The URL can be used to link to this page

RatingsREQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Terra Nova Planning and Research Reviewer•_ Date: Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 Experience Scope of Work 25 30 Presentation Format 5 5 Unique Qualities 10 Total 100 Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation)-+ Comments: �)D6 Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date TOTAL Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Terra Nova Planning and Research Reviewer: af�CoOC Date: Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 Experience 25 Scope of Work 30 5 Presentation Format Unique Qualities 5 10 Total 100 Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation) Comments: ml—s T �r,� u: 0,6 Gt-to - ff ounz TOTAL —,—. Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Terra Nova Planning and Research Reviewer: Date: Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 Experience 25 2 Scope of Work 30 Presentation 5 Format 5 Ll Unique Qualities 10 7 Total 100 Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation) O, c, C t,C Ze C-ri Comments:_Y-p) e- tr r em e W1,4 A L-Q L' , ate `l dg, knvt TOTAL Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date Scoring Breakdown: W ��W CAI IPORNIA - INTERVIEW EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Terra Nova Planning and Research Reviewer; �� 1.�' i i c Y Date: 12/ 13/ 18 Presentation of Scope of Work 25 _1 Questions 25 20 Initial Vision 20 I Experience 10 q Creativity 10 `] Intangibles/Fit 10 7 Total 100 -] e, Intangibles (Explanation): ood c4-iwU -t1 vY-"..xo 0 cc G� t� ` i Cbt� pro �ytyyv-A -� - ��L I,,, i 44,- S :Lr s �. rl [M Cj_lti"i � �CQ ko- tom- (^tr Comments: (!r4 jf (. f '.0 c "Cg� �f ; C � �y-P r-�7 - rl e d +o 4 c�,y� e✓ Ltt y LP_c' r ri i'l Y P C,6 pie �'L.L`� cL c LA-- w { TOTAL Reviewers Signature &, 4-,� j & � Contract Administrator's Initials Date S �Yi - a E L, rb s�"e s-, w 4'� Yam_ C_crco-c c �P,9 LA-P (A tj S- rX �r Gem--- C^ S . , P JSY' ta (2aiaa CALIFORNIA - INTERVIEW EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Terra Nova Planning and Research Reviewer• - �CQ' Date: 12/ 13/ 18 Presentation of Scope of Work 25 Questions 25 Initial Vision 20 Experience 10 .to Creativity 10 w Intangibles/Fit 10 ,4 Total 100 r10 Intangibles (Explanation): Comments: L-kr,-u-4U 4-1D Ca� �[�.nC��-{t � �� --�� • BSc s [ x�_ c� � I2Q u/�.2o� �Y1 TOTAL Reviewer's Sig Contract Administrator's Initials Date ta 0al(Ara C 1LIFOR\IA - INTERVIEW EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Terra Nova Planning and Research Reviewer: � C C[Ct y 1 Date: 12/ 13/ 18 j Presentation of Scope of Work 25 Questions 25 2 b Initial Vision 20 >-7 Experience 10 Creativity 10 g Intangibles/Fit 10 $ Total 100 [ Intangibles (Explanation): / Comments: �/1S`i-Ul`y( J/(U =7.� 77� SSt" 5 i S rye 64 t I 6,7�-x/l/A Is TOTAL n l �Gl� r!l �l(I�1� clwz c-r%�lv cUV / / r 7? j 7 Reviewer's Signature'. r Contract Administrator's Initials Date G� �� . Cc�cr��(1G� �� GV' C �X i L f ..�. ., , � r � d Z�J S Cc' S 1� J� � r �ZO��i 7� � c�'�C�i�'� f Z SC �L��U��' ta GiKra CAL IFORVIA - INTERVIEW EVALUATION Highway ill Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Terra Nova Plannina and Research Reviewer: - Date: 12/ 13/ 18 Presentation of Scope of Work 25 211 Questions 25 Initial Vision 20 Z Experience 10 D Creativity 10 Intangibles/Fit 10 Total 100 7 Intangibles (Explanation): • u�ZT'Ti�L�- 'iil TOTAL Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date c4( &�-At-t ta Qa[ t ra C \1 [FORNL\ - INTERVIEW EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Terra Nova Planning and Research Reviewe Date: 12/ 13/ 18 Presentation of Scope of Work 25 Questions 25 'Lc7 Initial Vision 20 Experience 10 Creativity 10 Intan ibles/Fit 10 Total 100 Intangibles (Explanation): Comments: TOTAL Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date TzMOA�va-, - I-L'ItLkk - -------- - ---------- 0 1 Out 4, , �i � r •�� # �� I r � � i REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: MSA Consulting Reviewer Date; ,'if Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 Experience 25 Sco a of Work 30 Z,, Presentation 5 =) Format 5 Unique Qualities 10 Total 100 Unique Qualities (Intangibles) : (Explanation) Comments: Gp: r r' �1_:4'+�,`��eG� �[ , is 4 ✓a -:) OF �[ Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials EC r, WW, TOTAL Date Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: MSA Consulting Reviewer:, �C��•�Y -+ Date: M 2—t I L Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understandini and Approach 25 'DO Experience 25 %`'l Sco a of Work 30 t V Presentation 5 GL Format 5 Uni ue Qualities 10 8 Total 100, Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation) Comments: ��. - _ C- i, L r - 0 c—,., ! 