Rating SheetsREQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION
City of La Quinta Construction Management Services for SilverRock Pak
Venue Site, Project No. 2016-08
Consultant: Z�Z CG�s�GT��s
Reviewer:
Date: s
r
Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet.
Experience and Qualifications
- 30
c�
Staffing and Scope of Work*0M1,1c1NS
s 25
77-5-
Understanding and Approach T1loto�s-I/We
� 20
Z c.?
Cost rV o+
-
.✓ ff
Unique Qualities
10
Presentation/Format
5
3
Total a
Unique Qualities (Intangibles): Gam`
(Explanation) UGC
v � 1-- -4 4-ei�7
-r-1z=Z7-r-- ---76�
7L s
'vas �L,�,�r/ati5 � Cs7W�r�
Comments: ��7 S �� �•�r�./��E-ACC`.
4/ S� v
,I elf
Reviewer's Signature
-,' v1T �I
0
TOTAL v::517
Contract Administrator's Initials
Date
REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION
City of La Quinta Construction Management Services for SilverRock Pak
Venue Site, Project No. 2016-08
Consultant: �� Lon.�v��ihS
Reviewer•
Date:
Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet.
Experience and Qualifications
30
? 7
Staffing and Scope of Work
25
23
Understanding and Approach
20
Cost
10
Unique Qualities
10
Presentation/Format
5
1
Total
100
Unique Qualities (Intangibles):
(Explanation)
Comments:
TOTAL I
Reviewer's Signature
Contract Administrator's Initials Date
REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION
r
City of La Quinta Construction Management Services for SilverRock Pak
Venue Site, Project No. 2016-08
Consultant: Z- & k CON s- VTry VOT!
Reviewer: ► :N
Date • a /+ -011
Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet.
Experience and Qualifications
30
3 e
Staffing and Scope of Work
25
zr
Understanding and Approach
20
Ld
Cost
10
Unique gualities
10
ao
Presentation/Format
5
S
Total
100
y o
Unique Qualities (Intangibles): /
(Explanation) Ita cre7r¢i+r`6��re.rr� ]n•rrrCT. ■n. �`u la��D/ ewsr i■wft,) /
Comments: JO4ase' * st4riricA41r tJK` pore-) iN psvll'W +f WAO)d
7,4 Dr-��J++t� I rd• arP7�C F/4�� �Mrh+e�s �r+"f/JQ"(l'�
TOTAL I
Reviewer's Signature
Contract Administrator's Initials Date
REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION
City of La Quinta Construction Management Services for SilverRock Pak
Venue Site, Project No. 2016-08
Consultant: 7 *'V- ( ,in6Ul�am-S
Reviewer:
Date:
Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet.
Experience and Qualifications
30
3 0
Staffing and Scope of Work
25
23
Understanding and Approach
20
\ 5
Cost
—fib---
Unique Qualities
10
2
Presentation/Format
5
Total
100
Unique Qualities (Intangibles):
(Explanation) FA&N
-7S
Comments: FV0V CU B t
►'17711�* [� Q��XI 1Q� %Ql�u �C�12S p ru v� 51n� s . p1C;1 IriQt ty\
tanMy5k 'W' 1n d ic�c�
Cc -75
TOTAL
L
Reviewer's Signature
Contract Administrator's Initials Date
REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION
City of La Quinta Construction Management Services for SilverRock Pak
Venue Site, Project No. 2016-08
Consultant: T,(,Jp�� "
Reviewer: �09��' �T
Date:
Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet.
Experience and Qualifications
30
'Z S
Staffing and Scope of Work
25
Z O
Understanding and Approach
20
zo
Cost/.q-
11-1/k
Uni ue Qualities
10
Presentation/Format
5
, s
Total d
-=I=
1 -7 E . -5-
Unique Qualities (Intangibles):
(Explanation)
p � � S �� /3c�� � 55v �S J�/,mod ;✓�%G�<5 1�,¢'J`�'�-- -' �
Comments: Z� 5 d/' .�-�� LpC�t ��S 4,1-CZ7
/ice %L��v y % , �; i[>� +�J = �. ✓�✓ /�"d S
�2 If 7J Viz" -T�r�a v •✓yam cJ r��/,,/ .
