CAPER (RDA) FY 2005-2006a aA& %&"dapnent
C
P.O. Box 1504
78-495 CALLE TAMPICO (7 60) 777-7000
LA QUINTA, CALIFORNIA 92253 FAX (760) 777-7101
July 7, 2006
Mr. Allan P. Bayer, Development Specialist
RIVERSIDE COUNTY EDA
Housing Rehabilitation and Ownership Division
P. O. Box 4637
Riverside, California 92514
Via Facsimile and First Class Mail
(909) 352-4852
CITY OF LA QUINTA REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY
Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report.(CAPER) Housing Activities:
Attached is the CAPER report of housing activities by the La Quinta Redevelopment Agency for the July 1, 2005 to
June 30, 2006 reporting period. You will find the sections listed below attached to this letter:
Attachment 1
- Narrative, Sections I through IX
- Residential Rehabilitation loan detail
Table 1 - Households & Persons Assisted
- Summary: all programs
- Program: La Quinta Housing Program — (home purchase loans)
- Program: La Quinta Housing Program — (residential rehabilitation loans)
- Program: La Quints Rental Housing
- Program: Hadley Villas Senior Apartments
- Program: Silverhawk Apartments
Attachment 2
- Narrative
- Project Area Map
If you have any questions regarding the content of this report, please contact the Agency's housing consultant,
Becky Caha of Rosenow Spevacek Group (RSG) at (714) 541-4585 extension 105.
Very truly yours,
CITY A Q'Ut�
s A
oug E s
Comm ity Development Director
Enclosures
cc: Frank Spevacek, RSG
CITY OF LA OUINTA REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY
ATTACHMENT 1
CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL PERFORMANCE AND EVALUATION REPORT HOUSING ACTIVITIES; July 1,
2005 - June 30, 2006
Homeownership Programs for First -Time Homebuyers and Lower -Income (under 80% of median)
Households. The Agency continues to provide homeownership opportunities to lower income households
through the La Quinta Housing Program, the sale of Agency -owned rental units. Although the programs
are not restricted to first-time homebuyers, the majority of those who qualify for and purchase homes
through these programs are first-time buyers.
To assist in their efforts to provide affordable home ownership to lower-income households, the Agency
has provided home purchase second trust deed loan assistance since the 1996-97 fiscal year through the
La Quanta Housing Program. The Agency loans fund the difference between the maximum first loan a
buyer can obtain and the purchase price less the minimum required 3% down payment. During this
reporting period, households with incomes of up to 50% of median could receive up to 60% of the purchase
price less down payment and those having incomes from 51% to 80% of median could receive up to
$85,000, from the Agency toward their home purchase. The program also provides loans of up to $40,000
to moderate income households to assist in their home purchase. The Agency loans do not require
monthly payments. Those funded have recorded 45 years affordability covenants and a resale restriction
pursuant to AB 637. If the owner is unable to sell the property, the Agency has right of first refusal before
agreeing to removal of the unit from its affordable housing stock and sale at market rates. In this event, the
Agency loan must be repaid along with a shared appreciation percentage in lieu of interest on the loan.
This Program has been funded annually since 1996 and has assisted a total of 228 households with an
opportunity for home ownership, 15 during the current reporting period.
The Agency -owned rental properties described in Section V below are rented to tenants having incomes
at 50% or less of County median income. Those who have been able to improve their work opportunities
and qualify for a first mortgage loan are also eligible for assistance in'the purchase of their home through
an Agency funded second trust deed loan. To date, 22 properties have been sold through this program
and the loans remain available to the other tenants.
Rehabilitation and Neighborhood Improvement Programs. The La Quinta Housing Program, the
Agency acquires abandoned, dilapidated single family properties. After substantially rehabilitating the
structure and upgrading the landscaping, the properties are sold as affordable units to income -eligible
households. There was no activity during the current reporting period.
II. Housing for Farmworkers and Migrant Farmworkers. The Agency has not provided housing
opportunities that specifically address these housing needs, although many of its resources have been
devoted to households earning less than 50% of County median income. Many City residents are
employed in the agricultural industry and have been the recipients of assistance through other Agency -
sponsored affordable housing programs.
III. Shelter for the Homeless. The Agency has not provided a program dedicated to this issue. Because of
the size of the City of La Quinta and its geographic location, homelessness is not as great a problem as it is
in other areas.