0 l c;C' W TOTAL C R Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials. Date Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: MSA Consulting Reviewer; Lk e i', Date: r-iG Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 —.?-- Experience 25 2 Scope of Work 30 22. Presentation 5 Format 5 q Unique Qualities 10 Total 100 Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation) S r +v-�t.�� Comments: g r- 4tv, r e.� r 0 v &to, �. TOTAL 93 Reviewer's Signature 17I � � ■ r -�'� Contract Administrator's Initials Date Scoring Breakdown: ta Qal�fra u [FORN n INTERVIEW EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: MSA Consulting Reviewer:chi Date: 12/ 13/ 18 Presentation of Scope of Work 25 'JD Questions 25 Initial Vision 20 Experience 10 Creativity 10 Intangibles/Fit 10 Total 100 Intangibles (Explanation): Comments: TOTAL Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date C&4tzil, ■ F A it (JV C ta Qwkra - CAI IFORNIA INTERVIEW EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: MSA Consultin Reviewer: - Date: 12/ 13/ 18 Presentation of Scope of Work 25 22 Questions 25 2 3 Initial Vision 20 3 Experience 10 Creativity 10 Intangibles/Fit 10 Total 100 Intangibles (Explanation): Comments: TOTAL 3 �jtReviewer's Signature a l � Contract Administrator's Initials Date INTERVIEW EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: MSrA,ConsultiEkg Reviewer: Date: 12/ 13/ 18 Presentation of Scope of Work 25 uestions 25 Zv Initial Vision 20 J Experience 10 Creativity 10 Intangibles/Fit 10 Total 100 Intangibles (Explanation): 1-0 CCLt -e a--,� rn f—eg raJ ect e a ;4; . comments `cL WLCtv COL(15 f)0,4 Afe-CL r 3 b-A-s Snc-c.e, , t�-Ai 0.6 ta Qa�Kra - (A[ IFORNIA (� P ,C- rU`L +ems CL -,V,A , L -0,Lk- &-�- 04- -X -f C n e TOTAL 1 Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date S�r�cs" CAb p(L (f w- 4 �, - [�, 5 - of 1 C4- b a)",- A K'a e.", eA/ ( s 1-. SP o6 p o-,,, cLk- e, ti U) ( c. l—i ►/enP.�� mz,-L V�,Cmlvl p cy .� N2R t(I0 � dA/(�f,/ Al IPORNIA INTERVIEW EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: MSA Consulting Reviewer: Date: 12/ 13/ 18 Presentation of Scope of Work 25 Questions 25 b Initial Vision 20 QD Experience 10 t o i Creativity 10 49 —1 Intangibles/Fit 10 1 Total 100 cc PA Intangibles (Explanation): 02iI�&�- fy-ya C1.(QYLQ Comments: 9-LUrr�t CLx"Js�g Ste{ k6 -Sr �J ,�lu� TOTAL Reviewer's SignatukC Contract Administrator's Initials Date ta 0"Cra — (A[ IFORNIn INTERVIEW EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: MSA Consulting Reviewer- Date: 12/ 13/ 18 Presentation of Scope of Work 25 z,�) Questions 25 Z Initial Vision 20 '-7 Experience 10 Creativity 10 j Intan ibles/Fit 10 Total 100 ' pp I angibles Explanation): r:'c�L 1kSSirr ViAoi "0', J/ UV �"r� CL C r✓r 46q. Corn r ;k� TOTAL Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date A 6+ /tea w&,r 6fc/6hzrts�t zle 3 a 0!j!/! Noy, - s�c { � � G� �� C � 7 c ,reC�, a7r pi a s REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Dudek Reviewer:�� Date: — Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 Z2- Experience 25 Scope of Work 30 z 3 Presentation 5 Format 5 Unique Qualities 10 Ci Total 100 Unique Qualities (Intang,-0les) ..1 (Explanation) {� Com�ments:CvuSZo z 7 TOTAL Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Dudek Reviewer: Date: Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 Experience 25 ZZ Scope of Work Presentation 30 5 Format Unique Qualities 5 10 Total 100 Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation) Comments: TOTAL Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Dudek