Code Section 7.08.030, the request can be approved if, and only if, it is determined: 1. That the proposed work would not detrimentally alter, destroy or adversely affect any architectural or landscape improvement. RESPONSE: The proposed design modifications are in keeping with the architectural character of the historic structures on the hotel grounds. The new landscaping and walkways will not significantly modify the plaza area in front of the restaurant. 2. If the owner of the designated historic site or landmark demonstrates that such property cannot be economically used and denial of a permit would deprive the owner of all or most of his economic interest in the property, the City Council may issue the permit with an effective date 180 days from the issuance of the permit to allow time for the investigation of alternatives to the work proposed in the permit application, such as acquisition of site improvement by the City or a public interest group. 002 P:\STAN\coa 2000-006 cc rpt.wpd A, RESPONSE: The proposed revision to Ithe entry area to a non-contributing building is in keeping with the character of the historic complex. 3. In the ca_ se, of construction of a new improvement upon a historic site, that the exterior of such improvement will not adversely affect and will be compatible with the external appearance of existing historically designated improvements { on said site. jl RESPONSE: The trellis is similar to the lobby entry trellis and therefore, compatible. The new trellis will be freestanding and not have a clay tile covering, thus providing differentiation from the original construction. 4. That the applicant has presented clear and convincing evidence of facts demonstratingto the satisfaction of the Council that such disapproval 'City will impose immediate and substantial hardship on the applicant because of conditions peculiar to the person seeking to carry out the work, whether.this be property owner, tenant, or resident, or because of conditions peculiar to the j particular improvement, or other feature involved, and that approval of the application will be consistent with the purposes of the permit procedures. i RESPONSE: The applicant has shown that the revision to the restaurant will improve access and visibility from adjacent areas, the design as presented is compatible with the exictin construction Th g e applicant has shown a desire to maintain design modifications compatible with the historic integrity of the structure. Historic Preservation Commission Review: The'' Historic Preservation Commission considered this request at its meeting of 'September 21, 2000, and adopted Minute Motion 2000-019, on a 4-0 vote, recommending approval as submitted. The Historic Preservation Commission meeting minutes are attached for your review (Attachment 2). FINDINGS AND ALTERNATIVES: Findings necessary to approve can be made as noted above. The alternatives available to the City Council include: 1. ji Approve Certificate of Appropriateness 2000-006, subject to the attached Findings. jl 2. . ! Deny the request; or ail 3. Continue the request and provide staff with direction P:\STAN\coa 2000-006 cc rpt.wpd 003 Respectfully submitted, Ali Jerry Herman 47 Community Development Director Approved for submission by: Thomas P. Genovese, City Manager Attachments: 1. Proposed plan exhibit book (bound book) (for City Council only) 2. Historic Preservation Commission minutes for the meeting of September 21, 2000 = P:\STAN\coa 2000-006 cc rpt.wpd • ATTACHMENT(S) 005 ATTACHMENT 2 DRAFT Historic Preservation Commission Minutes September 21, 2000 i ii B. Certificate of Appropriateness 2000-006• located at 49-499 Eisenhower Drive within the La Quinta Resort and Club to revise the entry area of the restaurant to the west of the Hotel Lobby. Applicant: KSL Desert Resorts, 1. Planning Manager Christinedi lorio presented the staff report, a copy of which is on file in the Community Development Department. {! 2. Commissioner Irwin asked if the interior wall mural of the Conquistidor on Horseback would remain. 3. David K. Robbins, Senior Vice President of KSL Development Corporation replied he did not know the answer to that question, but said he didn't believe anything on the inside would be affected. jj 4. Commissioner Irwin added she'd understood when the mural was originally installed there were gemstones in it and when the .Hotel was closed during World War II, the stones were dug out. I� i 5. Doug Yavanian, KSL Director of Community Affairs, replied he j would get an answer for the Commission. 6. Mr. Robbins told the Commission he assumed any interior changes ;I would have to come before' them for approval. 1{ 7. Planning Manager di lorio said the City does not have any interior regulations. 8. Commissioner Irwin interjected the mural was something that added to the character of the original La Mirage Room making it very special to the City's history and thought it would not detract from a new restaurant. 