TOTAL
Reviewer's Signature
Contract Administrator's Initials Date
REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION
City of La Quinta Construction Management Services for SilverRock Pak
Venue Site, Project No. 2016-08
Consultant: 1y
e
7
Reviewer• �l/4O
Date:
Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet.
Experience and Qualifications
30
Z;5
Staffing and Scope of Work
25
2 0
Understanding and Approach
20
/ 7
Cost
10
Unique Qualities
10
1 7
Presentation/Format
5
Total
100
Unique Qualities (Intangibles): ff
(Explanation) o/31E 57��71 - "J DUI; ? ✓� ��F
GG I� //, f
Comments: ��C' 1 F' a�U Si /uPr
TOTAL
Reviewer's Signature
Contract Administrator's Initials Date
REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION
r
City of La Quinta Construction Management Services for SilverRock Pak
Venue Site, Project No. 2016-08
Consultant: bw, r k
Reviewer: 0-ti eti
Date• -%/ 1-7/ t g
Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet.
Experience and Qualifications
30
I�
Staffing and Scope of Work
25
1 L
Understanding and Approach
20
Cost
10
0
Unique Qualities
10
a
Presentation/Format
5
5-
Total
100
Unique Qualities (Intangibles):
(Explanation) +rF tLr ct-a rr• s-t rxrrrt,rwt ir a.._+-rri r.r ry rrnFF- A to Loerr4
. tr A r tt ! r a f+ S l
)o7i�l wtron0, NO p+ipprjr 1'�ANa!►rMVW%/ Na / aFrrC-1ON
Comments: Orr r e.r <Lars !4 i R..!-:i At-#VAp1 f-ew A000 C-%K 4
oyy%-7 0+1ArWA&rr. — owo,wdr/Rr'r4VA. IrxPri.rW-e MAJWRf'r� I �rrI igtoO-1• wrrrr ?AP%kS,
rA r rgr ry r1 1.1 ar oe r ' A w %n o rP6 EqoA i i.► r
TOTAL —��
Reviewer's Signature
Contract Administrator's fnitials Date
REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION
City of La Quinta Construction Management Services for SilverRock Pak
Venue Site, Project No. 2016-08
Consultant: 0V 1 k--
Reviewer: Y1 S2C-Ivup—w
Date: 9— I-]-zQkc 1
Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet.
Experience and Qualifications
30
Staffing and Scope of Work
25
2()
Understanding and Approach
20
5
Cost
Uni ue Oualities
10
3
Presentation/Format
5
5
Total
100
Unique Qualities (Intangibles):
(Explanation) �n uJcs PaYt o� S�lye�r C�2d1 /66NCOuvl;�
oy\:5 u Cklf] h .
Comments: W vb4A►n Wf5 OV\ at'W ro aft.
1,30k cu3e i5 n In +p�G�r. '�Itia..a ry '�b� Co�xaC[r�ahv. a
WN1ln
TOTAL -77�V— lLO J
Reviewer's Signature
Contract Administrator's Initials Date
REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION
City of La Quinta Construction Management Services for SilverRock Pak
Venue Site, Project No. 2016-08
Consultant: / �yJ—�' ����s�a� S.
Reviewer: ��,✓q•Ci> �- ST Sr9`-'-L
Date:
Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet.
Experience and Qualifications
30
7 P
Staffing and Scope of Work
25
Understanding and Approach
20
Z o
Cost N �i
--Z46�
N//g-
Uni ue Qualities
10
Presentation/Format
5
-5�—
Total
r14€m-
1 sm—
Unique Qualities (Intangibles):
(Explanation)
Comments:�`��,
<
TOTAL
Reviewer's Signature
Contract Administrator's Initials Date
A
REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION
City of La Quinta Construction Management Services for SilverRock Pak
Venue Site, Project No. 2016-08
Consultant:
Reviewer:
Date:
Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet.