Reviewer: `«. E e, Date: Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 2-7- Experience 25 ZZ Scope of Work 30 2S Presentation 5 Format 5 Unique Qualities 10 Total 100 B Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation) 13,1? c4 s e + e,-� eA--) fy k-a-4t; k— ��, ;pl a Comments: k1104 K -2-05- LF J TOTAL n Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date Scoring Breakdown: 4(V QaW - CAL IPOR\IA - INTERVIEW EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: 'Dudek � Reviewer: Date: 12/ 13/ 18 Presentation of Scope of Work 25 1,210 Questions 25 Initial Vision 20 Experience 10 Creativity 10 Intangibles/Fit 10 Total 100 Intangibles (Explanation): Comments: TOTAL Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date I ro ta Qal�fra CALIr - INTERVIEW EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Dudek Reviewer: Date: 12/ 13/ 18 Presentation of Scope of Work 25 Questions 25 Z Initial Vision 20 Experience 10 p Creativity 10 Intangibles/Fit 10 Total 100 Intangibles (Explanation): Comments: TOTAL t v Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date rl o t-o, () U-ce. &-e- v i e- S--L� 9{ S c o 4 S ,�-�� ✓ s u s ' G I� f � —„�, s - � `" tev QW�Kraj CAI IFORNIA INTERVIEW EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Dudek Reviewer e Kie,,n' Date: 12/13/18 Presentation of Scope of Work 25 2,0 Questions 25 J�t 0 Initial Vision 20 10 Experience 10 Creativity 10 Intangibles/Fit 10 Total 1001Z Intangibles (Explanation): YTS +000me-L^s Wk,G— PlArRo-,4"r C, ci- b—t,,1 + 0 f-,:;o (- �47 :S Comments-, 0,6- Ll Pw-w q, vv va-q tp re,6j <.)-t\ TOTAL �0_ aReviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date , i- � a m 4- in.a-� 'S 2 -i 1 5CC.J �. t p °� �, ,�-K-,.� ac,�,(' w-w'f ►tee-c`-�`-- e,�s ��e., ta Qw�fra CALIFORN[.\ INTERVIEW EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: D dek Reviewer: Date: 12/ 13/ 18 Presentation of Scope of Work 25 Questions 25 Initial Vision 20 Experience 10 Q Creativity 10 Intan ibleslFit 10 -1 Total 100 Intangibles (Explanation): Comments: c,U `c�4� 6z.hav, �3, � C-yrz ® I�stL►�cJ 0? r ,ra--4L u] �rz� "wo f�c l�la (� �� Y ► �. Ccl��le m-t�' TOTAL Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date INTERVIEW EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Dudek Reviewer: 4�6 Date: 12/ 13/ 18 Presentation of Scope of Work 25 Questions 25 7 G Initial Vision 20 l7 Experience 10 7 Creativity 10 -Intangibles/Fit 10 Total 100 sSU Intangibles (Explanation): / `i�t�Gl/ i �- ! 9 o4rt-C- -�6r5 ta Qwkra CAI IFOR\I:\ 19 Commen s; —71—kpkl G vP 9-r 12 fb (,L -die-e �J C iro i (SCL1 (G �Cf( 41/� r%1 Irf CA TOTAL 9 f Z? Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date gy�pp. l � l i.�<t Ps -) 4' M edf 17vi�—/e�� I 2 � 73 coUlskyps an UL1 4L� 6x� tl(lil� 4�ur IrK-(re� 6ul on /I lie �2re,!�- -ter REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Rangwalla Associates Team Reviewer: Date: Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 Experience 25 Scope of Work 30' Presentation 5 Z_ Format 5 Unique Qualities 10 Total 100 Unique Qualities (Intangibles): �./ (Explanation) Comments: Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date TOTAL Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Ran walla Associates Team Reviewer: i Date: -C7" i r Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 Experience 25 Scope of Work 30 �)q Presentation 5 Format 5 Unique Qualities 10 l.O Total 100 7 Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation) to np-0 Comments: �.J1C •�- ` _:r.r .r I,?IrQ TOTAL: Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: RangwaIla Associates Team Reviewer: t C)'+ Date: G Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 / 0 Experience 25 20 Scope of Work 30 240 Presentation 5 Format 5 Unique Qualities 10 Total 100 Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation) 0a.r--( n,� 5�r Comments: �nc tr1f '�' 5V-qqe�' -2i 'S i 1 rn Jn f U `.0 TOTAL 80 Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date Scoring Breakdown: ta Qaigra CALIFORNIA INTERVIEW EVALUATION Highway Ill Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Rangwala and Associates Reviewer• Date: 12/ 13/ 18 Presentation of Scope of Work 25 