9. Commissioner Sharp said he was unclear if the tile path ended at the arbor and asked where the logo or sign for the restaurant was going to be. 10. Mr. Robbins replied he did not know if that had been determined yet but it was a good question. i 006 Historic. Preservation Commission Minutes September 21, 2000 L 11. Commissioner Sharp replied he Was concerned about it. 12. Chairman Wright asked Mr. Robbins if he wished to address any particular item. 13. Mr. Robbins introduced himself and Doug Yavanian and stated they were fine with the staff report and were at the meeting to answer concerns or to address any opposition. 14. Commissioner Mitchell stated he was under -the impression nothing was going to occur from the inside and was concerned about changes to the interior. He felt the exterior plan adhered to the Guidelines of the Secretary of Interior, in that it maintained the feeling and sensitivity of the structure. He agreed with staff's recommendations. 15. Commissioner Irwin also agreed it was a beautiful project. 16. Commissioner Sh-arp commented the plans looked very elegant. He had visited the site the previous day: 17. Chairman Wright also thought it was a beautiful project and a great presentation but added he would like to see the mural stay intact. 18. There being no further discussion, it was moved and seconded by Commissioners Sharp/Mitchell to adopt Minute Motion 2000-019 . recommending approval of the requested revision of the restaurant entry. Unanimously approved. 007 HISTORIC PRESERVATION'COMMISSION STAFF REPORT DATE: SEPTEMBER 21, 2000 ITEM: CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS 20007006 ` REQUEST: REQUEST :,TO' REVISE THE ENTRY AREA OF, THE " RESTAURANT TO THE WEST OF THE HOTEL LOBBY ENTRY AREA r LOCATION: 49499 'EISENHOWER DRIVE, WITHIN THE LA QUINTA RESORT AND. CLUB - APPLICANTS: KSL DESERT RESORTS, INC. (ANDREA. MERRILL-MOCK) LANDSCAPE ' ARCHITECT: STAMPER WHITIN WORKS - BACKGROUND: The restaurant is in a building which is a part of the original La Quinta Hotel, which -was constructed in 1926-27. While the hotel and its grounds have been designated by the. City as historic, the original character defining historic features have been altered 'in the building 'in which this restaurant is :in. Although altered enough to exclude its inclusion on the National Register of, in. Places, .the original hotel . buildings still possess architectural integrity at the local level. It has set the tone for development of the entire City and therefore, modifications are of importance. The Municipal" Code requires that revisions or additions to designated historic structures obtain approval from the City Council. This requires review and recommendation from the Historic Preservation Commission. PROPOSED REVISIONS:- The EVISIONS: The restaurant is located to the west of the hotel registration area; in front of the plaza and valet area. The previous Montanas restaurant is closed and being remodeled into a seafood restaurant called Azur. The applicant is proposing to modify the entry area to improve its visibility to guests. The proposal is to move the existing double arched wood' doors which. were installed in 1988 approximately 12 feet to the north, away from the interior corner of the "L" p:\stan\hpc rpt ca 2000-0061qresort.wpd U shaped building. In front of the new door location, a freestanding wood trellis supported by eight smooth plastered columns, similar in design to the one over the lobby entry without the tile roofing, will be constructed. The terra cotta tile walkways in front of the restaurant and between the lobby entry and fountain will be reconstructed to correspond with the new entry. Material colors and finishes will, match that used in the existing building and walks, except that small blue the accents will be added to the rectangular terra cotta tile walkway beneath the new trellis. A new false window is show to the left of the new door location. With the revision to the walkways, most of the adjacent landscaping. will be replanted. Plants retained include the large Ficus near the south wall of the .restaurant, the'Palm tree at -the east end near the lobby entry, and bougainvillea against the west wall of the restaurant. The theme of the new landscaping includes plants that are primarily "blue" or "white". ) DISCUSSION: Pursuant to Municipal Code Section 1.08.030, the request can be approved if, and only if, it is determined: 1. That the proposed work would not detrimentally alter, destroy or adversely affect any architectural or landscape improvement. RESPONSE: The proposed design modifications are in keeping with the architectural character of the historic structures on the hotel grounds. The new landscaping and walkways will not significantly modify the plaza area in front of the restaurant. 