IV. Rental Assistance Programs. In 1995, the Agency purchased fifty (50) single family homes which were
rented to very low income, Section 8 assisted households when the owner/developer filed bankruptcy; the
28 homes that have not been sold to the existing tenants have continued to be rented to very low income
households at an affordable rent. The Agency contracts for property management services and
maintenance of the units. The units have all received exterior renovation, which includes new paint,
landscaping, driveway renovation, and fencing renovation to maintain the properties in a similar condition to
other, owner -occupied properties, and to qualify them as substantially rehabilitated.
V. New Construction of Affordable Rental Housing. Through a developer Affordable Housing Agreement
executed in October, 2002, the Agency assisted in the construction of senior housing rental units for the
Hadley Villas. Construction has been completed on these units during this reporting period. The
agreement requires 81 units be rented to very low income senior citizens. During the current reporting
period, 79 units were rented by very low income senior citizens.
Through a developer Affordable Housing Agreement executed in June, 2003, the Agency assisted in the
construction of the Silverhawk Apartments located at Eisenhower and Tampico. Construction has been
completed on these units during this reporting period. The agreement requires 75 units to be income
restricted to moderate income households. During this past reporting period 3 of the units were rented by
moderate income tenants.
VI. New Construction of Affordable Special Needs Housing. Please refer to Section VII above.
VII. Other Housing Programs. The Agency has entered into an agreement with CP Development for the
development of Center Point, a mixed-use (residential and commercial) project on Miles and Washington.
This project will have 40 residential units restricted for moderate income, and construction is anticipated to
commence in fall 2006.
VIII. Use of Redevelopment Housing Set -Aside Fund:
Fund Balance on July 1, 2005: $ 18,114,435.00
Total Deposits — 7/1/05 — 6/30/06: $ 15,840,998.00
Total Expenditures — 7/1/05 — 6/30/06: $[18,112,468.00]
Fund Balance on June 30, 2006: $ 15,842,962.00 (unaudited)
CITY OF LA QUINTA REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY ATTACHMENT 2
CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL PERFORMANCE AND EVALUATION REPORT HOUSING ACTIVITIES; July 1,
2005 - June 30, 2005
A. Resources Made Available Within the Jurisdiction
During this reporting period, the La Quinta Redevelopment Agency (the "Agency') expended $12,319,912 in direct
assistance from its Low and Moderate Income Housing Fund to fund the implementation of eight (8) active
affordable housing programs. The Agency'has not used other funding sources in meeting their affordable housing
goals.
The Agency contracts with a redevelopment and housing consulting firm to formulate and implement its affordable
housing programs and ensure the programs and residents are afforded professional assistance on housing related
issues. By working closely with City and Agency staff, the entire project team is able to proactively address and
meet community needs.
Every program that was projected for implementation during the current reporting period has moved forward even
though the funds that were allocated were not fully expended due to the lengthy time periods involved in new
construction to meet the Agency's inclusionary housing requirements, real estate acquisition efforts and property
refurbishment programs.
B. Investment of Available Resources
The Agency's adopted current affordable housing programs address many of the goals the County has defined in
their Consolidated Plan, including homeownership opportunities, improvement of substandard housing, and
conditions of existing rental housing affordable to low income households.
(Program definition) The Agency's affordable housing efforts consist of the programs described below which
have provided assistance to approximately 1,048 very low, low and moderate income households since 1989:
• La Quinta Housing Program. When property values started declining throughout the State several years ago,
the Agency was faced with an aging housing stock in need of upgrading as well as an increasing number of
properties being abandoned through foreclosure when the owner was unable to sell. To address these
conditions and instances of neighborhood neglect, in addition to continuing its efforts to work with developers in
providing new affordable housing construction, the Agency adopted the La Quinta Housing Program (the
"Housing Program") in November, 1996. This program continues and is being made available in both Project
Areas No. 1 and No. 2. It incorporates the following elements to address the City's housing needs:
• second trust deed home purchase loans,
• Agency acquisition/rehabilitation/resale of dilapidated vacant homes, and
• Agency resale program.
The Home Purchase Loan element of this Program has been funded annually and has assisted a total of 228
households with an opportunity for home ownership, 19 during the current reporting period. The loans are not
restricted to first time homebuyers, but most of the families who receive loans are in fact first time homebuyers.