Experience and Qualifications
30
1? �,
Staffing and Scope of Work
25
Z 3
Understanding and Approach
20
lY
Cost
10
Unique Qualities
10
1 %
Presentation/Format
5
Total
100
LSD
Unique Qualities (Intangibles):
(Explanation) �/a �cGC ���Sl /f-7-f
Comments:
�r��
{ �rr�' �rf ,
. -��/ �7JttC
Reviewer's Signature
TOTAL 8 l
Contract Administrator's Initials
Date
REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION
r
City of La Quinta Construction Management Services for SilverRock Pak
Venue Site, Project No. 2016-08
Consultant: ?P-oJ c1-T D 1MC'N S)brJ S
Reviewer: uaA�.ne pYON
Date: '� �'► 9
Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet.
Experience and Qualifications
30
Is -
Staffing and Scope of Work
25
zo
Understanding and Approach
20
2.0
Cost
10
d
Unique Qualities
10
i&P
Presentation/Format
5
S
Total
100
g�
Unique Qualities (Intangibles):
(Explanation) ;,wr..•toSJ 3,r1%Qatrs Ir-P L64&1?, �,Wr'Pei[.�vft0.Y
Comments: a.,r a f-y,,,,.3F rar, r R, r N L ir w,T re rAA.k r / RIr6i 7*'cW OlAr &*P-W-0;L1irM.0
Ar OrNfl- PAFKr it A#+VA /
TOTAL so
Reviewer's Signature
Contract Administrator's Initials Date
REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION
City of La Quinta Construction Management Services for SilverRock Pak
Venue Site, Project No. 2016-08
Consultant: k G+ glry nslons
Reviewer: 6552 GwQA,,%
Date: 01-1I--TONR
Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet.
Experience and Qualifications
30
`C
Staffing and Scope of Work
25
20
Understanding and Approach
20
LI
Cost
Unique Qualities
10
Presentation/Format
5
Cj
Total
100
Unique Qualities (Intangibles):
(Explanation)
Ybv\&& A l 0 Y
�a�-•z�er o�2ySaw S�lUerr�-oc� �
r,�,6(jcc Y\,* i►tiGkvkd
U 7-
Comments: ��\6LV- ynykui,&l keshwYA kvwwo�,V. sub 0%-C-r— �nok-
TOTAL (-o2-
Reviewer's Signature
Contract Administrator's Initials Date
REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION
City of La Quinta Construction Management Services for SilverRock Pak
Venue Site, Project No. 2016-08
Consultant:
Reviewer:
Date: �}
Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet.
Experience and Qualifications
30
5
Staffing and Scope of Work
25
Z
Understanding and Approach
20
O
Cost
N
Unique Qualities
10
1—Z
Presentation/Format
5
Total
Unique Qualities (Intangibles):
(Explanation) a2 CAL
Comments:
l CG- - t V T S.g-T/S.�/cam �. / � j� L�/S Gt��/EC d�X&V_a1,Z
� tis ; ti�rv-ems
TOTAL
6-
Reviewer's Signature
Contract Administrator's Initials Date
REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION
City of La Quinta Construction Management Services for SilverRock Pak
Venue Site, Project No. 2016-08
Consultant:
Reviewer: '
Date:
Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet.
Experience and Qualifications
30
Staffing and Scope of Work
25
_70
Understanding and Approach
20
/b
Cost
10
Unique Qualities
10
Presentation/Format
5
Total
100
S Y
Unique Qualities (Intangibles): _
(Explanation) , -j i_'f u v,,! - ��D ��"- S %? 2[
Comments:
rj
f`i'.ct (`'. :f'�� �' —✓'J' .� f��&)/1, 1�([ �(�S
TOTAL S�
Reviewer's Signature
Contract Administrator's Initials Date
REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION
r
City of La Quinta Construction Management Services for SilverRock Pak
Venue Site, Project No. 2016-08
Consultant: roC ee0%T0,4^(-ale►+ 1V43rCC.TkDP%b ►,r-.1f.Ae&.r0,Lr
Reviewer: utA�po p�da
Date:
Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet.