2. -If the owner of the designated historic site or landmark demonstrates that such property cannot be economically used and denial of a permit would deprive the owner of all or most of his economic interest in the property, the.City Council may issue the permit with an effective date 180 days from the issuance of the permit to allow time for` the investigation of alternatives to the work proposed in the permit', application, such as acquisition of site improvement by the City or a public interest group. RESPONSE: The proposed revision to the entry area to a non-contributing building is in keeping with character of the historic complex. 3. In tfie case of construction of a new improvement upon a historic site, that the .exterior of such improvement will not adversely affect and will .be compatible with the external appearance of existing historically designated improvements on said site. p:\stan\hpc rpt ca 2000-006 Iq resort.wpd �r RESPONSE: The trellis while similar to the lobby, entry trellis and therefore,. compatible, will be freestanding and not have a clay tile covering, thus providing differentiation from the original construction. { 4. That. the applicant has presented clear and convincing evidence of facts demonstrating to the satisfaction of the City Council that such disapproval will impose immediate and substantial hardship on the applicant because of conditions peculiar to the person seeking to carry out the work, whether this be property owner, tenant, or resident, or because of conditions peculiar to the particular improvement, or other feature involved, and -that approval of the application will be consistent with the purposes of the permit procedures.. RESPONSE: The. applicant has shown that the revision to the restaurant will improve access and visibility from adjacent areas, the design as presented is compatible with the existing construction, and the applicant has shown a desire to maintain design modifications compatible with the historic integrity of the structure. RECOMMENDATION: Adopt Minute. Motion 2000-_, recommending approval of the requested revision to the restaurant entry. Attachment: 1. Proposed plan exhibits 2. Applicable Secretary ,of the Interior's Standards for Treatment of Historic Properties 3. Preservation Brief 14 Prepared by: Stan B. Sawa, Principal Planner Submitted by: �J t Christine di lorio, P nning Manager p:\stan\hpc rpt ca 2000-006 Iq resort.wpd _ _ y � � .. _ r ' . , .. '. t � r. 4 .. � � .. r r _ ' � � i ' � I 1 1 Le Bernardin @ Montanas Restaurant August 11, 2000 IASL Desert Resorts, Inc 49 499 Eisenhower Drive La Quinta, CA 92253 The City of La Quinta, California Historical Preservation Commission Community Development Department AUG 1 j f Pc/T �ANN NG � PQU/NTA ATMENT, AZUR Landscape Entry Concept for Restaurant Renovation Paving The paving under the trellis matches the surrounding existing terra cotta tile. The pattern changes to incorporate small blue tile insets. This paving helps to define the distinctive qualities of Azur while recalling the heritage of the existing paving. Landscape The landscape alternatives build on the garden tradition represented throughout the hotel grounds and uses the enormous existing fig tree to provide a shady retreat. The plant palette emphasizes a strong blue and white color theme. The addition of seating and planting at the existing fountain suggests an oasis of dining and entertainment. Accents of palms, textural agaves and desert spoons, flowering shrubs and climbing vines help create an environment that is distinct yet in harmony with the eclectic garden charm of La Quinta. STAMPER WHITIN WORKS 1504 So. Coast Highway Laguna Beach, CA 92651 USA T. 949 497 8298 F. 949 494 2421 stamper®stamFerwhitinworks.com The renovation design for the Azur entry respects La Quinta's legendary arrival landscape and welcoming traditions. The traveler seeking retreat, a charming desert hideaway and distinctive dining experience finds refuge here. Preserving the qualities and ' heritage established in 1926, as well as recognizing renovations added over the years, establishes an eclectic landscape experience unique to La Quinta. The aim of this renovation is to contribute thoughtfully to both La Quinta's history and future. ' The design elements that contribute to the renovation include: the relocation of the wooden entry doors; shifting the entry walk to form a direct connection from the lobby to the restaurant; adding columns with trellis; improving the existing fountain circle; and renovating the existing landscape. Trellis and Columns The realigned walk and new vine covered trellis emphasize the existing oversized wooden doors and strengthen the connection between the Lobby entry and Azur entry. The arrival to the restaurant is enhanced and framed by the trellis. Flowering vines wind up round stucco columns reminiscent of the Lobby columns and cascade over the wood trellis. Soft landscape lighting illuminates