The Agency acquired 2 dilapidated single family homes in early 1998. One of the homes was too structurally
dilapidated for refurbishment and was subsequently demolished; this lot has been sold for development and will
be sold as an income restricted unit. The second home has been refurbished and was sold during the 2000-01
fiscal year as an affordable unit. The Agency is researching additional properties to be included in this
program.
The Agency additionally repurchases units which have previously received second trust loans and have
recorded affordability covenants when a foreclosure sale is imminent to preserve the affordability covenants.
After any needed repairs are made, the property is marketed and resold to another income eligible household
to preserve the existing affordability covenants.
• Developer Affordable Housing Agreements. Between 1992 and the end of the current reporting period, the
Agency assisted a total of 292 very low, low and moderate income households by providing a means for home
ownership, and provided affordable rental housing to 118 income eligible households through Affordable
Housing Agreements with for-profit and non-profit developers. Assistance was provided in the form of land
purchase costs, and "silent" second trust deed loans to the home purchaser. Affordable Housing Agreements
have been negotiated for the construction of several additional mixed-use housing projects.
During this reporting period, the 11th year of a program with Building Horizons was completed. In this program,
homes are constructed by the Boys and Girls Club of the Coachella Valley under expert construction
supervision and sold to income -eligible households. During this reporting period, there were two affordable
constructed during this reporting period. This program has now constructed a total of 21 affordable housing
units in Project Area No. 1.
• Sewer Connection Subsidy Program. Since 1989, the Agency has provided property owner assistance to
approximately 520 income eligible households through subsidy of the costs associated with a street
improvement assessment, abandonment of the septic tank system, and connection to the sewer lines. This
program was available in both Project Areas through the formation of assessment districts; it is expanded to
each assessment district as it is formed to provide City sewer service to residents. The program was
discontinued in March, 2003.
La Quinta Rental Housing Program. In 1995, the Agency purchased 50 single family homes which were
rented to very low income, Section 8 assisted households when the owner/developer filed bankruptcy; these
homes have continued to be rented to very low income households. Since that time, with Agency assistance in
the form of second trust deed home purchase loans, 3 vacant units were sold to eligible very low income
households and 19 additional units have been sold to the occupying tenants who have been able to secure first
mortgage financing. The remaining very low income tenants are being provided with an opportunity to
purchase the home they rent also through the provision of Agency funded second trust deed home purchase
loans.
These programs are funded annually and are located within the boundaries of Project Area No. 1 and Project Area
No. 2; a project area map is attached.
(Funding) This program and all other Agency -funded affordable housing programs are funded by the Agency's
Low and Moderate Income Housing Fund from set-aside tax increment revenue. The Agency has not utilized any
other or outside funding sources. Any budgeted funds not expended in a fiscal year are annually carried over and
added to the next year's funding allocation, ultimately providing 100% utilization of budgeted funds.
(Public Contact) The Agency actively utilizes its City staff as a liaison with the public to provide a high level of
public awareness regarding the assistance that is available to address their needs. By ensuring that Code
Enforcement, Building Department and Community Development personnel are aware of program availability, the
Agency utilizes its "first line" public contact to address individual property and property owner situations.
C. Households and Persons Assisted
The following Table 1 forms have been prepared for each of the Agency's housing programs that were funded and
provided assistance during the reporting period, along with a summary tabulating the results of the individual
programs.
LA UINTA REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY
Redevelopment Project Areas
Project Area 4 goundades mumri�rr 3 NOM
uJ
0
" 0
Molz
NOT
A
PART
I vi -AVENUE 44
?_X4
NJ I I [ I
HIGHWAY 111
L
1: AVENUE A8
Existing Proled Area No. 2
6089 1119111411 art AVENUE 50
Exisfing P10JO.cl Area No. 1
AVENUE 54
vull."upun 11,7. L' .
Lu
E 56
THE COVE z,_ . I_ L
0
uJ
77,
uJ
AVE
AVENUE 60 ------
The Agency maintains complete detail records for each of the affordable housing programs funded. These records
are maintained at the offices of the Agency's housing consultant, Rosenow Spevacek Group, 309 West 4th Street,
Santa Ana, California 92701. The contact person is Becky Caha, Associate, who can be reached at (714) 541-
4585 extension 105, or bcaha@webrsg.com .