Experience and Qualifications
30
io
Staffing and Scope of Work
25
S
Understanding and Approach
20
S
Cost
10
v
Unique Qualities
10
Z
Presentation/Format
5
Total
100
Z
Unique Qualities (Intangibles):
(Explanation) cxvsa. % u c ,, rip lm*+ 6kj f'M r-rv,&r
Comments:A9- aE r•�rOc.2'_if0!L% 1U AWAY cF rah.-h,.r•� arR,-to 4Lr
TOTAL 23
Reviewer's Signature
-1-1
Contract Administrator's Initials Date
REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION
City of La Quinta Construction Management Services for SilverRock Pak
Venue Site, Project No. 2016-08
Consultant: GC COMS� a h T ���� t-A
Reviewer:
Date:
Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet.
Staff
Unique Qualities (Intangibles):
(Explanation) Eu?�rIeAACQ- ]eCk
Chp *AZA wv16UA
4-- CCGt rok pro�cKQ d
q-2—
Comments: '��a� Ylc7't �vlly�y �F�. aoQS riot 2 pwpy `� C@'ec
Cr7rr3�ffGm Q
TOTAL / Z
Reviewer's Signature
Contract Administrator's Initials Date
REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION
City of La Quinta Construction Management Services for SilverRock Pak
Venue Site, Project No. 2016-08
Consultant: I— Z .1�
Reviewer:
Date:
Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet.
Experience and Qualifications
30
Zd
Staffing and Scope of Work
25
S
Understanding and Approach
20
Cost No /,,4-/�-
Uni ue Qualities
10
Presentation/Format
5
Total
100
3
Unique Qualities (Intangibles):
(Explanation) N 's N��
i
Comments: �� S
r G r� Q•`3
Z s ��
Reviewer's Signature
cie=
-
TOTAL 5 S
Contract Administrator's Initials
Date
REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION
City of La Quinta Construction Management Services for SilverRock Pak
Venue Site, Project No. 2016-08
Consultant•
Reviewer:
Date:
Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet.
Experience and Qualifications
30
ZG
Staffing and Scope of Work
25
23
Understanding and Approach
20
/
Cost
10
Unique Qualities
10
Presentation/Format
5
Total
100
7
Unique Qualities (Intangibles):
(Explanation) _
Comments:
TOTAL
Reviewer's Signature
Contract Administrator's Initials Date
,,.
REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION
r
City of La Quinta Construction Management Services for SilverRock Pak
Venue Site, Project No. 2016-08
Consultant: 'A P, cR«a ?r- C, cI c.
Reviewer:_ u ,Lo. _.Yow_
Date• -kh-� /m
Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet.
Experience and Qualifications
30
zs
Staffing and Scope of Work
25
Lo
Understanding and Approach
20
157
Cost
10
0
Unique Qualities
10
f
Presentation/Format
5
S
Total
100
70
Unique Qualities (Intangibles):
(Explanation) /,ox-P4r t�.P6L W-VJt. A U- 4xs-7-t a F ^ Ps1tife-IC
Comments: QCJF&ILI
s-JVCV J✓
MAA.nCrP-
N7 A^00 &A OJOY& A /HMO WA7J-A 4�
titi&A. ice/
/rsw f r M0T tD
rdAX IMI• -rAA-*i
A#/4r
AMY AX IBC i —JOL 07'10NI Zia/► rb cAal0.
fAt7��+}'Mr rR
L-nAYj.r E"'iYP4'-c"r�'
! GhY.w
N1i�A
Reviewer's Signature
Contract Administrator's Initials Date
TOTAL ? o
REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION
City of La Quinta Construction Management Services for SilverRock Pak
Venue Site, Project No. 2016-08
Consultant: H- G7r" ?2GTlC, _
Reviewer: lnyAaSa
Date: q -I 1 - 2t Wg
Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet.