Questions 25 Initial Vision 20 Experience 10 Creativity 10 Intangibles/Fit 10 - Total 100 Intangibles (Explanation): Comments: TOTAL Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date mJ ' I i ': wo 1f ► A ! .ran Ul ta Qaigra (ALIFORNIA INTERVIEW EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Rangwala and Associates Reviewer:__ Date: 12/ 13/ 18 Presentation of Scope of Work 25 Z Questions 25 2 Initial Vision 20 157 Experience 10 I Creativity 10 Intangibles/Fit 10 Total 100 Intangibles (Explanation): Comments: TOTAL Reviewer's Signature r. Contract Administrator's Initials Date ta 0aiAra -1 %I 117OR\IA INTERVIEW EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: R/a�ngwala and Associates Reviewer:- CO2'ri V— I Date: 12/ 13/ 18 Presentation of Scope of Work 25 uestions 25 20 Initial Vision 20 Experience 10 ,g Creativity 10' Intangibles/Fit 10 Total 100 1 —7 Intangibles (Explanation): � `� C1 t MICr C, 6L)LA. 4y 1 b v PC, Comments: DC(.(6Lr1CC OA 4- IV h a f? ve r i S, �,�� c� e,c ► Ct::� a `. �: 6'�-�; f c w, _ U v, V C v\- a,,, o TOTAL Reviewer's Signature 0,"4rL, Contract Administrator's Initials Date C o 4 W 40 CJSerr s spa zld VIP p viko k� V:.),s i 1 1rc, taQ�W C At IfORNIA - INTERVIEW EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Roniqwala and Associates Reviewer: Date: 12/ 13/ 18 Presentation of Scope of Work 25 uestions 25 2 Initial Vision 20 Ra Ile) Experience 10 lO Creativity 10 q Intangibles/Fit 10 Total 100 Intangibles (Explanation): iF 0!�oLl �A[]��p5 etc, c�Qr�efwr04 4, PLOW Comments: _-Q>CiN0P ' P-'17 a [�1 Ugkk)� '-V 60 ti r 9e 0.0-r) - Ydh- 0lS TOTAL a' Reviewer's Signatur Contract Administrator's Initials Date taQai�tra CALIFORNIA - INTERVIEW EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Ranawala and Associates !7 Reviewer:_�I1 Date: 12/ 13/ 18 Presentation of Scope of Work 25 Z-( Questions 25 Initial Vision 20 /$ Experience 10 j Creativity 10 $ Intangibles/Fit 10 Total 100 Intangibles (Explanation): Comments: (Alm ,�Il?.iGkl r'S, VIS crT s i s eL TOTALrI Reviewer's Signature �tff G Contract Administrator's Initials Date /. -ors 76, A h kS d&�' o-Aar ��j e-,C,15 C,-5e J' f4(l 7� (Ar REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Placeworks Reviewer: Date: Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 1�zo Experience 25 Z-� Scope of Work 30 �y Presentation 5 y Format 5 Unique Qualities 10 5 Total 100 g�) Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation)r1� Comments: vl� �.��y f,-�k..1� . i Reviewer's Signature 1� Contract Administrator's Initials Date TOTAL Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Placewa Reviewer. Date: I l 12'1 / l 2) Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 90 Experience 25 Scope of Work 30 ) 01 Presentation 5 Format 5 a Unique Qualities 10 a Total 100 Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation) Comments:C TOTAL 1(0 Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Placeworks Reviewer- C r'r� Date: I 7 Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Ap roach Experience 25 2'2 25 2 2 Scope of Work 30.I� Presentation 5 Format 5 41 Unique Qualities 10 S Total 100 D Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation) , C Gt,. a �' 1:�/�' y "r� J:>Pll1 Oil �f U fr .rye f L l�n__ u c� a,L,1W Comments: &D-e Y ` ko- %?__0 S - 000 b," r V' � � r?t �•L f � � � tr m s" l.L-.n � _ _ ^�-y,�rr r� l' C � � �c. � �' 1 �•�a .a7 0�'?'� IP nti o . Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date TOTAL 0 V Scoring Breakdown: ta ICU CALIFORNIA INTERVIEW EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Placeworks C Reviewer: Date: 12/ 13/ 18 I Presentation of Scope of Work 25 Questions 25 Initial Vision 20 Experience 10 Creativity 10 - Intan ibles/Fit 10 Total 100 Intangibles (Explanation): Comments: TOTAL 1 � c Reviewer's Signature t Contract Administrator's Initials Date r Im W �4� Al IFORNLk INTERVIEW EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Placeworks .� Reviewer:— J.J 4--*` n Date: 12/ 13/ 18 Presentation of Scope of Work 25 �- Questions 25 rL Initial Vision 20 ) D Experience 10 j p Creativity 10 Intangibles/Fit 10 $ Total 100 Intangibles (Explanation): Comments:_yec ^'�1'� l+�! ; G�n,�,t �+- sr-6-er� - 1:Z�.i,e -A re, A.