During this reporting period, Agency assistance was provided to the programs and income categories identified in
the chart below:
Program
Total # Units
Very Low
Low
Moderate
2td Home Purchase Loans
15
0
3
12
Agency Rental Units
28
28
0
0
Rental Housing Sales
4
4
0
0
Hadley Villas
79
79 _
0
0
Silverhawk Apartments
33
0
1
32
TOTALS
159
111
4
1 44
The Agency's housing programs were not designed to address the needs of specific racial and/or ethnic groups,
but rather the community as a whole. The community is inhabited by a large number of households who provide
seasonal labor to the agricultural industry and who work in the tourism industry, which is also seasonally affected
due to the climate of the area.
The population in the City is generally evenly mixed between families and senior citizens, with a large number of
Hispanic households. As Indicated by the Racial/Ethnic composition statistics presented in Table 1, the Agency's
housing programs are serving the population in close proportion to the population characteristics of the area.
D. Other Actions Undertaken
As is evidenced by the number of programs and units assisted, the types of affordable housing programs, and the
level of funding allocated to affordable housing since 1989, both the Agency and City staff strive to maintain a high
level of awareness to the needs of the community. Responding to community needs has been and continues to be
a primary focus of the Agency. They have formulated an approach that provides affordable housing throughout the
City in both of the Redevelopment Project Areas, rather than in a particular neighborhood.
The Agency uses consultants to work as an extension of City staff who are experienced in formulating definitive
affordable housing programs that address and meet the needs of the community. These teams of City/consultant
staff implement and administer these programs, and strive to maintain an on-going relationship with the recipients
of the assistance and the community as a whole.
TABLE 1 - SUMMARY (all programs)
Households & Persons
Assisted with Housing, including Emergency Shelter and/or Supportive Services
Fiscal Year: 2005-2006
July 1, 2005 to June 30, 2006
form HUD- 0090-A (1193)
(A) Program Name:
(C) Total Funds Committed:
$29,737,485
(F) Funds Leveraged
ALL PROGRAMS
Amount: 9 0
Source(s):
(D) Funds Available (7-1-05 to 6-30-06):
$6,750,000
(B) Funding Source:
(G) Match
Source(s):
Low/Moderate Income Housing Fund
(E) Funds Expended (7-1-05 to 6-30-06):
$3,187,580
Amount: 1 0
Renters
Owners
Homeless*
Non -
Elderly
Small
Large
] st-Time Buyers
(H) Assistance Provided
Homeless
Total
by Income Group
& 2 Member
Related
Related
All Other
Total
Existing
with
Total
Individuals
Families
Special
Total
Section 215
Households
(2 to 4)
5 or more
Households
Renters
Homeowners
Children All Others Homeowners
Needs
(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
(E)
(F)
(G) (H)
(1)
(J)
(K)
(L)
(M)
(N)
1. Very Low -Income
(0 to 30% MFI)
22
22
22
0
2. Very Low -Income
(31 to 50% MFI)
57
16
12
85
4
0
4
89
0
3. Other Low -Income
(51 to 80% of MR)
0
1
I
1
2 1
3
4 1
0
4. Total Low -Income
(lines I +2+3)
79
17
12
108
5
2
7
115
0
5. Moderate Income
(81% to 120% of MFI)
0
32
32
12
0
0
12
44
0
*Homeless families and individuals assisted with transitional or permanent housing
Total
159
0
(I) Geographic Location
Banning
Murrieta
(J) Racial/Ethnic Composition
1. Hispanic
Number
68
%of Total
43%
Beaumont Norco 2. White
Blythe
Palm Desert
(Non -Hispanic)
71
45%
Calimesa
Perris
Canyon Lake
San Jacinto
3. Black