the trellis at night. Doors The Azur restaurant renovation includes relocating the existing wooden doors. The doors provide continuity to the past, add old world charm and provide a focal point from the Lobby entry. Paving The paving under the trellis matches the surrounding existing terra cotta tile. The pattern changes to incorporate small blue tile insets. This paving helps to define the distinctive qualities of Azur while recalling the heritage of the existing paving. Landscape The landscape alternatives build on the garden tradition represented throughout the hotel grounds and uses the enormous existing fig tree to provide a shady retreat. The plant palette emphasizes a strong blue and white color theme. The addition of seating and planting at the existing fountain suggests an oasis of dining and entertainment. Accents of palms, textural agaves and desert spoons, flowering shrubs and climbing vines help create an environment that is distinct yet in harmony with the eclectic garden charm of La Quinta. STAMPER WHITIN WORKS 1504 So. Coast Highway Laguna Beach, CA 92651 USA T. 949 497 8298 F. 949 494 2421 stamper®stamFerwhitinworks.com AVO. r[NNANOO 111111 I!I IIIII IIIII I1FFITI ' � II11111111111 m ++H-ItF -� �IIIIIIIIIIIIIU ] � __ 1111111'�,1�1111 � � _- III�IF III11 1,.f- Mull .9! �H�Mm� LOS A11YOLIS t La Quinta Resort & Club Site Map Location of Montanas Resta >Nli 7 00 60 40 20 0 00 160 NO �L SCALE 1'-00' I �Q° ��1111111 I: J � J .�. 0 0 � L� -= I as l�oa mol_ L _ u ►'rl , I n M I n ^ n I i MDSa coNsOGYCII o ucrim YNY im a M7P• W Aw Y (itll 1)1-tlY -y.- } 1 • 1 YNl �AIyAAN�a-Y+-I 'i;l f1ANIfINp • [NlLN[AINO • SYNVIYIMG • n•u.nm�w�... .vsv m r m m m m m m r i= m w m m m m m m Jr a�j h it-. 4,y 1NAM 1 cn c maid � J® o ~ y %d CCD 0 � Jr a�j h it-. 4,y 1NAM 1 ro 5 my� Jr a�j h it-. 4,y 1NAM 1 = m m m= m = = m m= m m m m m m m m cn Ch 711 T CD CD cn Ch 711 T m m m m m r m r r m m m m r +rte m r r m m 1 rW.. TI T T7TFTI a x m 1 rW.. TI T T7TFTI w m m m m m m m m m m mm mm No rI M m M z d O �• N Q O cn M m m m m r m= m m m r m m m m m® m m --� r- nEl (DUQ � o h.v Rel 79-- `' rUQ ' . CD Ln cn Ey rn p CD CD CD G7 l - O CD . rte`-• CD ilk �. ` .. s k 111 •�ihh 1 ``\' , � `� ���� ~ ���- r10 r r W � o2,0 �y CDy moo z CD Ln cn Ey rn p CD CD CD G7 l - O CD . rte`-• CD ilk �. ` .. s k 111 •�ihh 1 ``\' , � `� ���� ~ ���- m r m r m m +ter mm mm i m mm Em ■■1 m m Pj i> CD CD CD ! 'l7 M." �• G CD n C � CD CD p CD w O UR C P cn CD CD d O �y CD O O CD F� W CD R• cD I 4 rr r W CD w N y� max o .CD � C i> CD CD CD ! 'l7 M." �• G CD n C � CD CD p CD w O UR C P cn CD CD d O �y CD O O CD F� W CD R• cD I CI 11 r� t 11 AZUR Le Bernardin @ Montanas Restaurant Montanas Restaurant is going to reopen in season as a gourmet seafood restaurant run by the owner and chef of Le Bernardin, the renowned seafood restaurant in New York. The interior of the restaurant will boast a fresh new look, in keeping with the Spanish heritage of La Quinta. The designer, George Design Studio, is a well respected firm in the industry and is also of New York. To afford better visibility to the guest, we propose to keep the existing arched wood entry doors at the foyer, but to move the doors to the north approximately twelve feet. To further enhance the visual statement, a plaster column and wood trellis, planted and gently lit, and reminiscent of the columns at the front Lobby, is proposed at the front entry court. To reinforce the image of Azur, the surrounding planting is proposed in a blue theme. The paving under the trellis and leading the guest to the entry, is to be saltillo pavers with small blue tiles inset into the pattern. To maintain the historic charm of the main entry of the hotel, much care has been given to the selection of appropriate paver and plant materials, trellis elements, and reusing the entry doors and foyer as they currently exist, in the new location. The following pictures show the existing entry to Montanas,.as it was reconstructed in 1988. In the first picture the distance of 17' off the front wall is shown. The second picture shows the existing doors, installed in 1988 and their floor closer, at the wood frame and plaster wall. The third and fourth pictures show physical investigation into the foyer walls, displaying the wood and plaster construction. As always, we plan to enhance our property with the proposed changes, while keeping the unique historic elements alive for the pleasure of our guests. The prospect of having such a well known and highly honored restaurant at La Quinta Resort & Club is eagerly anticipated. We look to the City and the Historic Preservation Commision for partnering and guidance as we approach this enhancement to the hotel. Andrea Merrill -Mock Project Manager 8/11/00 I I I I 17' off wall is wcx)d fi-ame and plaster construction as shown. by the measuring tape, I 11 1 u [I ll� t J F L L� 1 1 ~� }. ��� �.0 g,; t m m m 9 m fs Ll I w 7