Experience and Qualifications
30
5o
Staffing and Scope of Work
25
25
Understanding and Approach
20
►-1
Cost
Unique Qualities
10
Presentation/Format
5
5
Total
100
— S:!;
Unique Qualities (Intangibles):
(Explanation) r—Y\t? VCyz)odS \ arASCNX \jcanse. Oqw S' W
1 IZa
Is
Comments: C)NC-Q hot- kbG:a\ [ k \nSV?Gk1X 1s i ocal,
TOTAL S S
Reviewer's Signature 6,�—
Contract Administrator's Initials Date
51
1,
REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION
City of La Quinta Construction Management Services for SilverRock Pak
Venue Site, Project No. 2016-08
Consultant: / L
Reviewer:�",�" �T
Date• C5
Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet.
Experience and Qualifications
30
145-
--Staffing and Scope of Work// S 9.✓eW53
25
/3
Understanding and Approach
20
) S
Cost
Unique Qualities '
10
Presentation/Format
5
3
f Total
p
Unique Qualities (Intangibles):
(Explanation) L`- 611
7-0
Comments:
't /��
r►J
Reviewer's Signature
Contract Administrator's Initials
S ��a ~:L11/1.5 I S
a�
TOTAL
Date
REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION
City of La Quinta Construction Management Services for SilverRock Pak
Venue Site, Project No. 2016-08
Consultant: A) �J-5
Reviewer:
Date:
Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet.
Experience and Qualifications
30
2Y
Staffing and Scope of Work
25
�7 1
Understanding and Approach
20
Cost
10
Unique Qualities
10
Presentation/Format
5
11
Total
100
J 77
Unique Qualities (Intangibles):
(Explanation)
Comments:
/A rJ: .%f r1
TOTAL
Reviewer's Signature
Contract Administrator's Initials Date
_r
REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION
r
City of La Quinta Construction Management Services for SilverRock Pak
Venue Site, Project No. 2016-08
Consultant: NV 5 1.,
Reviewer: ua 3 or -
Date: -1J 1? 11
Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet.
Experience and Qualifications
30
to
Staffing and Scope of Work
25
20
Understanding and Approach
20
it
Cost
10
b
Unique Qualities
10
Z
Presentation/Format
5
s
Total
100
6
Unique Qualities (Intangibles):
(Explanation) tmvw,vw,r r.^H,.; iIvA f. ra.•rrA.ucr rr� PA adri7Y./
lA+. rTiM r! S`&..& JsY / 49-4
Comments: w.4wcr rrr/r'1tIr,.•4r wor/f Pa,oi+ft7AT1•rr hN• ijr-r r-ATIIM3�
/�• 7r' 4 (+T' aF' PAJOr' aF AANy r-6 A P) NA f^dJr-f-T.f fo /l /a.,isrLl 70r-
TOTAL :,%'
Reviewer's Signature
Contract Administrator's Initials _ Date
I
REQUEST FOR PROPSAL EVALUATION
City of La Quinta Construction Management Services for SilverRock Pak
Venue Site, Project No. 2016-08
Consultant: NV 5 r Tr C,
Reviewer: ®Y1S52 C Yv�4,\
Date:
Refer to Scoring Breakdown on next sheet.
Experience and gualifications
30
30
Staffing and Scope of Work
25
1
Understanding and Approach
20
117
Cost
Uni ue Qualities
10
2
Presentation Format
5
Total
100
Unique Qualities (Intangibles):
(Explanation) 6CCt�v'5 V k OLC6
Comments: YYIx.k cJ125
Reviewer's Signature
V;&a
TOTAL V q--7(,P
Contract Administrator's Initials Date