✓�/ws f � i � 4•�tz •,_� • � L, �. � � r Lam- sc`� � e '�`� r � !-+ we r} , � � , '.<-�. b .,� �e + �, •e I L� W ' I�,1 �` (< a G `+� G n'i f' '`'� A, E � 4 ( � � F ('� 'a, e\ P d Jr� 47 r- I / col �Jr` ��' l TOTAL Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date k.04,,4 ., A/t4,e- Or_� CO -el ptj�-c,te-c i f + I r ta Qaiwra (A LIFoRNIA - INTERVIEW EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Pl�acnew^ oaks Reviewer:- c'.YlL ' 00Y-eS Date: 12/ 13/ 18 Presentation of Scope of Work 25 'LD Questions 25 Initial Vision 20 1 S Ex erience 10 S Creativity 10 5 Intangibles/Fit 10 Total 100 (p8 Intangibles (Explanation): comments:- 1� '�`�- �I ` �.� 1l+ ��Y�c A4-t_q ►'cek r2, 1 n b C-( k;,,LL— �-c." 0 L 'W a- -60 Le-. TOTAL I Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date ta Qw�(ra (Al ❑:01MA- INTERVIEW EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Placeworks Reviewer: Date: 12/ 13/ 18 Presentation of Scope of Work 25 Questions 25 gq 1'1 Initial Vision 20 Experience 10 V0 Creativity 10 Intangibles/Fit 10 Total 100 Intangibles (Explanation): C)f-oUirU AD C JICE,--k-> [Y��Lc �Gt�tiir Comments: ems- _��) QV�Su;�.kr0 Q," � r,.,..s` �� i,�nct + r�s O'd S s clpo- ail=, l c o ey c( r49PcH-v0,kti cif �_ SDI c�1 C-5L) r c t9 l ►�Xcv�Q�. r�cG�G kt l-r`7 :lQ 0100V-22 It Of1-V- wou�j Sp (-Cu1C In Ho l i5 L CLPP1NEC — ecrm rn . TOTAL Reviewer's Sig Contract Administrator's Initials Date INTERVIEW EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Placeworks Reviewer: Date: 12/ 13/ 18 Presentation of Scope of Work 25 Questions 25 /< Initial Vision 20 d> Experience 10 $ Creativity 10 17 Intangibles/Fit 10 Total 1004.� Intangibles (Explanation): �'� �9,v��7'�CfSC6 �to —Grp CS�[ C�r� 1 �-~ Se I,� : I J l � 1 r ram, l eft ��+.n �-✓�'� �'�: 7 ��2 j' �s s :. Comments: ��°Ir r+�k �� - " 4 �5z<<10 o rli Jr Kj e�, l/! - - 2(z 6).ri C n it V - 4U ark 17 TOTAL Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date tev (2a�fra CALIFORNIA - I r C/P A� Ae� C s JA4-1</l4?�S J �inPU 7 fn REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Design Workshop Reviewer: Date: Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 j Ex erience 25 ' 0 Sco a of Work 30 z Presentation 5 Format 5 Z Unique Qualities 10 Total 100 Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanatipn)_ fly V2-I CCi 6:-- lvest;e Cornents c r ' Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date TOTAL Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Design Workshoa Reviewer - Date: ll 18 Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 Zo Experience 25 7.0 Scope of Work 30 Presentation 5 y Format 5 3 Unique Qualities 10 Total 100 -7 2 Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation)_3r---Yecc.- Comments: (\c W i s k-e TOTAL Reviewer's Signature ^ ={ Contract Administrator's Initials Date Scoring Breakdown: ta QaiKra rei n:ORNI:\ INTERVIEW EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Design Workshop Reviewer: f t/) Date: 12/ 13/ 18 Presentation of Scope of Work 25 S Questions 25 /S Initial Vision 20 Experience 10 Creativity 10 3 Intangibles/Fit 10 3 Total 100 Intangibles (Explanation): 7C:n! ! t �' zf - � 5g TOTAL C 7 Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date �. ham' is � i�� P� x a -t 9 -11W ��r /��irl�� r�AjlG� f7o 71 r,eCc°5-. 5,— ft (� a- s ct Ck.it D 4 7 L--, - 4, 1-2 YYL 177 ein �s are �n��/ ir�,� r� l4w 4,d A,vZO///. 101 Q"fa INTERVIEW EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Desicin Worksho Reviewer: Date: 12/ 13/ 18 Presentation of Scope of Work 25 Questions 25 Initial Vision 20 p Experience 10 Creativity 10 2 Intangibles/Fit 10 Total 100 �?, Intangibles (Explanation): Comments: ,F� TOTAL Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date ta Q"fra CAL IFORNiA INTERVIEW EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Desi n Worksho . r- Reviewer: Date: 12/ 13/ 18 Presentation of Scope of Work 25 1 S uestions 25 JO Initial Vision 20 Q Experience 10 Creativity 10 3 Intangibles/Fit 10 Total 1 100 Intangibles (Explanation); �� JjA-e ES cko 1 rQ a-- � Comments: FVnL-,��P (,z,C`rwm co" l t i C a.Q tomcj o l �' c C*-�;Y,�, 9L, IN V C Gwy- u" V 'r- e-0-ce, -�o ex p e- i ZY1 cc-,, N t e bt, C C C en a C e_ inn TOTAL Reviewer's Signaturet-�': Lt Contract Administrator's Initials Date r-�w 0--a w.