9
1 6%
Cathedral City Temecula
Desert Hot Springs
Indio
Other
(please list)
4. Native American
5. Asian &
Lake Elsinore
Riverside
Pacific Islander
8
5%
3
2%
La Quints
XX
Palm Springs
6. Other
7. Total
must equal Total on
159
100%
Iine 4, column (M)
TABLE 1
Fiscal Year: 2005-2006
Households & Persons July 1, 2005 to June 30, 2006
Assisted with Housing, including Emergencv Shelter and/or Supportive Services Fnr HtII]dnn4n-A(t/Q 1)
(A) Program Name:
(C) Total Funds Committed:
$13,580,877
(F) Funds Leveraged
La Quinta Housing Program -
(LQHP project total)
Amount: g 0
Source(s):
Home Purchase Loans
(D) Funds Available (7-1-05 to 6-30-06):
$3,000,000
(B) Funding Source:
(available for home purchase loans)
(G) Match
Source(s):
Low/Moderate Income Housing Fund
(E) Funds Expended (7-1-05 to 6-30-06):
$1,151,190
Amount: 9 0
Renters
Owners
Homeless •
Non -
Elderly
Small
Large
I st-Time Buyers
(H) Assistance Provided
Homeless
Total
by Income Group
& 2 Member
Related
Related
All Other
Total
Existing
with
Total
Individuals
Families
Special
Total
Section 215
Households
(2 to 4)
5 or more
Households
Renters
Homeowners
Children All Others Homeowners
Needs
(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
(E)
(F)
(G) (H)
(1)
(J)
(K)
(L)
(M)
(M
1. Very Low -Income
(0 to 30% MR)
2. Very Low -Income
(31 to 50% MRI)
4
4
4
0
3. Other Low -Income
(51 to 80% of MR)
1
2
3
4. Total Low -Income
(lines 1+ 2+ 3)
5
2
7
7
7
5. Moderate Income
(81 % to 120% of MF7)
12
12
12
0
* Homeless families and individuals assisted with transitional or permanent housing
TOW
19
7
(I) Geographic Location
Banning
Murrieta
(J) Racial/Ethnic Composition
l.. Hispanic
Number
12
%of Tonal
63%
Beaumont Norco 2. White
Blythe
Palm Desert
(Non -Hispanic)
4
21%
Calimesa
Perris
Canyon Lake
San Jacinto
3. Black
1
5%
Cathedral City
Desert Hot Springs
Indio
Lake Elsinore
Temecula
Other
(please list)
Riverside
4. Native American
5. Asian &
Pacific Islander
2
1 I%
La Quinta
XX
Palm Springs
6. Other
7. Total
must equal Total on
19
100%
line 4, column (M)
TABLE 1
Fiscal Year: 2005-2006
Households & Persons July 1, 2005 to June 30, 2006
Assisted with Housing, including Emergency Shelter and/or Supportive Services form Hl TD-4(Mn-A(1101)
(A) Program Name:
(C) Total Funds Committed:
$5,156,608
([') Funds Leveraged
La Quinta Rental Housing Program
Amount: 9 0
Source(s):
(D) Funds Available (7-1-05 to 6-30-06):
$500,000
(B) Funding Source:
(G) Match
Source(s):
Low/Moderate Income Housing Fund
(E) Funds Expended (7-1-05 to 6-30-06):
$436,390
Amount: 1 0
Renters
Owners
Homeless•
Non -
(H) Assistance Provided
Elderly
Small
Large
Ist-Time Buyers
Homeless
Total
by Income Group
& 2 Member
Related
Related
All Other
Total
Existing
with Total
Individuals
Families
Special
Total
Section 215
Households
(2 to 4)
5 or more
Households
Renters
Homeowners
Children All Others Homeowners
Needs
(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
(E)
(F)
(G) (H) (t)
(J)
(K)
(L)
(M)
(N)
1. Very Low -Income
(0 to 30% MFI)
2. Very Low -Income
(31 to 50% MFT)
16
12
28
28
3. Other Low -Income
(51 to 80% of MFI)
4. Total Low -Income
lines I + 2 + 3)
1
1 16
12
1
28
28
5. Moderate Income
(81 % to 120% of MFI)
* Homeless families and individuals assisted with transitional or permanent housing
Total
28
0
(I) Geographic Location
Banning
Murrieta
(J) Racial/Ethnic Composition
I. His anic
Number
12
%of Total
43%
9
32%
Beaumont
Blythe
Norco
Palm Desert
2. White
(Non -Hispanic)
Calimesa
Canyon Lake
Perris
San Jacinto
3. Black
6
21%
Cathedral City
Desert Hot Springs
Indio