--t 4� {t'-..,'- 7-q e- �� a n +-o UI t- S &, - b u r Y' t,l� �- wee- `� [ c7 ` Yx UJ o a-v- CQ, f- , c L� . S Y l o -{ +u 4\a- Vc { n 4- IAJ CUBl.j I j WL� �/'1i� i' V� ��/\ i �� T�-�Yvt- $�� ❑ (� V�� i.� V-b Ce/� o�.�� - ►'� are a n o d" f p .- Q 6L W ►rYl a " J e- 1 h" C (Mcv\. ta-,U� Y1f-- s 1,,-.e, roa �'2e �' YYk 6Lr lc-C-rrcaLt " 7 q5:�A►r C,%-- S S v �'�n �� c,r,� S C.Sr�$, Cx v.rt e� Cs �W CAL IPORNIA - INTERVIEW EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Desi n Workshop Reviewer: rn Date: 12/ 13/ 18 Presentation of Scope of Work 25 Questions 25 j D Initial Vision 20 r Experience 10 Creativity 10 Intangibles/Fit 10 Total 100 Intangibles (Explanation): Comments: TOTAL Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date 4 -e S' LJ nn.- .�. v Ac c---1 N � fell l �\� ✓ S a n d4-- L ti— C) u I r- el �+ i ►�►. ✓J v► 1 T v n ,L,..� fV / " ru r tvl C,-� ;Io I " r�l �- 544(4"A-C�-Z_. �1..0 �GJ-{- t(I Qw C - cA1IFORNIA - INTERVIEW EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Design Workshop Reviewer• ' Date: 12/ 13/ 18 Presentation of Scope of Work 25 Questions 25 p Initial Vision 20 Experience 10 Creativity 10 3 Intangibles/Fit 10 3 Total 100 Intangibles (Explanation): Comments: TOTAL Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date 6 r i W W 4 'ilk � . � ►�� .•� •►_! ■r IRE aA Olt'a ..r wv P !I 1 %i IA►, ,.din D/l un el n 11 h rll i n + a) REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: MW Steele Group Inc. Reviewer: Date: Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 2v Experience 25 ZO Scope of Work 30 Z �j Presentation 5 Format 5 I Unique Qualities 10 Total 100 Unique Qualities \(Intangibles): (Explanation) 7. 7 Comments: s(/b YC —0 ,1 .5�fC)i.,-,<-- drfe 6ale 5 TOTAL Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: MW Steele Group Inc. Reviewer L� Date ksI an C sb Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 Experience 25 Po Scope of Work 30 Presentation 5, Format 5 Unique Qualities 10 lP Total 100 -1QF1 Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation) 7 C� Npro4c+ ory-4 Ml. ,tk6 d Yt -s-Q Comments: TOTAL Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: MW Steele Group Inc. Reviewer:O,h e, F1 o re. Date: lj 2(p Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 Experience 25 Scope of Work 30 Presentation 5 Format 5 Unique Qualities 10 Total 100 Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation) Comments: �r �� ck.�e �� y TOTAL r Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway Ill Corridor Area Plan Consultant: De Novo Planning Groug Reviewer: Date: Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 Experience 25 Scope of Work 30 Presentation 5 Format 5 Unique Qualities 10 - Total 100 -7 Unique Qualities (Intangibles): -, (Explanation) __ 1 ,;,y r c lC fir. j < t C7 �' /r t� �J� S�r7�s a• i n o 51;4 Comments: - !' /�,l I a aft � � {�'�'�' _ • rr�. Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date TOTAL Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: De Novo Planning Groul2 Reviewer: Date: \112-� l ' Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 act Experience 25 k�b Scope of Work 30 Presentation 5 Format 5 Unique Qualities 10 Total 100 Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation) comments: l�kL, TOTAL" Reviewer's Signatu Contract Administrator's Initials Date Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: De Novo Planning Group Reviewer: r r- Date: Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding_and Approach 25 20 Experience 25 (- Sco e of Work 30 22 Presentation 5 Format 5 Unique Qualities 10 Total 100 Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation)L!e S_ 700 u -3 G�\l e. r, Comments: L.4 S r n QUA 3 Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date TOTAL -1 q Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: KTGY Architecture and Planning Firm Reviewer: Date: Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 Experience 25 / 7 _ Scope of Work 30 Z (� Presentation 5 Format 5 3 Unique Qualities 10 Total 100 C� Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation) Comments: .l tis fD /T16 TOTAL Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: KTGY Architecture and Planning Firm Reviewer: Af"(Cz• Date: 0 Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 Experience 25 Scope of Work 30 Presentation 5 Format 5 .