Temecula
Other
(please list)
4. Native American
5. Asian &
Lake Elsinore
Riverside
Pacific Islander
La Quinta XX
Palm Springs
6. Other
1
4%
7. Total
must equal Total on
28
100%
line 4, column (M)
TABLE
Fiscal Year: 2005-2006
Households & Persons July 1, 2005 to lune 30, 2006
Assisted with Housing, including Emergency Shelter and/or Supportive Services form HUD -40090-A(1/93)
(A) Program Name:
(C) Total Funds Committed:
$9,500.000
(F) Funds Leveraged
Hadley Villas
Amount: $ 0
Source(s):
(D) Funds Available (7-1-05 to 6-30-06):
$2.500.000
(B) Funding Source:
(G) Match
Source(s):
Low/Moderate Income Housing Fund
(E) Funds Expended (7-1-05 to 6-30-06.):
$1,000,000
Amount: $ 0
Renters
Owners
Homeless s
Non -
Elderly
Small
Large
I st-Time Buyers
(H) Assistance Provided
Homeless
Total
by Income Group
& 2 Member
Related
Related
All Other
Total
Existing
with Total
Individuals
Families
Special
Total
Section 215
Households
(2 to 4)
5 or more
Households
Renters
Homeowners
Children All Others Homeowners
Needs
(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
(E)
(F)
((3) (H) (1)
(J)
(K)
(L)
(M)
(N)
1. Very Low -Income
(0 to 30% MFI)
22
22
2. Very Low -Income
(31 to 50% MFI)
57
57
3. Other Low -Income
(51 to 80% of MFI)
4. Total Low -Income
(tines I + 2 + 3)
79
79
5. Moderate Income
(81 % to 120% of MFI)
■ Homeless families and individuals assisted with tmnsirional or permanent housing
Total
79
Number
%of Total
(I) Geographic Location (,nRacial/Ethnic Composition
Banning
Murrieta
I. Hispanic
27
34%
Beaumont Norco 2. white
Blythe
Palm Desert
(Non -Hispanic)
47
59%
Calimesa Perris
Canyon Lake
San Jacinto
3. Black
2
3%
Cathedral City Temecula
Desert Hot Springs
Other
4. Native American
Indio (please list) 5. Asian &
Lake Elsinore
Riverside
Pacific Islander
3
4%
La Quinta XX Palm Springs
6. Other
7. Total
must equal Total on
79
100%
line 4, column (M)
TABLE
Fiscal Year: 2005-2006
Households & Persons July 1, 2005 to June 30, 2006
Assisted with Housing, including Emergency Shelter and/or Supportive Services form HUD -40090-A!1/911
(A) Program Name:
(C) Total Funds Committed:
$1.500,000
(F) Funds Leveraged
Silverhawk Apartments
Amount: $
0
Source(s):
(D) Funds Available (7-1-05 to 6-30-06):
$750,000
(B) Funding Source:
(G) Match
Source(s):
Low/Moderate Income Housing Fund
(E) Funds Expended (7-1-05 to 6-30-06):
$600.000
Amount: $
0
Renters
Owners
Homeless
Non -
(H) Assistance Provided
Elderly
Small
Large
1 st-Time Buyers
Homeless
Total
by Income Group
& 2 Member
Related
Related
All Other
Total
Existing
with Total
Individuals
Families
Special
Total
Section 215
Households
(2 to 4)
5 or more
Households
Renters
Homeowners
Children All Others Honvowners
Needs
(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
(E)
(F)
(G) (H) (1)
1 (J)
(K)
(L)
(M)
(N)
1. Very Low -Income
0 to 30% MFI
2. Very Low -Income
(31 to 50%, MFI)
3. Other Low -Income
(51 to 80% of MFI)
4. Total Low -Income
fines I + 2 + 3)
!
1
l
5. Moderate Income
(81 %i to 120% of MFI)
32
32
32
' Homeless familir-4 and individuals assisted with transitional or permanent housing
Total
33
(I) Geographic Location
Banning
Murrieta
(J) Racial/Ethnic Composition
1. H'ts anis
[Number
17
of Total
52%
33%
Beaumont
Blythe
Norco
Palm Desert
2. White
(Non -His anic)
-11
Calimesa
Perris
Canyon Lake
San Jacinto
3. Black
Cathedral City
Desert Hot Springs
Indio
Lake Elsinore
Temecula
Other
(please list)
Riverside
4. Native American
5. Asian &
Pacific Islander
3
9%
2
6%
La Quints
XX
Palm Springs
6. Other
7. Total
must equal Total on
33
100%
line 4, column (M)