� Unique Qualities 10 Total 100 Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation) Comments: J a -;"e-f"'.o e, TOTAL Reviewer's Signatu Contract Administrator's Initials Date Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway III Corridor Area Plan Consultant: KTGY Architecture and Planning Firm Reviewer: A-)e r t, F! Date: Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 Experience 25 /g Scope of Work 30 / 5- Presentation 5 3 Format 5 2 Uni ue Qualities 10 Total 100 U Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation) Comments: D c C-o,ae-- TOTAL U 0 Reviewer's Signature .CtiC<..c<ti' Contract Administrator's Initials Date Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: FORMA Design Inc. Reviewer: Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 ) Experience 25 / r. Scope of Work 30 ) Presentation 5 Format 5 Unique Qualities 10 Total 100 �5 Unique Qualities (Intang.ibles): (Explanation) -?7 Comments:__. •c.:�r,r� rrf�r�(i,�ri� I Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date TOTAL Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: FORMA Design Inc. Reviewer:,_ ¢ F0 Date: Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 Experience 25 I Scope of Work 30 Presentation 5 Format 5 a Unique Qualities 10 Total 100 Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation) Comments: I C, r s 1Z-nACnA n Reviewer's SignatureL Jil � Contract Administrator's Initials Date TOTAL f-7 Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: FORMA Design Inc. Reviewer Y i D re- Date: � iz�igg Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 20 Experience 25 zo Scope of Work 30 20 Presentation 5 Format 5 t� Unique Qualities 10 Total 100 71, Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation) pa 20S7, a0U &-dc�� f comments: J TOTAL r 6 Reviewer's Signature Jt Contract Administrator's Initials Date Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: The Altum Grouv Reviewer: Date: Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 Experience 25 Scope of Work 30 Presentation 5 S Format 5 Unique Qualities 10 Total 100 Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation) 3 r r ( r 1r'f--r2,-Cp,igs Comments: ,r�'`l S f_ arE, r.� �: C`��1 15 /�Sl� c, i„l� �UiG#� ■�;�z f i��J rr Y %CT rJ 1 Reviewer's Signature r� I 1 -1 Contract Administrator's Initials Date TOTAL q- Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: The Altum Group Reviewer: Date• m-)n 1 1q� Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 �k3 Experience 25 Scope of Work 30 1 Presentation 5 Format 5 L-1 Unique Qualities 10 to Total 100 -80 Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation) C) t%o `��? � r._L, fst�ry ► Comments: TOTAL Reviewer's Signatu Contract Administrator's Initials Date Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: The Altum Grou Reviewe Ir Date: I l 2 Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 23 Experience 25 / Scope of Work 30 22r Presentation 5 �f Format 5 3 Unique Qualities 10 Total 100 -78 Unique Qualities (Intangibles): , (Explanation) opt c,",Q 7 A4 r i n �r c� y4+�r v e.0 �► comments: (ASS t., pL)'t t.-r c corna- TOTAL - `" Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Torti Gallas and Partners Reviewer; Date: //- ) -Z) -,, Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 zz Experience 25 Z"2- Scope of Work 30 27 Presentation 5 Format 5 Unique Qualities 10 —3 Total 100 7q Unique Qualities (Intangible). X) (Explanation) Comments, 7" Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date TOTAL Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway III Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Torti Gallas and Partners Reviewer: •� f' i =•- Date; —1 � l Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 c Experience 25 Scope of Work 30 Presentation 5 Format 5 3 Unique Qualities 10 Total 100 .% — Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation). Comments:_ctr' �` � c am ` ma c; ::j:� €'tNeu ►r;a G7c.A�1` C IC. E TOTAL Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Torti Gallas and Partners Reviewer: C)AeX i 'F 1 orP—S Date: Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 Experience 25 23 Scope of Work 30 Presentation 5 Format 5 3 Unique Qualities 10 Total 100 1 72- Unique Qualities (Intangibles): r (Explanation) Z f",6,r Comments: r '20 J TOTAL 2 Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: MIG Reviewer: Date: Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 j Experience 25 Scope of Work 30 Presentation 5 Format 5 Unique Qualities 10 Total 100 Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation) hex, ip n14 *1 i , 1), �b 5-;7L �X-f a 06 t-4 2 1 Comments: 14TSV�, 1 6-ei& - Ale 1A 4 a,( Z -k- r U 2- /Voy-v Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date TOTAL Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: MIG Reviewer: , I .tom. Date: \j 9-7 1 ib Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 1 Experience 25 Scope of Work 30 I�1 Presentation 5 Format 5 3 Unique Qualities 10 a Tota 1 100 Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation) Comments: tR. b i l �20t4�j titer �-A TOTAL - Le I_ Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: M�I�G" Reviewer: Date: Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 20 Experience 25 Scope of Work 30 22 Presentation 5 Format 5 Unique Qualities 10 Total 100 Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation Comments: a-v�e-f- TOTAL '� (�9 Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway III Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Kimley Horn Reviewer: Date:—//- Z-0 Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 Experience 25 Scope of Work 30 Presentation 5 Format 5 Unique Qualities 10 Total 100 Unique Qualities (In, ngibles)-.-- (Explanation) is 61 5 Comments: A(',-4 11-JI-all ZIA& (19 r<. 10 -j Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date TOTAL Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway Ill Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Kimley Horn Reviewer: Date: Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 71 Experience 25 2C' Scope of Work 30 l i Presentation 5 Format 5 Unique Qualities 10 Total 100 l.015 Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation) _ Comments: Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date M TOTAL l.P R Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Kimley Horn Reviewer: LvIc v I o►'e Date: Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 Experience 25 / f3 Scope of Work 30 �3 Presentation 5 Format 5 Unique Qualities 10 Tota 1 100 Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation) Comments: TOTAL (t2j Reviewer's Signature J Contract Administrator's Initials Date Scoring Breakdown: REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Michael Baker International Reviewer: =1 Date:— Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and A rp oach 25 c Experience 25 � I Scope of Work 30 2 O Presentation 5 Format 5 j Unique Qualities 10 y _ Total 100 Z Unique Qualities (Intangibles): p1r - (Explanation) Comments:�� TOTAL Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway 111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Michael Baker International Reviewer: s' Date: , 7 l k Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 C-)4 Experience 25 01, Scope of Work 30 Presentation 5 Format 5 Unique Qualities 10 Total 100 Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation) L3�:f "r0 C: Comments: 1 P., TOTAL Reviewer's Signature Contract Administrator's Initials Date REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION Highway-111 Corridor Area Plan Consultant: Michael Baker International Reviewer: e-� Q Date: 21 IT Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet. Understanding and Approach 25 20 Experience 25 ! Scope of Work 30 20 Presentation 5 Format 5 Unique Qualities 10 Total 100 Unique Qualities (Intangibles): (Explanation) G•c k,W rr. f 4un0 „IVewI.- Comments: 600G( WGC.ra�-' dt ,io ° 3 f Yr Pil f �� — �-�f!.A-1 � drri TOTAL Reviewer's Signature ( Contract Administrator's Initials Date